Description

The bracket is here, the group chats are unhinged, and Round 1 of the CFP is basically a four-game stress test for your nerves, your bankroll discipline, and your ability to not overreact to the first busted coverage.

Marc & Scotty break down the slate with the usual recipe: matchup edges, pace, red zone math, and the “what’s the cleanest way this game goes sideways?” conversation for every favorite.

Locks & Leans We’re Watching

Bama vs. OU — Total Under (and 1H Under)
Marc and Scotty are together on this one: they like the full game Under, and they also like the 1st Half Under. Round 1 often starts tight and cautious—scripted drives, conservative play-calling, field position, and a whole lot of “don’t be the guy who gifts a touchdown.” If this turns into punts + long fields + red zone tightening, a slow first half is very live.

Miami vs. Texas A&M — Miami as a Live Dog
They also see Miami as a live dog against the Aggies. Not a “cute dog,” but the kind that can hang around and make this uncomfortable if Miami hits a couple explosives and keeps A&M from turning it into a trench-warfare game. If A&M sputters early or Miami’s speed shows up in space, the favorite can feel real pressure late.

Chalk Takes (Favorites to Handle Business)

JMU vs. Oregon — Chalk Holds
Both think chalk will hold in JMU–Oregon. The read: Oregon’s overall talent and depth should show over four quarters, and if the favorite plays clean early, this one can turn into the kind of “slow squeeze” where the underdog is fighting uphill the whole second half.

Tulane vs. Ole Miss — Chalk Holds
Same stance in Tulane–Ole Miss: both expect the favorite to take care of business. The idea is less about disrespecting Tulane and more about acknowledging what usually wins in playoff-style games—line play, speed on the edges, and the ability to finish drives when the field shrinks.

What We’re Debating

• 
  Round 1 tempo: Who actually wants to play fast, and who’s going full “don’t lose it early” mode?
  
  
• 
  Red zone reality: Playoff games are often decided by TDs vs. FGs more than highlight plays.
  
  
• 
  Coaching decision tax: conservative punts, “settle for 3,” and the one 4th-and-2 that swings everything.
  
  

Betting Card Summary (Early)

• 
  Bama–OU: Full Game Under
  
  
• 
  Bama–OU: 1H Under
  
  
• 
  Miami +points (Live Dog vs A&M)
  
  
• 
  Oregon to advance / chalk side leans
  
  
• 
  Ole Miss to advance / chalk side leans
  
  

Closing Thought

Round 1 is where “built for this” gets real. Everybody’s confident until the first busted protection, the first tipped ball, and the first time the underdog starts believing.

Buckle up. CFP season is here—and the board is about to get violent.