Ever scroll past the same joke, the same cropped video, and replies that don’t quite sound human? We dig into why the web can feel hollow without falling for the doomsday take. As a broadcast engineer and Linux nerd, I frame the “dead internet theory” like a signal problem: automation raised the noise floor, ranking systems amplified low-cost content, and honest creators now compete with industrial output that’s optimized for clicks, not clarity.
We start by separating the soft claim from the hard one. The soft claim holds: bots, SEO farms, and AI pipelines flood feeds and search with mass-produced posts. The hard claim doesn’t: humans haven’t vanished. What changed is the layer you see, feeds and results curated by algorithms that maximize watch time and engagement. That shift rewires incentives. If you can publish 10,000 posts and only 10 need to hit to pay, volume wins. Add fake likes, coordinated replies, and engagement pods, and the ranking loop gets gamed. Trust takes the hit, and users feel the static.
Then we tour the platforms. On search, “how to” results read like cloned pages with long intros and vague steps. On social, reply zones fill with generic praise, rage bait, and suspicious links seconds after posting. Short video feeds surface reposts, mirrored clips, and AI slideshows with confident claims and no sources. Forums and subreddits still show human texture thanks to moderation, but stealth marketing and AI-polished posts slip through. We also clear a key misconception: AI use doesn’t equal a bot; the problem is automation at deceptive scale.
Finally, we get practical. Treat feeds as outputs, not reality. Curate aggressively with mutes and pruned follows. Learn quick tells for bots and source-free videos. Use RSS, reputable newsletters, and search operators to bypass SEO sludge. Harden your browser with a content blocker, a password manager, and two-factor authentication. Keep one mental rule: authenticity costs something. Real people have constraints and histories; industrial content is smooth and interchangeable. Want the internet to feel alive again? Go where humans pay a cost to be present, moderated communities, creators with reputations, and spaces where conversation is the product.
If this resonates, follow along, share it with a friend who’s tired of AI slop, and leave a review so more people can find the human web.
Send me a text message with your thoughts, questions, or feedback
If you enjoyed the show, be sure to follow The Tyler Woodward Project and leave a rating and review on Apple Podcasts or your favorite podcast app—it really helps more people discover the show.
Follow the show on Threads or Bluesky. Get in touch on the official Matrix Space for the podcast.
All views and opinions expressed in this show are solely those of the creator and do not represent or reflect the views, policies, or positions of any employer, organization, or professional affiliation.
