Send us Fan Mail
One state, every court: the Victoria edition of 6 October 2026, six decisions of the Court of Appeal and nine of the Supreme Court. The Court of Appeal infers a freight forwarding contract from emails and paid invoices and settles the review standards for proportionate liability under the Wrongs Act; holds that family hardship in Commonwealth sentencing has two aspects, and that a judge's silence on its effect on the offender was error; and explains how the ceiling principle keeps moderating a sentence imposed after a retrial. From the Supreme Court, a prison visitor ban cannot reach video visits, procedural fairness attaches to such bans, and the Charter's protection of families is an institutional guarantee; equitable contribution is available between two wrongdoers liable to indemnify WorkCover; a wills registry's messages from China are ruled inadmissible hearsay; and the costs of a prolonged class action carriage fight. All six Court of Appeal decisions also feature in the Court of Appeal brief of the same date. Eight more decisions on the registry. House spot: a word from JADE after the opening block.
Commercial Law Desk (opening story; also in the Court of Appeal brief).
- Intelligent Scm LLC v Seaway Logistics Pty Ltd (Acn 094 204 609) [2026] VSCA 240 - leave granted on the contract and apportionment grounds, the contract ground dismissed and the apportionment ground allowed, leave refused on remoteness (Walker, Lyons and Kenny JJA): a contract may be inferred where the parties' conduct, objectively assessed as a whole, positively indicates that both considered themselves bound by sufficiently clear terms; items of conduct merely consistent with an agreement may be considered in combination, and describing such cases as rare states no legal principle; the price was established by invoices paid without objection, post-contractual conduct being admissible for that purpose; remoteness in contract requires only that loss of the general kind was within reasonable contemplation; apportionment under s 24AI of the Wrongs Act 1958 (Vic) is reviewed on the House v The King standard, but whether a party is a concurrent wrongdoer under s 24AH(1) is reviewed for correctness; the carrier was a concurrent wrongdoer for the second shipment too, and the judgment sum is to be reduced. JADE
Criminal Law Desk (also in the Court of Appeal brief).
- Douglas v The King [2026] VSCA 243 - extension of time and leave granted, appeal allowed and the applicant re-sentenced (Walker and Kidd JJA): in Commonwealth sentencing family hardship has two aspects, the effect on family members under s 16A(2)(p) of the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth), with no exceptionality threshold, and the effect of that hardship on the offender and her experience of imprisonment; silence in the reasons does not necessarily vitiate the discretion, but no inference of consideration was available where the second aspect was pressed, arguably as the focus of the plea; State cases, with their two-limb exceptional hardship test, distinguished; obiter, counsel and judges should avoid exceptionality language in Commonwealth sentencing. JADE
- Michael Kawana v The King [2026] VSCA 237 - leave to appeal against sentence granted and the appeal allowed (Emerton P, Boyce and Richards JJA): a judge sentencing after a retrial need not find the first sentence manifestly inadequate before imposing a heavier one; the first sentence is ordinarily a ceiling, departure requires an identified good reason, and imposing a higher sentence without one is specific error; once exceeded, the ceiling principle continues to moderate the sentence, so a sentence otherwise within range may be manifestly excessive; re-sentenced to a total effective sentence of 9 years 4 months. Sexual offences, reported as legal doctrine only; the complainant is not identified. JADE
Public Law Desk.
- Aeshaea v Secretary to the Department of Justice and Community Safety [2026] VSC 629 - judicial review of prison visitor bans succeeded only in part, as to video visits (Gorton J): a targeted ban under s 43(1A) of the Corrections Act 1986 (Vic) attracts the presumption of procedural fairness, the power being forward-looking and not an emergency power; the obligation did not extend to material subject to public interest immunity, matters already known or the obvious, and knowledge was inferred from the plaintiffs' unexplained failure to give evidence; the power to prohibit entering a prison as a visitor requires physical presence and does not extend to video visits, but that part of the ban was severable; under the Charter of Human Rights and Responsibilities Act 2006 (Vic), a visitor ban interferes with family under s 13(a) but was not arbitrary, and s 17(1) is an institutional guarantee rather than an individual right. JADE
Practice and Procedure Desk.
- Victorian WorkCover Authority v Granted Access Pty Ltd (Equitable contribution) [2026] VSC 640 - equitable contribution granted (Gorton J): two parties each liable to indemnify the Authority under s 369 of the Workplace Injury Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 2013 (Vic) for the same payments bear a common burden, so contribution is available to the one the Authority chose to pursue; differing statutory ceilings differ only in quantity, not quality; the right may be declared before payment where payment is imminent; contribution fixed at 30/95ths, the ratio of the parties' factor X values, until the co-defendant reaches its ceiling, with no contribution to interest for a period when only the paying party was liable. JADE
- Dacovic v Li (Evidence ruling) [2026] VSC 633 - objections upheld (Ierodiaconou AsJ): messages from a Chinese wills service centre and notary office were hearsay; the business records exception in s 69 of the Evidence Act 2008 (Vic) can extend to a foreign institution's communications, is not confined to first-hand hearsay and needs no identified maker, but the Court declined to infer the makers' personal knowledge; s 64 applies only to first-hand hearsay and requires evidence that calling the witness is not reasonably practicable, and a witness's stated non-cooperation is not taken at face value; alternatively, the communications would have been excluded under s 135 as unfairly prejudicial. JADE
- Edwards v Hyundai Motor Co Australia Pty Ltd; Sims v Kia Australia Pty Ltd (Ruling No 4) [2026] VSC 586 - costs of a carriage dispute between competing group proceedings (M Osborne J, 11 September 2026): the usual position is that the unsuccessful contender bears its own costs, but where it unnecessarily prolongs the dispute it pays the additional costs of the protraction, here standard costs from November 2023 to June 2025; no non-party costs order against a litigation funder whose role was a contingent funding commitment and a commonplace affidavit, a carriage dispute being anterior to the litigation; costs fixed in a gross sum rather than a projected fifteen-month taxation. JADE
Registry (Court of Appeal; then Supreme Court, list-only or synopsis-only, no outcome stated).
- Tayeh v Vorchheimer [2026] VSCA 244 - security for costs of $45,000 ordered against a bankrupt applicant for leave to appeal from VCAT; impecuniosity significant but not decisive on appeal, and stultification not shown given his crowdfunding history (Niall CJ and Kenny JA). JADE
- West v The King [2026] VSCA 242 - Commonwealth child abuse material offences; leave to appeal against sentence refused (Walker and Kidd JJA). JADE
- John B Yaacov Myers v Medical Board of Australia [2026] VSCA 241 - extension of time to seek leave to appeal from security for costs orders refused, the substantial delay not satisfactorily explained (Beach JA). JADE
- Re Furry Meatball Pty Ltd (in liq) [2026] VSC 632 - synopsis only: the framework for freezing orders against a prospective judgment debtor and a third party, in a liquidator's challenge to a property transfer alleged to be a sham. JADE
- Re Lion Property Group Pty Ltd [2026] VSC 639 - list only (personal insolvency). JADE
- Rich v Secretary to the Department of Justice and Community Safety [2026] VSC 638 - list only (interlocutory applications). JADE
- Koca v Koca [2026] VSC 642 - list only (caveats). JADE
- Wallace v Crompton [2026] VSC 644 - list only (estate administration). JADE
Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.