Gary and Selena unpack their night at Hamilton and everything that followed, from struggling to understand the lyrics to questioning why certain cultural experiences are treated as untouchable. The conversation drifts into live theater expectations, nostalgia driven hype, and how something widely praised can still feel alienating in real time.
From there Gary and Selena spiral into period logistics, awkward bodily realities, conspiracy theories, elite myths, celebrity obsession, and historical figures behaving badly. The episode moves freely between humor, confusion, irritation, and curiosity, capturing the feeling of sitting nearby while two people talk through what confused them, annoyed them, and stuck in their heads long after the night was over.
