In which the afflicted Sacristan is discovered drenched and disoriented, recounting an uncanny tale that divides opinion within the monastery, while Father Eustace grows intrigued by the mention of a forbidden vernacular Bible and prepares for a resolveful journey to Glendearg. The monastery’s authorities grapple with suspicion, superstition, and the delicate handling of scandal as they navigate the tensions between sacred duties and human frailty.