Gonzalo E. Mon
Coterie Baby advertises that its diapers provide “up to 4x more absorbency” and “up to 3x drier skin” compared to “leading brands.” P&G, the maker of Pampers – one of the two leading brands of diapers – challenged this claim (among others) before NAD. One of the key questions in the case is what evidence is necessary to support an “up to” superiority claim involving multiple competitors.