Send us Fan Mail
Ten decisions in the Queensland weekend edition of 25 to 27 September 2026, all headnoted. The Supreme Court strikes out a claim against the other side's lawyers: no duty of care or fiduciary duty to an opponent, no civil action for breach of duties to the court, caveat compensation only against the caveator, and advocates' immunity against suits by the opposing party. A litigation funder that paid more than $20 million in legal bills is held to its costs agreements, and non-disclosure goes to discretion, not validity. The Court of Appeal puts a registered after-acquired property security ahead of a later assignee of a tax refund, and past a deed of company arrangement. Then two criminal appeals reported as doctrine only, and five registry-length decisions. The eight Court of Appeal decisions also appear in the Court of Appeal brief of the same weekend and are re-aired here with the Queensland angle.
Practice and Procedure Desk (lead).
- Yang v Gao [2026] QSC 191 - claim against the opposing party's solicitors, two law practices and an unserved barrister struck out (UCPR rr 16(i), 171; inherent jurisdiction), Sullivan J: a legal representative owes no duty of care to the client's opponent save in very limited exceptions, and no fiduciary duty, which would conflict with the duty to the client [45], [51], [133]; fraud must be distinctly alleged, particularised and proved [49]-[50], [81]; the Land Title Act 1994 (Qld) gives no damages action against a practitioner over a caveat, s 130 compensation lying solely against the caveator [61], [69]-[73]; ethical duties to the court (ASCR rr 3.1, 19.1) create no civil cause of action for an opponent, the remedies being discipline and the Court's costs jurisdiction [74]-[80], [105]-[113]; a knowledge plea must plead the facts, and practitioners could not have known the law to be the opposite of existing authority [84]-[94]; advocates' immunity protects barristers and solicitors, for acts and omissions in court and in work intimately connected with it, against suits by an opposing party in all forms of action [135]-[148]; leave to replead refused [96]-[102], [149]; an unserved defendant may be struck out of the Court's own motion [153]-[155]. The strike out implies no impropriety by any defendant [156]-[157]. JADE
Commercial Law Desk.
- LCM Operations Pty Ltd v R Kelly & Ors Trading as Clyde & Co Australia [2026] QSC 214 - questions referred by a costs assessor answered, Smith J: a funder that paid the costs is a third party payer entitled to assessment under s 335(2) of the Legal Profession Act 2007 (Qld) and bound by the costs agreement to which it is party [32]-[38]; a costs agreement is construed objectively and as a whole, so an arithmetical error in an estimate table does not override express terms confining the uplift to professional fees [49]-[54]; the agreements were not void under s 327, and the uplift was never payable, there being no recovery [42]-[45], [58]; s 318 required clear written disclosure of substantial changes in estimates, not ordinarily made by delivering bills, and timely disclosure was arguably not made [61]-[64]; non-disclosure does not void a costs agreement but is one factor in the s 328 discretion, and unfairness was not established [65]-[73]; a proportionate reduction under s 316(4) is for the assessor [74]-[76]; the firm's solicitors may be heard, and interest on any refund is for the Court [79]-[84]. The assessment proceeds on the costs agreements. JADE
- Kirk v Moreton Resources Pty Ltd [2026] QCA 186 - receiver's appeal allowed, Boddice JA, Thomson AJA and Crowley J: an expectancy (a contested R&D tax refund) that produces a right to payment is after-acquired property within an all-assets security [43]-[44], which attaches automatically under ss 18-20 of the Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth) and is enforceable against the assignee [46]-[49]; a later assignment for value does not take the property out of the prior registered security, Re Anroma Pty Ltd governing only company against secured creditor [60]-[69]; a DOCA release of the secured debt under s 444D of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) does not release the security, which remains enforceable for that debt against after-acquired property, Re Bluenergy not adopted [90]-[93]. The receiver may conduct the tribunal proceedings for the company. Also in the Court of Appeal brief. JADE
Criminal Law Desk.
