Every time a machine catches up to us, we redraw the line around what makes us human — and call whatever's left the "remainder." This week, Jessica and Kimberly (no guest) dig into Language Machines: Cultural AI and the End of Remainder Humanism by NYU professor Leif Weatherby, and ask whether the whole human-vs-machine contest is a trap.
Along the way: why Emily Bender's "it's just intent" argument doesn't hold up as well as it seems to, why cognition and culture can't actually be separated, a 100-year-old linguistics theory (structuralism) that explains why LLMs work at all, and why the body — not the brain — might come first.
In this episode
- The core argument — Remainder humanism: defining "human" as whatever's left over once machines take a skill. Why that's a losing game (the "arm wrestling a forklift" bit).
- Team Bender vs. Team Weatherby — Emily Bender's claim that intent is what separates human language from AI output, and Weatherby's counter: intent doesn't ground meaning, the language system grounds intent.
- Form vs. function — A quick linguistics 101 detour: language isn't just words on a page, it's what those words do in context ("it's hot in here" as a request, not a weather report).
- Cognition vs. culture — The WEIRD psychology problem (Western, Educated, Industrialized, Rich, Democratic) and why decades of "universal" cognitive science findings didn't hold up outside that narrow sample.
- Structuralism, 100 years early — The idea that words get meaning from their relationships to other words, not from pointing at things in the world — and why that theory basically predicted LLMs.
- Meaning without truth — Why hallucinations are what a meaning-making system with no truth-tracking looks like.
- Embodiment — Descartes' "I think therefore I am" flipped: feeling comes before thinking, and what that means for machines that don't have bodies.
- Practical takeaway — How to stop playing defense: quit asking "what can I still do that machines can't," start asking what these systems are trained on, who's represented, and who gets to shape them.
Mentioned in this episode
- Language Machines: Cultural AI and the End of Remainder Humanism — Leif Weatherby
- Emily Bender — linguist, "stochastic parrots" / text extrusion
- Noam Chomsky — universal grammar, cognition as separate from culture
- Maha Bali — "Where Are the Crescents in AI?"
- Michael Pollan & Annika Harris — on consciousness and embodiment
Personal segment
The episode closes with a quick peach-and-pit check-in — home renovation surprises and a therapy update on sitting with feelings in the body instead of just thinking through them.
Leave us a comment or a suggestion!
Support the show
Contact us: https://www.womentalkinboutai.com/
