Listen

Description

Does a 1998 state decision making 117 acres west of Bozeman a resort area give its owners a vested right to seek liquor licenses without regard to the city's quota, one the Legislature could not take away in 2021? The Gallatin County District Court said no and ruled for the State.

Brian Gallik argued on behalf of appellants Boardwalk Properties, Michael Delaney and Ileana Indreland. Matthew Cochenour argued on behalf of appellees State of Montana and Department of Revenue. District Judge Matthew Cuffe sat in place of Justice Beth Baker, and Justice Gustafson took part by video.

Listen for Justice McKinnon pressing Gallik on the cases that call a liquor license a privilege, the Chief Justice's golden ticket, Justice Bidegaray asking what benefit the designation still holds 1:08:22, and Justice Shea on what the owners have left without new licenses 1:18:12.

We predict the Court will affirm, though the argument made it closer than the precedent suggests. Based on the Court's average pace after oral argument, a decision can be expected between February and June 2027.

The full transcript of the argument, with each speaker named, is on lawformt.com.

Case number: DA 25-0537.

Oral argument before the Montana Supreme Court in Boardwalk Properties v. State (DA 25-0537), heard October 29, 2026.

A direct appeal (civil), from DV-16-2021-625 below, filed July 24, 2025.

Who argued:

Parties: State of Montana, Department of Revenue, Boardwalk Properties, Inc., Ileana Indreland, Michael Delaney.

No opinion has issued in this appeal.

Audio drawn from the Court's own video of the argument.

Briefs: Appellant's Opening · Appellee's Response · Appellant Reply

The law and its history: MCA § 16-4-213 · MCA § 16-4-202 · MCA § 16-4-201 · MCA § 16-4-401

The transcript of the argument, with who spoke

The case, its docket and every filing

Listen to more Montana Supreme Court oral arguments

Chapters: