What happens when the pursuit of Christian unity becomes more important than biblical truth? And can we defend the unity of the visible church while condemning faithful Christians who leave a denomination that has departed from Scripture?
In this episode of Weighed in the Balance, Jonathan Brooks responds to an online controversy surrounding the Reconquista movement and the claim that the Presbyterian Church (USA) possesses the only legitimate Presbyterian jurisdiction in America. We examine the historical roots of the Associate Reformed Presbyterian Church, the nature of ecclesiastical schism, and the question of whether Christians are obligated to remain in churches that tolerate serious doctrinal error.
But this episode is about more than Presbyterian polity. It's also about how Christians ought to conduct themselves when discussing serious theological disagreements in public.
Can we defend the truth without abandoning Christian charity?
In this episode, we discuss:
Christians should take the unity of the church seriously. We should also take doctrinal fidelity seriously. Neither concern gives us permission to abandon the commands of Christ in how we treat those with whom we disagree.
As we continue this series on schism, our aim is to examine these claims carefully and charitably, weighing them against Scripture and the history of the Reformed tradition.
Do you think this claim is found wanting? Let us know on social!!