Why Some Torah Laws were Meant to be Heard not followed
Live at the JCC’s new Shtiebel, Geoffrey Stern and Rabbi Adam Mintz ask: what do we learn from laws that never happened? From the rebellious son to Bialik’s Halakha and Aggada, discover halakhah as a language of Jewish life.
In this week's episode of Madlik, we delve into a fascinating exploration of Jewish law that challenges our conventional understanding of mitzvot (commandments). As we navigate through the complexities of Halakhah, we uncover a profound truth: sometimes, the most impactful lessons come not from observance, but from observing and listening.
Key Takeaways
- The Rebellious Son: A law that never was and never will be, yet teaches us volumes.
- Halakha as Language: How Jewish law communicates deeper truths beyond mere observance.
- Bialik's Perspective: The unexpected harmony between Halakha and Aggadah from a secular Jewish thinker.
Timestamps
- [00:00:37] Intro — recording live at the JCC Manhattan
- [00:01:42] Mitzvot as a cultural language, not just observance
- [00:02:56] The rebellious son in Deuteronomy 21 and its harsh punishment
- [00:04:13] Talmud: “There never was and never will be a rebellious son”
- [00:06:18] Death penalty framed as pedagogy vs deterrence
- [00:07:45] Fear as a teaching tool, like fairytales and folklore
- [00:08:32] The “idolatrous city” — another law never fulfilled
- [00:11:09] Reward in Torah study as outcome, not payment
- [00:15:47] Maimonides reduces 248 commandments to only 60 definite ones
- [00:20:36] Soloveitchik: Halakha as the language of Judaism
Links & Learnings
Sign up for free and get more from our weekly newsletter https://madlik.com/
Safaria Source Sheet: https://www.sefaria.org/sheets/672006
Transcript here: https://madlik.substack.com/
