Recovered (mostly) from the flu, Joe picks a match with one of his favorite wrestlers that he doesn't remember ever having seen. Jason -- possibly too healthy -- picks a match that's just one of his favorites ever. And the RMG, well, the RMG does its thing. Luckily one of the competitors in the random match allow your hosts to pontificate on the talent and standing of someone Joe thinks is a long-time dark horse (see, Jason's not the only one who can do throwbacks!) candidate for G.O.A.T: The Natural, the most controversial superstar in WWE history, the son of the son of a plumber. Overall it's kind of a rocky return, but we're glad to be back!
- Joe's pick: Faarooq vs Bart Gunn, Raw 194, January 20, 1997
- Jason's pick: Stunning Steve Austin vs Dustin Rhodes, WCW World Television Championship match, Halloween Havoc 1991
- RMG's pick: Goldust vs Ultimate Warrior, King of the Ring tournament qualifiers, Raw 161, May 27, 1996