In this episode, Aaron and Nathan continue their two-part conversation on AI and therapy—this time getting practical. Rather than debating whether AI should be used, they start from a clear position: AI cannot replace therapy. But when used wisely, it can support and strengthen the therapeutic process.
They explore how AI can function as a supplement to therapy—helping with normalization, psychoeducation, journaling, symptom tracking, and preparing for sessions—while also naming its clear limitations. You’ll hear why human therapy offers experiential knowledge, co-regulation, and real-time feedback that AI simply cannot replicate, and why screens can never replace being with another regulated human nervous system.
This episode also dives into:
The difference between informational knowledge and experiential healing
When gaining more information helps—and when it actually increases anxiety
How to use AI prompts intentionally to track patterns, not avoid emotions
Ways AI can help you clarify what to bring into therapy
Why skepticism, self-honesty, and boundaries matter when using AI
How journaling, normalization, and skill-building can be enhanced (but not replaced) by AI
If you’re already using AI—or considering it—this episode offers a grounded, human-centered framework for using it without outsourcing your healing.
Aaron Potratz & Nathan Hawkins are behavioral health experts, licensed counselors, and clinical supervisors with over 35 years of experience. They each own a private group therapy practice and co-own a third one together. Aaron is also a business consultant for therapists in private practice wanting to start, grow, or expand their business.
*Watch this episode: https://youtu.be/ayPgXJcvH1o
*Now on YouTube: @shrink-think
*Sign up for our FREE email course on overcoming fear and insecurity at:
https://www.shrinkthink.com/podcast
Member of the PsychCraft Podcast Network
https://psychcraftnetwork.com/
