Sometimes inviting a homeless person to join your band works out--case in point, Tyler's 7th favorite album. Tyler is adamant that All is not a punk band, even though 3/4 of the band were also in the Descendents. Eric finds fault in the album's production, but appreciates the number of songwriters contributing material to the album. Tucker is stoked because, well, it's punk! Dots are connected from Millencolin to the Replacements--play it loud.