What at first seems like three totally incongruous match picks becomes a story about the special energy and the legacy of Extreme Championship Wrestling. We've got two fatal four-way matches. We've got the Whole F'n Show vs the New F'n Show. And we've got... Four the Hard Way. Yeah, that's a match -- and it's the best hardcore match Bobby Heenan has ever seen. Do our hosts agree with The Brain? You'll have to listen to find out, or I guess you could just look at the people in it, and the show it was a part of, and kind of figure it out for yourselves. This one runs over an hour and is, in this neutral-voiced description-writer's opinion, up there around second-best or best episode yet!
- Joe's pick: Adrian Neville vs Tyson Kidd vs Tyler Breeze vs Sami Zayn, Fatal 4-Way for the NXT Championship, NXT TakeOver: Fatal 4-Way, Sept 11, 2014
- Jason's pick: Rob Van Dam vs Jerry Lynn, for theTelevision Championship, Living Dangerously 1999, March 21, 1999
- RMG's pick: Fit Finlay vs Meng vs Norman Smiley vs Brian Knobbs, Fatal 4-Way for the WCW Hardcore Championship, Souled Out 2000, Jan 16, 2000