Listen

Description

 

Have you ever attended a music competition, heard the winners announced, and thought, "Really? That's not what I experienced!"

Maybe there's a reason for that.

In this episode of Intentional Musicianship, Jeff Price explores the difference between how we evaluate musical excellence and how audiences experience a performance.

A 2023 study examining 370 editions of international classical music competitions found that professional juries and audiences selected the same winner only about 38% of the time.

The research doesn't establish why their preferences differed, but it raises an interesting question: Are we measuring everything that matters in a musical performance?

From concert band festivals and traditional choral assessments to show choir and musical theater, different disciplines emphasize different performance standards. While technical fundamentals help musicians develop excellence, visual communication, storytelling, characterization, and audience engagement are often more deeply integrated into some performance settings than others.

And as the saying goes, what gets measured gets done.

Preparing to earn an excellent rating isn't necessarily the same thing as preparing to connect with an audience.

In this episode, Jeff invites musicians, educators, and directors to consider three ideas:

  1. Understand what you're measuring. Rubrics and adjudication standards help develop musicianship, identify weaknesses, and recognize achievement. But no single evaluation system necessarily captures the entire performance experience.
  2. Learn from other musical disciplines. Show choir and musical theater integrate visual communication, expression, and storytelling throughout their performances. What might instrumental and traditional choral ensembles learn from those approaches?
  3. Prepare for your audience, not just your evaluation. Technical excellence gives musicians the tools to communicate, but meaningful connections depend on how those abilities are shared onstage.

An excellent rating can recognize musical achievement. But the experience an audience takes home may be what encourages them to return, become fans, and develop a lasting relationship with the performers.

Perfection doesn't equal connection.

The next time you're preparing for a performance, consider how much time you're spending meeting evaluation standards compared with developing the experience you want to share with your audience.

Both matter.

Study mentioned

Asmat, R., Borowiecki, K. J., & Law, M. T. (2023).

Do Experts and Laypersons Differ? Some Evidence from International Classical Music Competitions.

Related Episodes

Episode 52: Do You Have a Roadmap for Your Performance?

Understanding your musical destination, shaping phrases, and communicating a larger musical story rather than simply performing individual notes.

Episode 50: What Makes a Great National Anthem Performance?

Considering the purpose of a performance and how musical choices can serve the audience and the occasion.

Episode 48: Are You Fixing the Problem or the Symptom?

Examining how musicians identify and address issues during musical preparation.

Visit intentionalmusicianship.com for more episodes and resources.

#IntentionalMusicianship #PerfectionDoesntEqualConnection #MusicEducation #MusicPerformance #Musicianship #AudienceEngagement #StagePresence #MusicAdjudication #ConcertBand #ChoralMusic #ShowChoir #MusicalTheater #MusicTeachers #MusicalStorytelling #CenterStage #musicalkrubrik

Welcome to Intentional Musicianship!

The Intentional Musicianship podcast, hosted by Jeff Price, is designed for musicians who aim to elevate their performance on multiple levels. This isn't your average "how to play better" show. We go beyond technique to focus on improving your stage presence, musical storytelling, audience communication, and breaking genre norms to form a deeper connection with your audience. Whether you're an amateur, a seasoned professional, or a music educator, our goal is to help you achieve a greater return on your performance investment. This could range from building a more committed fanbase to increasing merchandise sales. We utilize an adult learning model, so we assume you already have a foundation in performance and aim to refine and innovate on your existing skills. The ultimate goal? To create unforgettable experiences that not only entertain but engage your audience on a deeper level. The call to action is to foster community, encourage engagement, and provide actionable insights, all of which can be further explored at intentionalmusicianship.com.