Send us Fan Mail
One state, every court: the Victoria edition of 7 October 2026, seven decisions of the Supreme Court and none from the Court of Appeal. A council's emergency works under an order never served were a trespass, though its entry was lawful, with one dollar in nominal damages and no damages under the Charter; a Commercial List trial on whether a boardroom conversation ever happened, and how courts test an unrecorded oral agreement; and judicial advice on a will that gave a widower a right to reside, not a life interest. Four more decisions on the registry. House spot: a word from JADE after the opening block.
Public Law Desk (opening story).
- Giurina v Greater Geelong City Council [No 2] [2026] VSC 646 - claim in trespass allowed as to the works, nominal damages of $1, otherwise dismissed (Gray J): the power of entry in s 228J of the Building Act 1993 (Vic) does not require prior service of an emergency order, but the power in s 121 to carry out works is enlivened only after the order is served and the time for compliance has expired, on the ordinary meaning of fails and the principle of legality, so works done under an unserved order were a trespass actionable without proof of damage; compensatory damages for torts affecting land turn on the true loss, not a dichotomy of diminution in value or reinstatement cost; no aggravated or exemplary damages; s 39(3) of the Charter of Human Rights and Responsibilities Act 2006 (Vic) precludes damages for breach of the Charter. JADE
Practice and Procedure Desk.
- Maradox Pty Ltd v Normet Industries Nominees Pty Ltd (No 2) [2026] VSC 637 - proceeding dismissed (Waller J): where a conversation is the foundation of the claim, s 140 of the Evidence Act 2008 (Vic) requires actual persuasion on the whole of the evidence, including contemporaneous documents, conduct and commercial context, not merely which witness is believed; a conversation cannot be found where its only identified location did not exist in usable form; progressively more convenient recollection suggests reconstruction; a paper prepared years later for a tax investigation is not reliable evidence of what was agreed, particularly where a principal author conceded under s 128 protection that its operative statements were untrue, though no finding of fraud or knowing dishonesty was made; obiter, silence amounts to assent only in limited circumstances. JADE
Commercial Law Desk.
- Re the Estate of Sharon Louise Walker [2026] VSC 653 - judicial advice given (Barrett AsJ, 18 September 2026): estate debts are paid in preference to gifts, including out of specifically devised property, so the executor may sell despite a pending family provision application, which operates only on the net estate; a direction to permit the husband to reside rent-free until he vacates or needs full-time care confers a personal right of residence, not a life interest; under the rule in Cherry v Boultbee his residuary share may be withheld until his untaxed costs liability is quantified; nieces and nephews excludes step-relations; a thirty-day survivorship condition, not survival to distribution. JADE
Registry (list only, no outcome stated).
- Hu v HWL Ebsworth Lawyers [2026] VSC 652 - list only (civil appeals, appeal grounds; Fary AsJ). JADE
- Wallan Pastoral Pty Ltd v Matzuri Pty Ltd [2026] VSC 649 - list only (interlocutory orders; Stynes J). JADE
- Nautilus Insurance Pte Ltd v Underwriters of Lloyd's Syndicate NVA 2007 [2026] VSC 655 - list only (extension of time; M Osborne J). JADE
- DPP v Curtis [2026] VSC 648 - list only (sentencing; Incerti J). JADE
Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.