Listen

Description

Send us Fan Mail

Your Tribunals brief for 25 June 2026 — three decisions from the civil and administrative tribunals of Queensland, New South Wales and Western Australia, on a single theme: stay inside the lines the statute draws. You cannot use one review to sneak an attack on a decision you were never allowed to challenge. An internal appeal is not a second go at the whole case. And a substitute decision-maker, spending another person's money, must ask first and account for everything. The principles, not the noise.

A note on care: one matter in this episode concerns a person under administration. It is reported in a restrained register — principle and consequence only, no detail, no parties named (the pseudonym is preserved).

In this episode:

• Queensland Building and Construction Commission v Crocker — no back-door merits review: https://jade.io/article/1234016

• Aristidi v Kitchen Connection — an internal appeal is not a second hearing: https://jade.io/article/1234010

• LJ — administration orders and spending another person's money under supervision: https://jade.io/article/1234084

Case notes

Queensland Building and Construction Commission v Crocker [2026] QCATA 101 (Senior Member Brown, Member Taylor, 1 June 2026) — https://jade.io/article/1234016

Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld) s 86(1)(g). Held (by majority): review of a scope-of-works decision is strictly confined to whether the works are reasonable and necessary; s 86(1)(g) cannot be used to challenge indirectly an antecedent decision to accept or allow a claim under the statutory insurance scheme; tribunals must not permit back door merits reviews of non-reviewable decisions; a party wishing to challenge the antecedent decision must use alternative remedies, defending recovery proceedings or judicial review, and must precisely identify the specific reviewable decision to avoid jurisdictional dismissal.

Aristidi v KWB Group Pty Ltd t/as Kitchen Connection [2026] NSWCATAP 196 (I R Coleman SC ADCJ, Principal Member; K Merrick, Senior Member; 25 June 2026) — https://jade.io/article/1234010

Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (NSW) s 80. Held: applications to adduce new evidence on appeal are refused where the material was reasonably available at first instance, the power being strictly remedial, not an opportunity to supplement a deficient evidentiary case; leave to appeal requires isolating a specific legal error rather than conflating factual disputes with questions of law, and showing that an alternative evaluative outcome was open is insufficient; and an internal tribunal appeal is not a de novo rehearing, requiring a defined legal error, a jurisdictional failure, or a substantial miscarriage of justice.

LJ [2026] WASAT 73 (Ms R Bunney, Member, 25 June 2026) — https://jade.io/article/1234084

Guardianship and Administration Act 1990 (WA) ss 16(4), 72(3), 118(2). Held: applications to authorise charitable, benevolent or ex gratia payments from the represented person's funds must be filed prospectively, as the tribunal lacks power to approve such payments retrospectively; the reimbursement of a substitute decision-maker's expenses must strictly differentiate costs reasonably incurred performing statutory functions from voluntary familial actions such as routine hospital visits; and the discretion to have legal costs of a review paid from the represented person's estate is not enlivened lightly, even where a party has acted in good faith. Reported in a restrained register; the pseudonym is preserved.

Also on the docket (notes only): Lake v Golf Australia Limited [2026] NSWCATAP 199 (what counts as a proper appeal ground) — https://jade.io/article/1234009 ; GSY v Western Sydney Local Health District [2026] NSWCATAP 200 (access to health records; apprehended bias) — https://jade.io/article/1234014

This episode of The Petal was produced by BarNet OpenLaw, the creators of JADE. The voices are AI-generated. Nothing in this program is legal advice. The Petal is an experiment and your feedback is essential.