• Tactical Missteps & Bullpen Usage
A New York Post piece highlights a glaring example: Boone used reliever Devin Williams in an extra-innings high-leverage spot despite Williams’ recent struggles—and it backfired, resulting in a key loss to the Astros. Critics argue this underscores Boone’s poor bullpen management.
• Soft Leadership & Public Defensiveness
Several commentators have criticized Boone’s “coddling” approach—suggesting that publicly defending underperforming players is eroding his credibility. One such article called his leniency “a disservice to his players, fans and even himself,” arguing that the teams and their fans deserve more accountability.
