Text us your comments or topic ideas for future shows.
On this episode of The KeyHire Small Business Podcast, Corey Harlock breaks down why so many small business owners take great candidates through their process only to watch them ghost before the final interview or the offer, and why candidate experience may be the most underused advantage a small business has.
Corey’s core message is simple but often overlooked: candidates are customers too. Generating candidates has never been easier, between job boards and a thousand AI sourcing tools. What happens after you find them is what decides whether you land them. And as a small business, you are not Google. The people applying to your job have never heard of you, they are interviewing at several other companies, and they are there to be educated on you as much as you are there to evaluate them. If you are excited about a candidate, at least one other company is too, which means you are already on the clock.
The episode focuses on three challenges. The first is hiring speed. Corey makes an important distinction: speed to hire is not about rushing, it is about using the correct process for the role and then holding the timeline. A CNC operator who walks in, passes a shop floor test, and shows they know the machine should have an offer before they leave the building. A manager or director role should move from first contact to offer within about ten business days. He explains why entry level candidates come off the market almost immediately, and why rescheduling an interview because you are busy tells a great candidate they are an inconvenience. If a client asked for time tomorrow, would you push them to next week?
The second challenge is the hiring system. Corey emphasizes consistency, the same people asking the same questions in the same order, and shares the one question that tells you whether someone belongs in the process at all: if you love the candidate and they do not, will you hire the candidate anyway? He also gives a sharp warning about C players, toxic high performers, and anyone who hates accountability, because they will either scare a candidate off or sabotage the interview outright. From there he walks through the peer to peer conversation that is a problem solving discussion rather than an interrogation, the owner interview that focuses on culture, and the power of giving candidates the good, the bad, and the ugly. Selling a future culture you have not built yet breaks trust on day one. Honesty gets you a hell yes or a hell no, and keeps you away from the amber flag maybe.
The third challenge is ownership. Corey argues that screening resumes should not fall on the business owner, especially now that AI tools make nearly every resume look polished and every phone screen look worth taking. He shows how to hand screening to a trusted team member armed with ten or twelve clear non-negotiables and a scoring threshold, so owners protect their time while the process keeps moving. Once a candidate is on site, though, nobody gets to say they are busy this week.
This episode is especially valuable for small business owners, entrepreneurs, and hiring managers who are competing for high quality talent, losing candidates late in the process, or trying to build a repeatable hiring system. Corey also points listeners to a free hiring assessment in the show notes, a 15 question tool that takes about three minutes and reports back where your process is strong and where it is costing you.
Your sales process is designed to close business. Your hiring process should be designed to close people. Tune in for a practical, numbers backed conversation on candidate experience, hiring speed, interview systems, and how to stop losing the people your business needs. Stop grinding, start growing.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
Candidates are customers too: 83% of talent says a negative experience can change their mind about a company they liked, 87% say a positive one can win them over to a company they doubted, and 66% say it directly influences whether they accept an offer.
Generating candidates is the easy part: job boards and AI sourcing tools will find people for you. Nothing about your process after that point is automated, and that is where great candidates are won or lost.
They have never heard of you: in a market with more jobs than people, it is not the candidate’s job to research you. It is your job to make the case, and to assume that anyone you are excited about is excited by someone else too.
Speed to hire is not rush, rush, rush: it is picking the correct process for the role and then staying on the timeline. Entry level gets an offer before they walk out the door. Manager and director level is ten business days from first contact.
Every reschedule sends a message: pushing an interview because you are busy tells a candidate they are an inconvenience, and it previews what working there will feel like. If you have to move it, offer them something better, not a slot next week.
Same people, same questions, same order, and only your A players: if you would hire the candidate over someone’s objection, that person does not belong in the process. Never put a C player, a toxic high performer, or anyone who hates accountability in front of a candidate you want.
Give them the good, the bad, and the ugly: selling a culture you are still building breaks trust on day one. Every job is perfect for someone, so put everything on the table and aim for a hell yes or a hell no. The amber flag maybe is the worst outcome in hiring.
Screening is not the owner’s job: AI written resumes make everyone look qualified, so screening costs more time than it ever has. Hand it to someone you trust with ten or twelve non-negotiables and a scoring threshold, and protect your calendar for the interviews that matter.
LINKS & RESOURCES
Free hiring assessment, 15 questions in about three minutes: https://www.keyhire.solutions/scorecard
Connect with Corey Harlock on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/coreyharlock/
Learn more about KeyHire Solutions: https://www.keyhire.solutions
Subscribe on Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-keyhire-small-business-podcast/id1643962763
Subscribe on Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/1FT9oqXSek3jMfiKrZPLQs
EPISODE CHAPTERS
0:00 - Why great candidates ghost you
0:35 - Show intro
1:23 - Housekeeping, and two episodes worth going back for
2:34 - Candidates are customers too: 83%, 87%, 66%
3:27 - Generating candidates is the easy part
5:29 - You are not Google, and they have never heard of you
6:49 - They are on a recon mission, not there to sell you
7:58 - Challenge one: hiring speed
8:23 - The correct process for an entry level role
10:21 - Manager and director: ten business days
11:29 - Every reschedule burns your clock
12:09 - Would you push a client to next week?
13:34 - How to move a meeting without losing the candidate
14:17 - Speed is not rush, rush, rush
14:35 - Challenge two: the hiring system
15:31 - Who to include, and the question that decides it
17:00 - Never put a C player in front of a candidate
18:51 - Same people, same questions, same order
20:16 - The peer conversation, not an interrogation
20:44 - The owner interview is about culture
21:15 - Do not sell a culture you have not built yet
22:35 - The good, the bad, and the ugly
24:16 - Every job is perfect for someone
24:59 - The amber flag maybe
25:53 - Challenge three: who owns the process
26:17 - AI resumes mean everyone looks good
26:37 - Non-negotiables and a scoring threshold
28:22 - Everyone makes time, especially for the on site
30:15 - Your process is a preview of what it is like to work there
31:00 - Close candidates the way you close deals
31:16 - The free 15 question hiring assessment
31:58 - If 80% of a process was wasted, would you keep it?
33:03 - Closing thoughts
