Is there an insurmountable obstacle to becoming Protestant? Cameron argues that without an infallible interpreter, Protestants have no reliable way to determine what Scripture actually teaches. If Scripture can be interpreted in different ways, how can we know which interpretation is correct?
In this episode, I respond to Cameron's objection and turn to one of the great Reformed theologians of the seventeenth century: Francis Turretin.
In his Institutes of Elenctic Theology, Turretin addresses the doctrine of the perspicuity, or clarity, of Scripture. His argument is not that every passage of Scripture is equally clear, that every theological question can be answered without interpretation, or that Christians never disagree. Rather, he argues that Scripture clearly teaches those things necessary for salvation, without requiring unwritten tradition or the infallible judgment of the Roman Catholic Church.
We examine:
Cameron, I appreciate the more measured approach in your recent discussion. I hope this response can contribute to a genuinely productive conversation.
The question is not whether Christians disagree. They do. The question is whether Scripture itself provides the authoritative standard by which those disagreements must be judged.
Does Turretin provide a reasonable answer to Cameron's objection? Is this really an insurmountable obstacle to Protestantism?
Let me know what you think in the comments.
Weighed in the Balance is the show where we examine to see if claims can hold up to scrutiny.
Subscribe for more discussions of Protestant theology, Roman Catholic apologetics, church history, and biblical interpretation.
Do you think this claim is found wanting? Let us know on social!!