Send us Fan Mail
Five decisions. A running-collision contest the Supreme Court holds is a combat sport, and the ordinary meaning of "strike" and "hit"; a daughter's claim to half the waterfront property her father left her only in part, and how a proprietary estoppel must be pleaded; the Court of Appeal's gross sum costs order with the state angle; a probate hearing that proceeded without the defendant; and a registry line. Thursday: no house spot.
Public Law Desk.
- Run Nation Championship Pty Ltd v Combat Sports Authority of New South Wales & Anor [2026] NSWSC 1089 (Coleman J) - "strike" and "hit" in Sch 3 Combat Sports Act 2013 (NSW) bear their broad ordinary meaning of forceful contact or collision, not blows within a fight; dictionaries are a starting point, not a substitute for context; a mandatory body-to-body "tackle" from which all scoring flows makes striking the primary objective of each combatant, shared by runner and defender; the cl 5(1)(d) exclusion requires all strike zones to be "fully protected" and substantial compliance is insufficient; characterisation regulates, it does not ban; commercial loss irrelevant to construction. Amended summons dismissed with costs. JADE
Commercial Law Desk.
- Sellar v Ryan [2026] NSWSC 1086 (Kunc J) - "my principal place of residence as at the date of my death" construed by the armchair principle as the dwelling with the land on which it stands, here both adjoining lots as one functioning property; proprietary estoppel requires a clear and unequivocal promise, and a promise of an undefined share "amounting to most" of the property is not one; a spouse's words bind the testator only with actual or ostensible authority, and acquiescence by silence requires a pleaded duty to speak; reliance not established, the plaintiff having known from December 2015 the mutual wills could not change; no express trust from statements of future or testamentary gift; no common intention or joint endeavour constructive trust; no Morris v Morris charge; quantum meruit failed on five bases, the benefit of the unpaid work having gone to the family company; conceded debt of $128,700 recoverable, amounts paid by the company not; representations are pleaded as material facts, not verbatim conversations (UCPR rr 14.7-14.9). Declaration; judgment for $128,700; otherwise dismissed with costs. JADE
Practice & Procedure Desk.
- Bolton v WAM Active Ltd (No 4) [2026] NSWCA 189 (Leeming JA) - payment out of security for costs turns on a secured liability exceeding the security, not the lawyers' entitlement to their bills; an undertaking secured by money in court excludes set-off by clear implication (s 21(3) CPA does not assist); costs of a reply affidavit necessitated by an overstated affidavit in chief excluded; gross sum costs under s 98(4)(c) fixed by the work reasonably required (Pasade) under s 60 proportionality at $6,500. Whole $25,000 security released. Litigant in person. Full treatment in today's Courts of Appeal brief. JADE
- Smith v Pallister [2026] NSWSC 1091 (Bennett J) - illustrative: proceeding in a party's absence under UCPR r 29.7 (Lester v Brown; NSW Trustee and Guardian v Gregory), the evidentiary steps establishing notice, ss 56-60 CPA on adjourning or proceeding, exclusion of NCAT reasons under s 91 Evidence Act (Bale; Quach), and revocation of a grant and removal of an executor for delay. Carried at insight level; outcome not stated. JADE
Registry.
- Australian Mortgage Finance Services Pty Ltd v Patel [2026] NSWSC 1085 (Fagan J) - mortgages. Listed without headnote. JADE
Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.