Reviewed by Dr Reza Lankarani, General SurgeonFounder | Surgical Pioneering Newsletter and Podcast Series Editorial Board Member | Genesis Journal of Surgery and Medicine· Online Publication Date: September 9, 2025· DOI: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2025.30787· Journal: JAMA Network OpenConcise Overview:This large, retrospective cohort study aimed to determine if bariatric surgery reduces the risk of developing new obesity-related metabolic comorbidities compared to a structured medical weight management program (WMP) alone.· Key Findings: Over a 5-year period, veterans who underwent bariatric surgery (Roux-en-Y gastric bypass or sleeve gastrectomy) had a significantly lower risk of developing new-onset type 2 diabetes (79% lower risk), hypertension (59% lower), hyperlipidemia (51% lower), obstructive sleep apnea (57% lower), and metabolic liver disease (MASLD, 40% lower) compared to a propensity score-matched cohort enrolled only in the WMP.· Methods: The study analyzed data from 269,470 veterans in the Veterans Health Administration (VHA) system between 2008 and 2023. Using sophisticated statistical techniques (risk-set propensity score matching), the authors compared 5,813 surgical patients to a carefully matched control group from the 263,657 patients in the WMP, accounting for factors like age, BMI, and existing comorbidities.· Conclusions: The study strongly supports bariatric surgery not only as a treatment for existing metabolic diseases but, crucially, as a powerful preventive measure against the development of new ones. It positions surgery as a durable strategy for long-term risk mitigation in patients with obesity.2. Detailed Assessment of Strengths and WeaknessesStrengths:· Large Sample Size and Long Follow-up: With nearly 270,000 patients and a median follow-up of over 9 years, the study has tremendous power to detect differences in outcomes that smaller, shorter trials cannot.· Robust Methodology: The use of risk-set propensity score matching is a major strength. This advanced technique accounts for the fact that surgical patients spent time in the WMP before surgery, allowing for a more accurate "like-for-like" comparison with controls who had been in the program for an equivalent amount of time. This minimizes selection bias.· Clinically Relevant Outcomes: Focusing on the incidence (new development) of major comorbidities addresses a critical question in patient counseling: "Will this surgery prevent me from getting diabetes in the future?"· Real-World Data: Utilizing the VHA database provides insights into the effectiveness of these interventions in a broad, real-world population beyond the controlled environment of a randomized clinical trial (RCT).· Subgroup Analysis: The authors responsibly conducted a separate analysis on female veterans, confirming that the benefits held true in this demographic despite their underrepresentation in the VHA system.Weaknesses:· Retrospective Design: Despite advanced statistics, this remains an observational study. It can demonstrate association but not definitive causation. Unmeasured confounding factors (e.g., patient motivation, socioeconomic stability, diet/exercise adherence outside the program) could influence the results.· Generalizability: The VHA population is overwhelmingly male and older than the typical bariatric surgery candidate. While the female subgroup analysis is reassuring, the findings may not be fully generalizable to the broader, younger, and predominantly female population seeking bariatric surgery.· Missing Data on Contemporary Treatments: The study period (2008-2023) largely predates the widespread use of highly effective GLP-1 agonist medications (e.g., semaglutide, tirzepatide). The control group (WMP) did not systematically include these modern pharmacotherapies, which are now a standard of care. This is the study's most significant limitation, as it compares surgery to an outdated medical management paradigm.· Selection Bias: Patients chosen for surgery are a highly selected group who have met strict medical and psychological criteria and have navigated complex healthcare pathways. This inherent selection bias is difficult to fully eliminate statistically.· WMP Engagement Variability: The study could not fully account for the variable levels of engagement and adherence within the WMP control group, which could dilute the observed effect.3. Comparison with Latest Related StudiesThis study fills a specific niche. While many studies have shown bariatric surgery leads to the remission of existing diseases, few large-scale studies have quantified its power to prevent new ones.Table: Comparison with Key Recent Studies on Bariatric Surgery OutcomesGraphical Representation of Key Finding (Risk Reduction):This bar chart visually summarizes the core finding of the Bader et al. study—the significant reduction in the risk of developing new metabolic diseases following bariatric surgery compared to medical management.4. Brief Scholarly Review and CommentSignificance & Impact: This is a highly significant study that provides the most comprehensive evidence to date on the preventive power of bariatric surgery. It moves the conversation beyond remission and into the realm of primary and secondary prevention for metabolic diseases. The robust methodology and immense sample size make its findings compelling. It offers powerful data for clinicians counseling patients who are on the fence about surgery, highlighting the long-term health perils of not undergoing surgery.Future Research Directions: Future work must compare the effectiveness of bariatric surgery head-to-head with modern medical management that includes GLP-1 agonists. Other key directions include:1. Cost-Effectiveness Analysis: Quantifying the long-term healthcare cost savings from preventing multiple chronic diseases.2. Risk Prediction Models: Using this data to build tools that predict an individual patient's risk of developing specific comorbidities, further personalizing treatment recommendations.3. Mechanistic Studies: Further elucidating the weight-loss-independent mechanisms (e.g., hormonal changes) through which surgery provides this profound metabolic benefit.Final Expert Perspective for Patients and the Public:"In simple terms, this important study tells us that weight-loss surgery is much more than a procedure to help people lose weight. It's a powerful tool that can significantly shield individuals from developing serious health problems like diabetes, high blood pressure, heart disease, and sleep apnea in the future.The research showed that compared to people who only participated in a structured weight management program, those who had surgery were up to 80% less likely to develop these conditions over the next five years. Think of it as a long-term investment in your health—surgery doesn't just treat existing issues; it actively helps prevent new ones from starting.While healthy eating and exercise are always the foundation of good health, this study confirms that for many people with severe obesity, surgery offers a level of protection against future disease that lifestyle changes alone may not achieve. It's a crucial option to discuss with your doctor to understand your personal risks and benefits."Reza Lankarani M.D To access additional details, please refer to the Surgical Pioneering Podcast Series application available at the following link:https://surgicalpioneer.codeadx.me/#bariatricsurgery #bariatricsurgeryjourney #bariatrics #diabetes #diabetescontrol #diabetesmanagement #diabetesremission #gastricsleeve #healthrecovery #healthrisks #heartdisease #howtoloseweight #metabolicsurgery #metabolicsyndrome #obesity #obesitysurgery #obesitytreatment #surgery #surgeryrecovery #surgicalintervention #surgicalweightloss #weightloss #weightlossjourney #weightlosssurgery #weightlosstips #weightlosstransformation
Get full access to Reza Lankarani at lankarani.substack.com/subscribe
Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/surgical-pioneering-podcast--6733149/support.
Dr. Reza Lankarani, a surgeon and musician, has released a new album showcasing a diverse range of musical styles, from soulful ballads to high-energy tracks. His music, available on iOS and Android platforms, is characterized as a deeply personal exploration, reflecting his unique perspectives as both a medical professional and a dedicated artist.
Lankarani's music is described as a powerful exploration of identity, self-expression, and the struggle against societal expectations, blending various genres
including folk, rock, and even jazz fusion.
Reza Lankarani's music offers a compelling exploration of the struggle for self-identity in the face of societal pressures, employing powerful metaphors of masks and chisels to represent the inherent pain of conformity. His compositions reveal the internal conflict between externally imposed roles and one's authentic self, underscoring the universal experience of feeling constrained by external judgments. Ultimately, however, Lankarani's music celebrates resilience and the reclamation of personal narrative, affirming the transformative power of self-discovery and authenticity. Through evocative imagery and profound emotional depth, his songs provide a transformative journey toward self-actualization within a society that often seeks to define us.
