Listen

Description

Episode Summary

A shallow leader is someone who looks the part of a leader on the surface but lacks the depth to carry real responsibility, and learning to spot them is one of the most important leadership development skills a senior leader can build. Shallow leaders interview well. They know the language of leadership, and many hold an advanced degree like an MBA to strengthen their case. Left unchecked in positions of influence, they can become a cancer in your organization.

Brandon Pinkerton speaks from hard experience. One of his greatest regrets from his years of building a company was allowing a shallow leader to keep running a regional office for several years after he recognized the problem. The office eventually imploded almost entirely, and Brandon lost significant respect within his organization. In the aftermath, he resolved to be much tougher and more proactive with those who had the privilege to lead under his watch.

The first lesson he took away: you have to know what you are looking for before you can act on it. Brandon identifies two of the clearest signs. Shallow leaders are sticklers for rules, leaning on structure and process instead of instinct and visionary thinking, which leaves them stuck when a challenge falls outside the rule book. They also avoid pain and run from difficulty, enjoying the privileges of leadership while making excuses when sacrifice is required. Often, someone they respected told them they were already a finished product. Pride keeps them from asking for help, and insecurity turns into a facade of bravado and overcompensation.

The challenge for every leader with influence over hiring and promotion is clear. Promote, elevate, and hire only those individuals with the depth of leadership to support your vision. And if shallow leaders already hold positions of influence in your organization, do yourself a favor and have the hard conversations today.

KEY TAKEAWAYS
Looking the part is not the same as having depth. Credentials and a strong interview can mask shallow leadership.
You have to know what you are looking for before you can act on it.
Leaders who lean on rules instead of judgment get stuck when a challenge falls outside the rule book, and the problem festers.
Leaders who enjoy the privileges but avoid the sacrifice believe only in the easy parts of leadership.
Every season you allow a shallow leader to keep influence, your organization and your own credibility pay the price.
Closing Reflection

So take five minutes and consider. Who are the shallow leaders in my organization that I've given too much influence? Am I willing to have honest conversations with my shallow leaders about taking a step back to work on growth?

FINAL THOUGHT

Shallow leaders rarely set out to be shallow. Someone told them they had arrived before the real work had begun. Your job is to look beneath the surface, have the hard conversation, and reserve the privilege of leading for those with the depth to carry it. It's time to now go lead.