Glasgow's assistant police chief posed online as a fourteen-year-old boy, using an app to make a photo of himself look younger. Ronald Kulczyk, convicted by a Valley County jury of two counts of sexual abuse of children and sentenced to 25 years with 20 suspended, argues that the AI-altered persona was not a person under the 2021 version of the statute, and that the 2025 amendment covering undercover officers proves the gap. He also claims outrageous government conduct, an involuntary Miranda waiver and an illegal sentence.
Jeremy Yellin argued on behalf of appellant Ronald William Kulczyk. Thad Tudor, an assistant attorney general, argued on behalf of appellee State of Montana.
Listen for Justice Shea's avatar and altered-photo hypotheticals, Tudor's account of what the 2025 amendment actually fixed 40:15, Justice Shea's distinction between an AI officer and an AI image of an officer, and Justice McKinnon asking whether the texts alone would have been enough 1:10:43.
We predict the Court will affirm. Based on the Court's average pace after oral argument, a decision can be expected between October 2026 and February 2027.
The full transcript of the argument, with each speaker named, is on lawformt.com.
Case number: DA 25-0099.
Oral argument before the Montana Supreme Court in State v. R. Kulczyk (DA 25-0099), heard June 25, 2026, in the Supreme Court courtroom.
A direct appeal (criminal), from DC-2022-027 below, filed February 4, 2025.
Who argued:
Parties: State of Montana, Ronald William Kulczyk.
No opinion has issued in this appeal.
Audio drawn from the Court's own video of the argument.
Briefs: Appellant's Opening · Appellee's Response · Appellant Reply
The law and its history: MCA § 45-5-625 · MCA § 45-2-101
The transcript of the argument, with who spoke
The case, its docket and every filing
Listen to more Montana Supreme Court oral arguments
Chapters: