A first date is basically a tiny audition for trust, and these stories prove how fast things can go off the rails. I’m coming to you on a mocktail (75 Hard is in the final countdown), then I open up a five-page doc of listener-submitted worst first dates that range from painfully awkward to genuinely scary.
We get everything: a grocery store meet-cute that turns into a surprise showdown at the ex’s workplace, a dinner date interrupted by a mom who will not stop calling and FaceTiming, and a Tinder “Netflix and chill” that ends with a phone call. We also talk about the kind of lies you can hear at a bar when someone claims they’re besties with Taylor Swift, plus the brutal moment a married man gets exposed mid-date when his wife shows up and throws wine in his face.
Between the chaos, we pull out real takeaways on first date safety, boundaries, and red flags: having your own exit plan, noticing sudden anger shifts, and paying attention when someone treats one night like instant commitment. And yes, Debbie’s story deserves a trophy for pure mayhem.
Have your own Gremlin Story? Need Gremlin Guidance? Have a juicy piece of Gremlin Gossip? Email us at EMILYTOGREMILYPOD@GMAIL.COM and make sure to tune in next week for our 1 year anniversary celebration!