- R v LBQ [2026] QCA 181 - appeal against two convictions of indecent treatment of a child allowed and a new trial ordered, Johnstone J (Bowskill CJ and Henry J agreeing): verdicts are inconsistent only if no reasonable jury could have reached them, and an acquittal on a count requiring an additional intent was reconcilable [52]-[66]; once the evidence raises an honest and reasonable but mistaken belief under s 24 of the Criminal Code (Qld), the Crown must disprove it beyond reasonable doubt as well as proving each element, and the jury must be directed on the defence, the onus and its bearing on wilfulness [74]-[79]; the omission was material although no redirection was sought [72], [80]-[82]; the remedy is a new trial, whether the prosecution proceeds being for the prosecuting authority [83]. Reported as doctrine only; the complainant is not identified; the presumption of innocence applies. Also in the Court of Appeal brief. JADE
- R v NAJ [2026] QCA 182 - conviction appeal dismissed and leave to appeal against sentence refused, Doyle JA (Brown JA and Kelly J agreeing): choosing between a Foley direction and recalling the complainant is a forensic decision for trial counsel [35]-[38]; a judge may have the jury review a witness's evidence as a whole [37]; a juror's volunteered remark did not meet the fair-minded lay observer test for discharge [50]-[52]; the verdicts were not unreasonable [53], [98]-[116]; a forensic disadvantage under s 132BA of the Evidence Act 1977 (Qld) must be real, identifiable and significant [122]-[128]; exceeding the prosecution's range is not itself error [131]-[149]. Reported as doctrine only; the complainant is not identified. Also in the Court of Appeal brief. JADE
Registry (headnoted Court of Appeal decisions, one clause each on air).
- Kerr v Legal Services Commission [2026] QCA 184 - leave to appeal under s 118(3) of the District Court of Queensland Act 1967 (Qld) refused, Bond, Boddice and Doyle JJA: engaging in legal practice under s 24(1) of the Legal Profession Act 2007 (Qld) requires neither multiple clients nor remuneration, and multiple acts for one person, including written legal opinions, by an admitted lawyer without a practising certificate sufficed [16]-[19]; a $4,000 fine with convictions recorded was not unreasonable or plainly unjust [20]-[23]. JADE
- Antai Solar Australia Pty Ltd v Towers [No 2] [2026] QCA 188 - costs of the appeal, Brown, Bradley and Doyle JJA: UCPR r 766(1)(a) empowers the Court of Appeal to vary a costs order below not separately appealed, but a consent costs order is disturbed only for a particular reason, and none was shown [6]-[7]; respondents to pay 50 per cent of the appellant's costs [8]-[9]. JADE
- Jason H Pty Ltd as trustee for the Jason H Family Trust v Habchi [No 2] [2026] QCA 189 - costs of the appeal, Brown, Bradley and Doyle JJA: an offer to settle made after all submissions were prepared and offering none of the appellants' costs to date was not shown to be unreasonably declined, and seven days was not shown to be sufficient [9]-[12]; the appellants' costs of the appeal are their costs in the proceedings below [13]-[15]. JADE
- R v Kennedy [2026] QCA 183 - application for leave to appeal against sentence refused, Bond and Doyle JJA and Cooper J: a sentence application does not permit the Court to go behind guilty pleas or the agreed facts [6]-[7], and a marked difference from other sentences does not alone establish manifest excess [26]-[27]. JADE
- Donaci v Director of Public Prosecutions (Qld) [2026] QCA 185 - appeal against refusal to vary bail conditions dismissed and fresh evidence refused, Brown JA, Gotterson AJA and Cooper J: review is for House v The King error [1]-[2]; parole monitoring and police bail monitoring are distinct regimes, so there was no double loading [32]; human rights points not raised below were not an error to leave unaddressed [36]-[41]; fresh evidence under UCPR r 766 failed the three requirements [59]-[66]. The charges are untried; the presumption of innocence applies. JADE
Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.