Bethany Joy Lenz (Emily) may be the best actress Hallmark has ever seen. Tyler Hynes (Jamie) is arguably the most popular leading man in Hallmark history. And Paul Campbell — already beloved as a Hallmark leading man — has also become one of the network’s most talented writers.
Put them all together and you get the 2021 Hallmark Christmas favorite: An Unexpected Christmas.
When Variety released its 2025 list, “The 25 Best Hallmark Christmas Movies, Ranked,” the Hallmark world exploded with debate… and their #1 pick was none other than An Unexpected Christmas!
In this episode, we cover:
• Behind-the-scenes movie fun facts
• Our favorite moments
• Scenes we’d rewrite
• The best supporting characters
• “Are We Sure?” — our ultimate Hallmark logic check
• Whether Emily and Jamie would actually last as a couple
• The multiple kisses… and the letter grades they earned
• Who (or what) truly won the movie
• Our personal — and unbiased — final rating
For the love of Hallmark!
Follow us on Instagram: www.instagram.com/foreverhallmarkchristmas
Email: ForeverHallmarkChristmas@gmail.com
*** Not affiliated with Hallmark Media.