Send us Fan Mail
September in family law, told as one argument: the appellate courts applied the test the law writes, no more and no less. No added condition on a statutory right of appearance, no freestanding unacceptable-risk test, no presumption of time and no second forum through parens patriae; but every material contest and every joined claim decided, the trustee heard before a superannuation split, and best interests expressly satisfied before a settlement binds a person with a disability. Family matters where children are described are reported as legal doctrine only. House spot: a word from JADE after the opening lead.
The thread.
- Palacio & Ksenia [2026] FedCFamC1A 156 (Jarrett, Smith and Behrens JJ, 8 September 2026) - Top Case. A restricted State practising certificate and legal aid panel terms do not qualify the s 55B Judiciary Act right of appearance; acting beyond a certificate is for the State Supreme Court under s 20AD, not a personal costs order; the supervisory jurisdiction to restrain a practitioner is for exceedingly rare cases; costs certificate refused for want of a Schedule of Costs. Ledger · JADE
- Verissimus & Polycarpe [2026] FedCFamC1A 166 (Gill, Schonell and Brasch JJ, 16 September 2026) - Top Case. Failing to resolve a material contest over initial contributions and inheritances, or to explain why it could not be resolved, is s 79 error; a spousal maintenance claim raised and joined must be determined, if only by dismissal with reasons; property and maintenance remitted for rehearing; AI-prepared appeal documents should be avoided. Ledger · JADE
- Cadwgan & Cadwgan [2026] FedCFamC1A 149 (Schonell J, 28 August 2026) - A superannuation splitting order made without s 90XZD procedural fairness to the trustee is inoperative and made without power; a party's concession does not relieve the appeal court of satisfying itself that error is established. Ledger · JADE
- W v S [No 3] [2026] WASCA 136 (Seaward JA, Bowskill AJA, Solomon J, 24 September 2026) - Top Case. The r 109(1)(d) best-interests requirement for consent orders binding a person with a disability is a substantive protection; satisfaction cannot be inferred, is not supplied by a just-and-equitable finding or a case guardian's appointment, and cannot be dispensed with under r 12; remitted for rehearing. Ledger · JADE
- Bergsma & Hyde [2026] FedCFamC1A 148 (Campton, Christie and Schonell JJ, 28 August 2026) - No freestanding unacceptable-risk test: risk is assessed under the Act's express provisions, principally ss 60CC and 60CG; long-term or indefinite supervision is permissible where the evidence justifies it, the Full Court's cautions being guidelines; exhaust the slip rule before appealing. Ledger · JADE
- Helias & Tadeu [2026] FedCFamC1A 161 (Riethmuller J, 10 September 2026) - No presumption in favour of time orders merely because no unacceptable risk of harm is found; the effect of orders on a primary carer's capacity to parent may outweigh the benefit of the relationship; a fall-back position is not a concession. Ledger · JADE
- WS v Secretary, Department of Communities and Justice [2026] NSWCA 178 (Leeming JA, Griffiths AJA, 7 September 2026) - Leave from an interlocutory summary dismissal needs principle, public importance or a reasonably clear injustice; the parens patriae jurisdiction ordinarily fills only procedural gaps in the Care Act regime, and discontinuing the statutory appeal does not cure an abuse of process. Ledger · JADE
- Mishra & Piatos [2026] FedCFamC1A 171 (Williams J, 24 September 2026) - The existence and duration of a de facto relationship is reviewed for correctness under Warren v Coombes, not House v The King; periods aggregate under s 90SB(a) without a threshold temporary-or-final inquiry; parties are bound by the conduct of their case; AI-generated grounds criticised. Ledger · JADE
- Ibragimov & Izquiredo [2026] FedCFamC1A 146 (Williams J, 27 August 2026) - Refusing leave under r 15.26 to use another proceeding's documents is interlocutory; special circumstances need significant probative value and exhausted alternatives; a hopeless intervention filed to reach confidential family law material may be an abuse of process. Ledger · JADE
Cases referenced at the table.
House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499 JADE · Warren v Coombes (1979) 142 CLR 531 JADE
What to watch.
Two matters go back for rehearing, Verissimus (property and maintenance) and W v S [No 3] (the consent-order application), and nothing here expresses a view on their outcome. After Palacio, the referral to the professional regulators stands, and certificate questions belong to the State Supreme Court. After Bergsma, watch how trial judges structure supervision without an end point. Watch whether two judicial warnings about AI-drafted appeal documents in one month harden into practice guidance, and how the word ordinarily in WS is tested.
Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.