The Gruesome Twosome present their scariest epsiode yet! The guys talk petrifying fall paddles (1:14). Tim presents a Halloween concoction - a potion if you will - that Jack Nicholson would love (11:09). Colin talks about some near-zombies he saw in concert before the guys discuss Tom Petty's paddling songs, and his spooky songs (22:38). Colin administers the Bob Dylan or Bro Country exam (32:25) and discusses the pains of aging he realized were affecting him during a golf outing (42:00). Vampires and other frightening things are making their way to the small screen (59:43) and Will Ferrell's movies are ranked (63:38).