Description

Send us Fan Mail

Rhode Island’s primary sprint, the Providence mayor’s race, and the shakeup in statewide politics

With early voting underway, Bill Bartholomew and Jim Hummel (The Hummel Report, Ocean State Media, WPRO) break down a Rhode Island primary that feels unusually compressed, low-energy, and wide open in several marquee races. They focus on the governor’s race, the Providence mayoral primary, and how turnout, apathy, and candidate organization could decide everything.We discuss why the governor’s race appears to be Helena Foulkes versus Dan McKee, why Providence mayor could be the most consequential contest on the ballot, and how the attorney general and lieutenant governor primaries are shaped by heavy uncertainty and weak candidate separation. The conversation also zooms out to the collapse of Rhode Island Republican infrastructure and the question of whether independent Ken Block can change the dynamics.

Key topics

• The primary feels like a sprint after a long buildup, with very little time to energize voters before election day.
• Hummel argues that apathy is the dominant force in this cycle, especially because many races feel either predetermined or hard to differentiate.
• In the governor’s race, Dan McKee is framed as carrying a long list of political liabilities, including the Washington Bridge, CVS/opioids, and general voter fatigue.
• Helena Foulkes is seen as holding a consistent polling advantage, with multiple polls showing her ahead by a meaningful margin.
• The Providence mayor’s race between incumbent Brett Smiley and challenger David Morales is described as the most interesting contest, with Morales bringing national attention and youthful energy.
• Smiley’s strength is his political infrastructure, especially his turnout operation and support from Eddie Catucci, who is described as a master of mail ballots and ground game.
• The lieutenant governor and attorney general primaries are portrayed as crowded and muddy, with lots of undecided voters and very little ideological separation.
• The discussion notes that gun policy and constitutional concerns may be pushing some Democratic voters away from more aggressive positions in the AG race.
• National anti-incumbent sentiment is seen as helping challengers broadly, but not necessarily translating cleanly to every local race.
• Rhode Island Republicans are described as deeply weakened, lacking a coherent bench, a strong message, or an effective opposition strategy.
• Aaron Guckian and the Republican gubernatorial field are viewed as weakly positioned, while the congressional races are portrayed as even more chaotic.
• Ken Block is treated as the most plausible wild card in the governor’s race, especially if he can consolidate support or benefit from a one-on-one dynamic.

Timestamps

(00:00) Opening the primary sprint and why this cycle feels flat
 (01:43) Why turnout and election-day energy matter more than usual
 (03:23) Providence mayor becomes the race to watch
 (05:36) McKee’s polling problem and the uphill climb in the governor’s race
 (06:23) What could help McKee and what still works against him
 (07:31) Smiley’s turnout machine versus Morales’ grassroots energy
 (08:42) Why the lieutenant governor and AG races are so unsettled
 (09:46) Little separation in the AG field and the gun policy divide
 (11:23) Does national anti-incumbent anger spill into Rhode Island?
 (13:14) What Providence schools and city management mean for Smiley
 (14:15) The collapse of the Rhode Island Republican ecosystem
 (15:55) Why the GOP congressional slate looks so weak
 (17:14) How Trump hollowed out the state party
 (19:41) Could Ken Block become the real governor’s race alternative?
 (21:55) Block’s media strategy and money challenge
 (22:25) Election day timing, early voting, and closing thoughts

Support the show

Follow Bill on Instagram and YouTube