The suits were sharp, the jokes were chaotic, and the wings were hot—perfect conditions for the Ponsies, our annual Game of the Year awards engineered by Seb’s “committee” of number-crunchers. We opened the books on four very different gaming diets and found a story that spanned cozy farms, roguelike obsessions, comeback ports, and a JRPG that might define a generation.
Our Switch 2 streak is undeniable, but the data went deeper: indie love runs strong, platform diversity got its due, and yes, we called out retro comfort when it smothered discovery. After tiebreak fireworks, the top ten settled into a shape that actually makes sense: Persona 4 at #10 for its lasting impact, Mafia: The Old Country at #9, and a surprisingly excellent Cyberpunk 2077 port at #8 that finally lets you enjoy the dream without patches. Story of Seasons: Grand Bazaar brought a fresh market-day loop at #7, while Witcher 3’s “Switcher 3” mystique refused to die at #6.
Then the momentum hit hard. Pokemon ZA fought its way to #5—underrated, heartfelt, and worth your time. No Man’s Sky reclaimed #4 on the strength of its transformative Corvette update, a masterclass in live-game redemption. Expedition 33 soared to #3 with world-class design and a new bar for JRPGs. Ball XP broke the internet in our little universe at #2—breakout-meets-roguelike with pinball-flavored mid-run strategy and “one more run” magic across platforms. And the Ponsie for Game of the Year? Hades 2. Leaner file size, deeper systems, immaculate performance, and that irresistible loop that defines why we play.
We locked in new rules to keep the Ponsies sharp—no repeat nominations without real evolution and a five-year eligibility window—while spinning forward to 2026: GTA 6 if it lands, Fable as a sleeper, Wolverine as a prestige swing. Looking for a to-play list you’ll actually finish? Start with Ball XP, give Pokemon ZA a fair shake, make time for Expedition 33, and clear a week for Hades 2.
If this ride made you laugh, argue, or add a game to your queue, tap follow, share with a friend, and drop your own top three. Which pick would you move up?
Join our fantastic discord
https://discord.gg/v7RFSUcG
If link has expired then message us at questions@unofficialcontrollerpodcast.com
or DM us on instagram or X and we'll send you an invite.
Cheers gamers!
Subscription Tiers
$3
Name read out on every show
Access to unglorious chat section of discord
Quarterly Zoom meet up
$5
Name read out on every show
Access to unglorious chat section of discord
Quarterly Zoom meet up
A single item of yearly limited art merch
$8
Name read out on every show
Access to unglorious chat section of discord
Quarterly Zoom meet up
A single item of yearly limited art merch
Yearly art merch mug
$10
Name read out on every show
Access to unglorious chat section of discord
Quarterly Zoom meet up
A single item of yearly limited art merch
Yearly art merch mug
Yearly art merch t-shirt
Thanks to all who subscribe, it means the world to us and really helps us keep the shows going.
