The Patent Office and three tribunals, twelve decisions, in the Tribunals edition of Wednesday 28 October 2026, one with a headnote. Why a reward scheme run through a payment terminal is mostly not a manner of manufacture after Aristocrat '25; how to get back into a VCAT case you missed and how to test a Calderbank offer; why a small business sale without a disclosure statement is void; and the exceptional case test in a blue card review.
Tribunals Desk: a reward scheme at the Patent Office (lead).
Tribunals Desk: missed hearings and costs offers (frameworks from synopses; no outcome stated).
Tribunals Desk: a business sale and a building contract (frameworks from synopses).
Tribunals Desk: blue card reviews and unacceptable risk (legal framework only; no outcome stated).
Registry and the thread (list only, by subject; no outcome stated): HPL Construction Vic Pty Ltd v Gardenview Homes Pty Ltd [2026] VCAT 903 (estoppel); Millington v Bala Homes Pty Ltd & Anor (Costs) [2026] VCAT 902 (costs); Mason Constructions (VIC) Pty Ltd v Port Phillip CC [2026] VCAT 889 (heritage permit conditions); HJZWLIJ Pty Ltd v Bass Coast SC [2026] VCAT 841 (rural subdivision); Arnold v Macedon Ranges SC [2026] VCAT 711 (strike out); GWF v Commissioner of Victims Rights [2026] NSWCATAD 326 (victims support review).
Case notes
Kyro Card Capital Pty Ltd [2026] APO 31 - Dr W.E. Guinea (delegate of the Commissioner of Patents), 22 October 2026. Patents Act 1990 (Cth) ss 18(1)(a), 40(2)(a), 40(3); Patents Regulations 1991 (Cth) reg 13.4(3). Held also: the physical integers were standard components; claim 1 was not limited to PCI compliance (claims construed to avoid redundancy); the terminal was altered only by the data it stored; distributed storage on the reward server is well established (Rokt). Acceptance date set at six months. Why aired: a clean application of the post-Aristocrat '25 practice to computer implemented claims. Pending: further examination; nothing predicted.
Turner v Mico [2026] VCAT 901 - I Lulham, Deputy President, 4 September 2026. Why aired: a reusable checklist for reviews of orders made in a party's absence.
Stanley v EWH Construction West Pty Ltd (Costs) [2026] VCAT 896 - I Lulham, Deputy President, 14 October 2026. Why aired: Calderbank timing and when VCAT fixes costs itself.
Bowen Smith Pty Ltd v Mane & Ors [2026] VCAT 899 - I Lulham, Deputy President, 14 October 2026. Why aired: a drastic statutory consequence for small business sales.
Newearth Constructions Pty Ltd v Gillis & Anor [2026] VCAT 897 - Member R Curie, 21 October 2026. Why aired: jurisdiction for subdivision works, incorporation by reference, certificates on account, and breach without loss.
Blue Card Applicant MG v Director-General Department of Justice [2026] QCAT 501 - Member P Roney KC, 20 October 2026. Why aired: a full restatement of the exceptional case test that corrects a common balancing error.
A working with children review is reported by its legal framework only, and a victims support review by subject only; no one is identified. The patent application remains under examination and nothing here predicts its outcome. Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.