Send us Fan Mail
One state, every court: the Victoria edition of 8 October 2026, one decision of the Court of Appeal and three of the Supreme Court. A guarantor illiterate in English, who signed only the signature pages, could not resist summary judgment on a mortgage over his home: agency, misrepresentation, non est factum and unconscionability all failed, and the all monies clause secured the guarantee. Then an extension of time to appeal in long-running estate litigation, refused as futile, with grounds too vague to identify an error and no apprehended bias in adverse procedural rulings; that decision also features in today's Court of Appeal brief, here with the Victorian angle. Two more decisions on the registry. House spot: a word from JADE after the opening block.
Commercial Law Desk (opening story).
- Judo Bank Pty Ltd v Sun [2026] VSC 651 - summary judgment for the lender (Hetyey AsJ): a bare assertion that a third party acted as the lender's agent, without material facts as to authority, control or holding out, is fanciful, so the third party's representations were not attributable to the lender under s 18 of the Australian Consumer Law or s 12DA of the ASIC Act; non est factum requires a belief that the document was fundamentally or radically different from what was signed, and a director and experienced borrower who signed single signature pages without requesting full copies was careless; special disadvantage from illiteracy in English was overcome by interpreted independent legal advice, and without knowledge in the lender the defence could not defeat indefeasibility under s 42 of the Transfer of Land Act 1958 (Vic); an all monies clause is construed by its language, the instrument as a whole and the purpose of the security, and here secured the guarantee. JADE
Practice and Procedure Desk (also in today's Court of Appeal brief).
- Morris v Morris [2026] VSCA 256 - extension of time and stay refused (Walker JA, on the papers): in exercising the discretion under r 64.05(1)(b), read with s 7 of the Civil Procedure Act 2010 (Vic), time will not be extended where a proposed appeal is so devoid of merit that an extension would be futile, even where the delays are relatively moderate; vague, rolled-up and unparticularised grounds that do not identify the decision or the error are hopeless; disagreement with a judicial officer's procedural decisions, or prior involvement in a disputed procedural course, does not found a reasonable apprehension of bias; prejudice to the estate, including erosion of its funds and repeated deferral of a family provision trial under pt IV of the Administration and Probate Act 1958 (Vic), further supported refusal. JADE
Registry (list only, no outcome stated).
- R v Hagi Ali [2026] VSC 647 - list only (sentence appeal; Croucher J). JADE
- Re Heffernan [2026] VSC 641 - list only (bail application; Elliott J). JADE
Full typeset judgments are in the Judicial Ledger. Theme music by Michael Green SC.