The podcast details the shocking murder of Ray Trusca aboard a cruise ship during his 20th-anniversary celebration in 2001. The episode, titled "Secret Gay Love Triangle Turns Deadly on Cruise Ship," uncovers a complex web of clandestine relationships involving Trusca, his wife Dina, a colleague named Bob Hackles, and another man, Carl Bowhines. The narrative follows the investigation by the FBI, highlighting the discovery of crucial evidence and the interrogation of the suspects.