Main Thesis
Lenny argues that God does not punish Christians. Distinction is drawn between punishment (a penalty for past sins, which Christ absorbed fully) and discipline (future-oriented training for growth). The episode asserts that viewing God as an angry punisher contradicts the New Covenant gospel of grace, where believers are fully reconciled and no longer have their sins counted against them.
Key Interpretations of Difficult Passages:
- Hebrews 6 & 10 (Falling Away & Willful Sinning): Lenny contends these warnings are not about Christians losing salvation or being punished for sinning. Instead, they are addressed to 1st-century Jews (a "corporate" audience) who were rejecting the Messiah to return to the "dead works" of the Mosaic Law. The "judgment and fire" mentioned refer to the coming physical destruction of Jerusalem in AD 70, not eternal hell or divine retribution against believers.
- Ananias and Sapphira (Acts 5): The author argues that Ananias and Sapphira were not true believers. Since the New Covenant promises a "new heart" where the Holy Spirit dwells, and Peter states Satan filled Ananias's heart, they are viewed as impostors or spies, not Christians being killed by God for lying.
- Simon the Sorcerer (Acts 8): Similarly, Simon is described in scripture as having a heart "not right with God" and lacking the Spirit (not yet having received it), indicating he was not a regenerated Christian when Peter rebuked him.
- The Lord’s Supper (1 Corinthians 11): The passage mentioning people being "weak, sick, and dying" for eating unworthily is interpreted as natural consequences (hunger and drunkenness) or spiritual weakness within the community body, rather than God striking believers dead for improper ritual observance.
Conclusion
The transcript concludes by citing 1 John 4, emphasizing that "perfect love casts out fear" because fear has to do with punishment. Therefore, Christians should serve God out of love and awe, not out of a fear of divine retaliation.
Episode Page: https://wakinguptograce.com/does-god-punish-christians/
Support the show
