A Cascade County jury convicted Robert Dan French of sexual intercourse without consent against a four-year-old girl. At trial she said she did not remember, so the conviction rests on her earlier statements to her parents and a forensic interviewer, which Montana law says must be independently corroborated. The Court affirmed in December, then granted rehearing, withdrew that opinion and heard the case again before the full Court.
Jeff Wilson, of the Appellate Defender Division, argued for appellant Robert Dan French. Mardell Ployhar argued for appellee State of Montana.
Listen for Justice Shea asking whether enough unreliable statements add up to a reliable one; Justice Baker telling the State its request to change the corroboration rule was not in its brief 41:37; Ployhar agreeing that the child's demonstration in her interview counts as a statement 42:45; and Wilson's rebuttal on State v. Giant, 2001 MT 245.
The question for the decision is whether the Court keeps Giant's bright-line rule and finds enough else in this record. Based on the Court's average pace after oral argument, a decision can be expected between July and November 2026.
The full transcript of the argument, with each speaker named, is on lawformt.com.
Case number: DA 23-0528.
Oral argument before the Montana Supreme Court in State v. R. French (DA 23-0528), heard March 4, 2026, in the Supreme Court courtroom.
A direct appeal (criminal), from BDC-19-280 below (Judge Elizabeth A. Best), filed September 15, 2023.
Who argued:
Parties: State of Montana, Robert Dan French.
Decided: 2025 MT 280 — Affirmed, written by Beth Baker on December 2, 2025.
Audio drawn from the Court's own video of the argument.
Briefs: Appellant's Opening · Appellee's Response · Appellant Reply
The law and its history: MCA § 3-15-405 · MCA § 46-16-702 · MCA § 46-16-112 · MCA § 26-1-102
The transcript of the argument, with who spoke
The case, its docket and every filing
Listen to more Montana Supreme Court oral arguments
Chapters: