Listen

Description

Send us Fan Mail

Your Tribunals brief for 23 June 2026 — five decisions from the civil and administrative tribunals of New South Wales, Victoria, Queensland and Western Australia, on a single theme: fairness, and limits. A tribunal cannot decide your costs without reading what you filed; a power of attorney can be reset when the attorney falters; a rent rise is tested by the law of its day; vilification can be compensated for hurt feelings alone; and a crime does not stay hidden behind a professional title. The principles, not the noise.

A note on care: two matters in this episode touch racial and religious vilification and the loss of a person's capacity. They are reported in a restrained register — principle and consequence only, no detail, no parties named.

In this episode:

• Lirantzis v Calligas (No 2) — natural justice, bias, representation and costs: https://jade.io/article/1233712

• AB — revoking an enduring power of attorney: https://jade.io/article/1233745

• Ali v Homes Victoria — testing a rent increase by the law in force when it was given: https://jade.io/article/1233746

• Vorchheimer v Tayeh (No 2) — vilification, compensation and remedies: https://jade.io/article/1233753

• Psychology Board of Australia v Schroder — professional misconduct from criminal dishonesty: https://jade.io/article/1233761

Case notes

Lirantzis v Calligas (No 2) [2026] NSWCATAP 195 (S de Jersey, Principal Member; J Sullivan, Senior Member; 23 June 2026) — https://jade.io/article/1233712

Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (NSW) ss 38(1), 60; Civil and Administrative Tribunal Rules 2014 (NSW) rr 38, 38A. Held: filed submissions left unread because of an administrative error is a denial of natural justice and grounds reopening; a prior adverse decision is not, by itself, actual or apprehended bias; a solicitor on a supervised practising certificate may appear; where the amount in dispute exceeds thirty thousand dollars the ordinary costs rule displaces the special-circumstances test; a Calderbank offer made in the original proceeding does not ground indemnity costs on the appeal.

AB [2026] WASAT 69 (Ms F Child, Member; 23 June 2026) — https://jade.io/article/1233745

Guardianship and Administration Act 1990 (WA) s 107. Held: the presumption of capacity is displaced only on proper medical evidence; an enduring power of attorney is revoked where the attorney can no longer keep the represented person's funds separate, maintain records, or act in their best interests, including by reason of the attorney's own ill health or financial disarray; the least-restrictive-alternative and best-interests tests govern the appointment of substitute decision-makers. Reported in a restrained register; the pseudonym is preserved.

Ali v Homes Victoria [2026] VCAT 453 (Dr A Treble, Senior Member; 18 June 2026) — https://jade.io/article/1233746

Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (Vic) ss 46(3), 47(3), 48(1); Interpretation of Legislation Act 1984 (Vic) ss 14, 28. Held: the validity of a rent-increase notice is assessed under the law in force when the notice was given; rights accrue at that date and later substantive amendments do not apply retrospectively; a refund runs only from the application filing date; the tribunal is confined to the enumerated factors and may not weigh a renter's hardship or the broader social-housing context.

Vorchheimer v Tayeh (No 2) [2026] VCAT 461 (Vice President Judge Tran, 22 June 2026) — https://jade.io/article/1233753

Racial and Religious Tolerance Act 2001 (Vic) ss 23C(a)(i)-(iii); VCAT Act 1998 (Vic) s 112. Held: compensation for vilification is available for hurt feelings and distress without proof of physical or mental injury; post-hearing conduct may aggravate; the tribunal may accept an enforceable undertaking instead of a prohibition order where it adequately covers the conduct, and may order a corrective social-media statement; the offer-of-compromise costs presumption does not arise where the offer was not substantially comparable to the relief ordered. Reported in a restrained register; no detail, no names.

Psychology Board of Australia v Schroder [2026] VCAT 473 (N Campbell, Acting Senior Member; M Power and C Manning, Health Practitioner Members; 23 June 2026) — https://jade.io/article/1233761

Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (Victoria) Act 2009 ss 5, 196. Held: a course of criminal, dishonest conduct concerning an estate — perjury across four affidavits, attempting to obtain property by deception, attempting to pervert the course of justice and subornation of perjury — is professional misconduct; orders of reprimand, disqualification, a four-year bar before applying for reinstatement, and a four-year prohibition on providing any health service; determinations protect the public and the profession and are not punitive, but a lack of insight and remorse warrants firmer deterrence.

Also on the docket (notes only): YPG v GMK [2026] VCAT 457 (the reasonable-and-proportionate possession test) — https://jade.io/article/1233741 ; Charles v Gannawarra SC [2026] VCAT 465 (a permit attaches to the land, not the person) — https://jade.io/article/1233749 ; LG (a Pseudonym) v Office of the Queensland Ombudsman [2026] QCATA 100 (the public-interest test) — https://jade.io/article/1233716

This episode of The Petal was produced by BarNet OpenLaw, the creators of JADE. The voices are AI-generated. Nothing in this program is legal advice. The Petal is an experiment and your feedback is essential.