Host, Michael Dargie, begins by sharing his own daily wellness routine: a glass of water, a multivitamin, vitamin D, magnesium, omega-3, creatine before the gym, a protein shake, and a high-fibre breakfast. It leads to a question many of us have asked ourselves: which of these supplements are genuinely supporting our health, and which might be unnecessary?
Joining Michael are Loreen Wales, CEO of My Viva and Registered Dietitian, and Dr. Prerana Rudrapatna, My Viva's Chief Medical Liaison, for a thoughtful discussion on the role supplements can—and can't—play in supporting long-term health. Together, they explore the evidence behind popular supplements, the importance of prioritizing nutrient-rich whole foods, and when supplementation may be appropriate, particularly for those managing chronic conditions or addressing specific nutrient deficiencies. The conversation also highlights the importance of quality, safety, potential drug interactions, and seeking guidance from qualified healthcare professionals rather than relying on marketing claims or social media trends.
Whether your supplement shelf is overflowing or you're simply trying to make informed choices, this episode offers practical, evidence-based advice to help you navigate an often-confusing marketplace. The takeaway is refreshingly balanced: supplements have an important role when used appropriately, but a healthy, varied diet remains the foundation of lifelong wellness.
Key Highlights
Food first, always. There is no supplement that delivers real benefit on top of a poor diet. Balanced eating is the foundation; supplements fill genuine gaps, they don't replace the work. Loreen's blunt verdict on the "supplement, supplement, supplement… oh, and maybe some food" pattern: "Completely backwards."
Michael's stack held up surprisingly well. The things he's already taking — omega-3, magnesium, vitamin D, creatine, a 50+ multivitamin — happen to be among the most-studied supplements with the strongest evidence. Cautiously validated.
Third-party testing is the single most important filter. Price does not equal quality. Look for NSF Certified for Sport, USP, or Informed Choice on the label, and use ConsumerLab.com to check for contaminants. Loreen's pick people love to sneer at — Centrum — earns her respect precisely because it's been third-party tested for decades, is affordable, and is available everywhere. (No kickbacks; she's said it her whole career.)
"Natural" does not mean "no interactions." Dr. Prerana's key safety point: supplements are metabolized like drugs. St. John's Wort, for example, can ramp up the cytochrome system and quietly weaken oral contraceptives and blood thinners like warfarin — meaning treatment failure you'd never see coming. Always tell your treating team everything you're taking.
The industry used to be the Wild West — and still has bad actors. When Loreen started 28 years ago, there were essentially no supplement regulations ("Someone could put dirt in a capsule and make any claim they wanted"). Canada now requires Natural Product Numbers and evidence behind claims, but contamination and mislabelling persist — from banned substances that get athletes suspended, to "olive oil" that isn't even olive oil.
Blood panels won't hand you all the answers. For the vast majority of nutrients, serum levels don't reflect true body stores — your body pulls from reserves to keep your blood normal. Loreen (the "zinc queen" of her kidney-ward days) explains you often learn more from symptoms than a lab draw. Iron is the classic trap: check ferritin (stores), not just serum iron. Some markers are genuinely worth testing — vitamin D, B12, iron/ferritin — especially on medications like metformin, which depletes B12.
Omega-3: right idea, rethink the source. Supplements matter most for people who don't eat fatty fish. But "eat fish three times a week" is not sustainable or affordable for landlocked populations — and the oceans can't supply it. Plant sources like flaxseed, chia, and hemp hearts are nutrient-dense alternatives.
The influencer problem — where the experts respectfully clashed. Dr. Prerana argued social media is unavoidable and can be a starting point if you verify against evidence and your care team. Loreen pushed back hard on air: run in the opposite direction of anyone saying "I took this and look what happened." Her bake-show analogy landed the nuance — don't obsess over the perfect vanilla extract before you've learned to make the cake.
The lightning round. Creatine — yes (5 g max; promising brain-fog research in women). Vitamin D — yes, especially over 50, darker skin tones, and Canadian winters (Oct–Mar we can't synthesize it; get 15–20 min of sun in summer). Protein powder — a tool, not a meal replacement; buy third-party tested. Collagen — thin evidence. Daily electrolytes — no, unless you're sweating heavily; skip the Gatorade for kids at meals. NAD+/resveratrol — expensive hype, minimal evidence. Lion's Mane/nootropics — unproven. Ashwagandha — some real research, but liver-toxicity cases exist and it can't outrun a bad lifestyle. L-citrulline — talk to a sports dietitian.
You can't outrun a bad lifestyle. Loreen's closing sermon ties it to the pillars: you can't out-supplement poor diet, no exercise, bad sleep, unmanaged stress, or isolation. A pill won't do the work a life change does.
See the right professional. A crucial nuance: many doctors — and even many dietitians — don't specialize in supplements. Ask directly how comfortable your provider is with this topic, and seek out someone (a dietitian, a sports dietitian, or a pharmacist) who genuinely digs into the science.
Questions People Are Afraid to Ask
"Can I just get a blood panel to show what I'm missing?" People do it — and Loreen visibly winced. For 99% of nutrients, serum levels won't tell you much because your body draws from stores. Start with diet and symptoms, and test the few markers that actually matter (vitamin D, B12, ferritin).
"What supplement do you secretly wish people would stop buying without talking to a professional first?" Loreen: any supplement that isn't third-party tested — that's the real danger. Dr. Prerana: honestly, all of them — see a registered dietitian first and build a plan around your actual health history.
Links & Resources Mentioned
Michael's picks referenced on the show — Centrum and Vega — are noted here as the ones he mentioned taking, not as endorsements.
Disclaimer: This podcast is for informational and educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice. Always consult your treating physician or a qualified health-care provider before making any changes to your diet, exercise, or lifestyle.