Send us Fan Mail
A quiet day on the Victorian list, one decision, and it is the Court of Appeal on a workplace safety prosecution after a death at a camping park: the offence under s 26 of the Occupational Health and Safety Act is risk-based, so the accident was relevant to the gravity of the risk but, as led, ought to have been excluded under s 137 of the Evidence Act, and the court divided two to one on whether the verdict was open. Conviction set aside, new trial ordered. Carried at depth as a single story on the Criminal Law Desk with two Host question beats. The decision also appears in the Court of Appeal brief of the same date. Tuesday is a control day: no house spot.
Criminal Law Desk (lead).
- Yarra Valley Park Lane Holiday Park Pty Ltd v The King [2026] VSCA 233 - conviction appeal from a jury trial on a single charge under s 26 of the Occupational Health and Safety Act 2004 (Vic) after a branch fell on a tent and killed a camper; the prosecution particularised an annual arborist assessment as the only measure, it was common ground that measure would not have reduced the risk from the branch that fell, and the case concerned the other trees. (1) OHSA offences are risk-based, not outcome-based; death or injury is not an element but may bear on the existence, likelihood and gravity of the risk. (2) Evidence of the death was relevant under s 55 of the Evidence Act 2008 (Vic) to the degree of harm if the risk eventuated (s 20(2)(b) OHSA) and was not made irrelevant by an informal pre-trial concession short of a formal admission (unanimous). (3) Its probative value was low, the emphasis on the death extensive and emotive, and the evidence as led ought to have been excluded under s 137; an appellate court assesses the evidence as ultimately led, not merely the pre-trial ruling; the volume of the accident evidence and directions that did not guard against sympathy created a real risk the jury misunderstood its task, a substantial miscarriage of justice (unanimous); failure to renew the objection at trial weighs against leave but was not determinative where the failed pre-trial application dictated the forensic course. (4) By majority (Boyce and Kidd JJA), where the accused has an existing system the prosecution's burden under Baiada Poultry is to prove beyond reasonable doubt that the system was insufficient, assessed against the actual state of the workplace, not to prove counterfactually that its measure in isolation would have reduced the risk more than the accused's system in isolation; the post-accident arborist's report proved insufficiency and the verdict was open. (5) Walker JA, dissenting as to disposition, would have held that on the particulars as framed the jury had to be satisfied the specified measure alone would reduce the risk more than the existing system alone, which no witness addressed, and would have entered an acquittal. Leave granted, appeal allowed, conviction set aside, new trial ordered; the sentence application not determined. Care: a workplace fatality; the deceased is not named on air; a new trial is pending and nothing here prejudges it. JADE
Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.