Send us Fan Mail
The month in commercial law, in one sitting: ten decisions from the Monthly Petal's Commercial Law edition (31 August to 29 September 2026), and one argument running through them. Your paper protects you only if it is fair, plain and complete: the Full Federal Court voids an arbitration clause in click-through consumer terms and refuses to halt a class action without notice to the group; the Federal Court approves a $3.5 million penalty under the dual regime for proposing and relying on unfair terms; and the NSW Supreme Court holds that a principal that judges a defective extension claim on its merits waives the time bar, no-waiver clause or not. House spot: a word from JADE after the opening lead.
Leads.
- Plus500AU Pty Ltd v AghaeiRad [2026] FCAFC 125 (Lee, Banks-Smith and Stewart JJ, 16 September 2026) - Unfairness under ASIC Act s 12BG is judged by the particular contract and consumer; transparency is objective, with no assumption that a box-ticking consumer read 50 pages of terms; significant imbalance turns on practical operation (arbitration cost against modest claims, loss of the class action), not formal symmetry; the supplier bears the reasonable-necessity onus; pro-arbitration policy informs but does not immunise. A void arbitration term cannot found a stay under s 8(1) of the Commercial Arbitration Act 2010 (NSW), and a whole class action cannot be stayed on the representative's personal obligation without notice to group members and a chance of substitution. Appeals dismissed. Ledger · JADE
- Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Venture 5 Group Pty Ltd [2026] FCA 1278 (Jackman J, 31 August 2026) - Seven small amount credit contract terms unfair, the default and authority terms conferring unconstrained control over unscheduled withdrawals without notice; terms relied on to collect money lawfully owed void only prospectively, terms never relied on void ab initio; proposing (s 12BF(2A)) and relying on (s 12BF(2C)) an unfair term are separate civil penalty contraventions, analysed as a course of conduct with totality as the final check; agreed $3.5 million penalty, injunction, replacement terms and adverse publicity order; a Credit Code s 87(2) declaration despite an inadvertent system error. Ledger · JADE
- Clarke Energy (Australia) Pty Ltd v Alinta Energy Transmission (Roy Hill) Pty Ltd [2026] NSWSC 1124 (Rees J, 21 September 2026) - A principal that directs a superintendent to decide an EOT claim on its merits waives non-compliance with conditions precedent, and a no-waiver clause does not prevent waiver by election; float belongs to the contractor where the entitlement clause disregards its ability to finish on time; delay costs include margin, overheads and profit absent clear words; an absolute-discretion reserve power does not exclude the prevention principle; non-final determinations are decided afresh on all the evidence; no superintendent duty of care to a contractually protected contractor. 142 days of extensions and judgment for about $7.19 million, some figures still to be settled. Ledger · JADE
The September docket.
- Gobbo v State of Victoria [2026] VSCA 221 (Emerton P, Beach and Kenny JJA, 11 September 2026) - General words of release are restrained by text, context, purpose, the recitals and the disputes in contemplation, with subjective intention inadmissible; a release of all causes of action accrued from dealings with police still barred the claims. Leave refused to the first applicant; the other appeals dismissed. (The negligence holdings are in the Torts and Negligence edition.) Ledger · JADE
- UIL (Singapore) Pte Ltd v Wollongong Coal Limited (No 5) [2026] FCA 1336 (Bennett J, 10 September 2026) - The CISG applies under Art 1(1)(b) despite Singapore's reservation; Art 14(1) exhaustively sets minimum content and displaces domestic certainty rules; Art 55 cannot price a deal meant to be priced per transaction; under Art 8 the coal sale agreements were a back-to-back framework, not contracts of sale. Dismissed. Ledger · JADE
- Built Pty Ltd v State of New South Wales [2026] NSWSC 1147 (Rees J, 24 September 2026) - Under GC21 (Edition 2) cl 71.8.2 the $500,000 litigation threshold applies to each Issue determined, not the aggregate; CPB Contractors followed; EOT claims with delay costs are money claims; below-threshold claims permanently stayed under s 67 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW), costs payable forthwith. Ledger · JADE
- Macsteel International Australia Pty Limited v Oliver [2026] FCA 1300 (Neskovcin J, 26 August 2026) - Interlocutory, the claims untested: r 14.01(1) forensic inspection of a former CFO's devices by an independent expert on targeted parameters; a prima facie case of misuse of confidential information inferred from unexplained mass downloads and contact with a competitor; injunction and disclosure orders. Ledger · JADE
- Kline Industries International Pty Ltd v Cross & Anor [2026] QCATA 139 (Senior Member Lember, 15 September 2026) - Repudiation or frustration is at least a mixed question needing leave; a party is bound by its case below; a building contract with variation machinery for the supervening problem is not frustrated by dearer performance; readiness and willingness need not be proved unless put in issue. Leave refused on ground 1; appeal otherwise dismissed. Ledger · JADE
- OPES Lifestyle Homes Pty Ltd v KMA Concrete Constructions Pty Ltd [2026] NSWCATAP 275 (G Blake AM SC and A Bell SC, 3 September 2026) - An oral variation to raise slab levels 'similar to the height of the road/gutter' was certain enough; uncertainty is a mixed question, not a pure question of law for an appeal as of right; new points not run below excluded. Leave refused; appeal dismissed. Ledger · JADE
- Anderson v Granda Venture Pty Ltd trading as Butopia [2026] NSWCATAP 286 (A Balla ADCJ and K Merrick, 9 September 2026) - Joinder of a builder's supervisor and director turns on utility; where the company is liable for its employees under CCA s 84 and complete relief is available against it, refusal was open; interlocutory practice appeals face a high hurdle. Appeal dismissed with costs. Ledger · JADE
What to watch.
Plus500 left the unconscionability ground undecided, and only Lee J (obiter) addressed whether the arbitration was commercial and the claims arbitrable, so there is no majority view on arbitrability of consumer class action claims. In Built, aggregation was assumed but never decided in the earlier appellate case, so the per-Issue construction of GC21 (Edition 2) holds the field at first instance. Clarke Energy's remaining delay-cost and interest figures are still to be settled.
Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.