Send us Fan Mail
Seven decisions in the Australian Federal Courts edition of 23 September 2026, four with headnotes: three from the Full Court, carried at depth here and pointed to from the Court of Appeal brief of the same date, and four from single judges. The lead: a unanimous Full Court holds that a doctoral candidate on a Commonwealth-funded research scholarship was not an employee of the University of Sydney, because a contract of service needs a contractual obligation to work whose non-performance would be a breach, and a stipend conditioned on diligent progress is support for a student's education, not wages. Also: the abandoned child provision of the 1948 citizenship Act, where the contrary to be proved is birth outside Australia, not another nationality; non-disclosure certificates, closed sessions and the Court's own look at confidential material in a security assessment appeal; and non-standard discovery, fishing and oppression in a Fair Work claim against Qantas. House spot: a word from JADE after the opening block.
Commercial Law Desk (lead).
- Burt v University of Sydney [2026] FCAFC 129 - appeal from the dismissal of a representative proceeding under Pt IVA of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 dismissed, no order as to costs: a contract of service requires the supply of labour, for the putative employer's benefit, in performance of a contractual obligation whose non-performance would sound in breach, in exchange for remuneration, and benefit to the putative employer alone does not suffice; a higher degree by research candidate who made no promise to the University to progress his research, diligent progress being only a condition of continued payment, was in no relationship of mutual obligation, and the scholarship stipend was educational support rather than remuneration; leave entitlements and expected hours did not indicate employment; a contractual right of control is relevant only where the work is performed under an obligation owed to an employer or principal; alternative grounds in notices of contention need not be decided where the appeal fails on the primary ground; s 570 of the Fair Work Act 2009 very likely prohibits a costs order. JADE
Public Law Desk.
- Deyanti v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2026] FCAFC 126 - appeal dismissed with costs: 'the contrary' to be proved under the abandoned child provision in s 5(3)(b) of the Australian Citizenship Act 1948 is proof of birth outside Australia, not proof of entitlement to another nationality, a construction reading nationality in being circular; the unincorporated Convention on the Reduction of Statelessness cannot displace clear enacted text, s 5(3)(b)(i) enacting only the first element of art 2, even where statelessness results; and (Banks-Smith and Stewart JJ) a Full Court follows a prior Full Court's construction (SZRTN) unless it is plainly wrong or there is a compelling reason not to, even where a new argument is advanced, provided the question was argued and decided rather than assumed, Younan J reaching the same result on construction. JADE
- MJZP v Director-General of Security [2026] FCAFC 127 - appeal on questions of law from the Tribunal's Security Division affirming an adverse security assessment, and a proceeding challenging non-disclosure certificates, dismissed with costs: the Tribunal's documents transmitted under s 46(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 are before the Court without formal tender, so conditions on tender and exclusion under s 135 of the Evidence Act 1995 have no work to do; a certificate under ss 39A(8) and 39B(2)(a) is legally unreasonable only if the requisite satisfaction could not have been reached logically or rationally on the material; the Minister errs if she treats the public interest as precluding anything but prejudice to security, but not by assessing security as the only significant issue; decision-makers must consider the direct, immediate and statutorily prescribed consequences of a decision, not indirect or contingent ones; once a certificate is given the statute itself excludes the applicant's representatives unless the Minister consents, so a refusal of consent changes no legal rights; s 39B(11) is a source of power to receive information in closed session without a certificate, procedural fairness depending on the circumstances and practical injustice; and the Court may examine confidential reasons and evidence for unreasonableness or a failure to engage. JADE
Practice and Procedure Desk.
- Sharpin v Qantas Airways Limited [2026] FCA 1399 - non-standard discovery under rr 20.12 and 20.15 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 ordered in a Fair Work Act claim: relevance is assessed against the pleaded issues without deciding contested questions of construction on the merits (whether a 'medically significant condition' under the Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998 includes pre-diagnosis symptoms left for trial); a live pleaded issue and evidence grounding a suspicion that discovery will aid proof answer a fishing objection; existing consent discovery was no substitute; a party resisting discovery as oppressive ordinarily needs evidence of the extent, cost or difficulty of the searches and the likely volume of documents; costs reserved under s 570 of the Fair Work Act 2009 without any finding of unreasonable conduct. JADE
Registry (synopsis and list only; no outcomes stated on air).
- Finnegan v Kemner (No 3) [2026] FCA 1402 - synopsis: leave to withdraw an admission or amend pleadings on the first day of trial (rr 16.53 and 26.11). JADE
- James v Narang Bir-Rong Aboriginal Corporation, in the matter of Narang Bir-Rong Aboriginal Corporation (Special Administrators Appointed) [2026] FCA 1408 - list only. JADE
- Clark v Registrar of Titles (No 2) [2026] FCA 1404 - list only. JADE
Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.