At Fox Hollow Farm in Westfield, Indiana, a family’s discovery of human remains exposed the dark truth about Herb Baumeister, a man living a double life. Linked to the disappearance of multiple men in the 80s and 90s, his crimes went unnoticed for years… until survivors and investigators began connecting the dots.
With haunting details—mannequins staged around a pool, narrow escapes, and a property hiding hundreds of remains—this case is as disturbing as it is unforgettable.
And it’s not over. New searches and modern forensic genealogy are still identifying victims decades later.
Plus, we cover a recent and still-unfolding dismemberment case out of Long Island that proves some stories are still being written.
And let us not forget about Buster the Wonder Dog and the closure he was able to provide to the MIA’s from WWII
Listen now if you’re ready for a case that’s eerie, complex, and far from closed.
The list of the identified victims of Fox Hollow Farms to this date
Music by audionautix.com: Jason Shaw
All individuals mentioned in this podcast are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. The information presented is based on publicly available sources and is intended for educational and entertainment purposes only. We make every effort to ensure accuracy, but details may vary as new information becomes available.
This podcast does not condone or glorify criminal behavior. Our goal is to shed light on true events, promote awareness, and honor the victims and their families.
