Can consent be a defense to a prostitution charge in Montana? After a Bozeman police sting built around an online ad, Brian Edward Heck was charged with patronizing a prostitute. A Gallatin County District Court judge dismissed the charge before trial, reasoning that the Legislature's carve-outs for children and trafficking victims leave consent available to other adults. The State appealed.
Mardell Ployhar argued on behalf of appellant State of Montana. Nicholas Miller argued on behalf of appellee Brian Edward Heck.
Listen for Justices Gustafson and Shea asking why the consent statute names the prostitution statute at all, and Ployhar agreeing with Chief Justice Swanson that the Legislature wrote it badly 16:01. Listen for Justice Rice calling prostitution a consent-based crime, and for the State's concession about proving a lack of consent at trial 31:29. And listen for Justice Shea's three dispensaries on his way to the Copper King.
We predict the Court will reverse and send the charge back for trial. Based on the Court's average pace after oral argument, a decision can be expected between February and June 2027.
The full transcript of the argument, with each speaker named, is on lawformt.com.
Case number: DA 26-0015.
Oral argument before the Montana Supreme Court in State v. B. Heck (DA 26-0015), heard October 7, 2026, in Butte.
A direct appeal (criminal), from DC-23-337A below, filed January 5, 2026.
Who argued:
Parties: State of Montana, Brian Edward Heck.
No opinion has issued in this appeal.
Audio drawn from the Court's own video of the argument.
Briefs: Appellant's Opening · Appellee's Response · Appellant Reply
The law and its history: MCA § 45-5-601 · MCA § 45-2-211 · MCA § 45-5-701
The transcript of the argument, with who spoke
The case, its docket and every filing
Listen to more Montana Supreme Court oral arguments
Chapters: