The episode recounts the chilling true story of John Yelanick, a dentist from Blairesville, Pennsylvania, who mysteriously predicted his own murder and even paid his lawyer $10,000 to investigate it should it occur. The narrative details his life, his marriage to Michelle Cameler, their contentious separation and impending divorce, and the eventual gruesome discovery of John's body. Suspicion initially falls on a neighbor and a cousin due to financial dealings, but the investigation ultimately uncovers compelling evidence against Michelle's new boyfriend, Kevin Foley, a state trooper, despite initial attempts by authorities to dismiss his involvement. The episode highlights how Foley's own colleagues, bootprint evidence, and DNA found under John's fingernails ultimately led to his conviction, all while suggesting a possible, though unproven, manipulative role by Michelle.
