How Great Were Rochester Lancers 1967–1971?
Where do the Rochester Lancers (1967–71) rank in the Table of Greatness — and what do they reveal about American soccer’s first great boom?
In this episode of By Far The Greatest Team, hosts Graham Dunn and Jamie Rooney are joined by esteemed US journalist Michael Lewis for an unforgettable journey through the early story of soccer in the United States — and the wild, wonderful era around the North American Soccer League (NASL).
We explore the meteoric rise of soccer’s popularity in the US, Michael Lewis’ journey as a journalist, and the pivotal role played by the Rochester Lancers in the league’s early identity. From memorable NASL moments to the epic playoff series between the Lancers and the Dallas Tornado, we dive into what made this period so addictive: intense rivalries, dirty play, chaotic logistics, and the brutal reality of travel in a sprawling country.
We also zoom out to the bigger picture: the influx of superstar names that grabbed headlines, the factors behind the league’s eventual downfall, and the alternate-history “what if” of the US hosting a World Cup in 1986.
In the final stretch, the episode turns into a wider football-history conversation as Michael Lewis shares firsthand memories from World Cups and the US World Cup bidding journey — illustrating how far American soccer had to travel from the NASL era to the modern game.
Where does Rochester Lancers 1967–71 land on the Greatness Index — not just as a team, but as a chapter in the origin story of US soccer culture?
Takeaways
🎧 Listen / Follow the podcast
Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/7erZQ9qQEsa2Xq8Rg843Gv
Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/by-far-the-greatest-team-football-podcast/id1678832405
Website: thegreatnessindex.com
✅ Subscribe for weekly football history — Shorts, Clips + video clips from the archive.
#SoccerHistory #NASL #RochesterLancers
If you enjoy these podcasts, please don't forget to subscribe and give us a rating and also tell everyone about them!
