Listen

Description

Eric and John ask when AI sharpens our thinking, when it weakens it, and how to keep practicing the skills we want to keep.

Summary

AI helped Eric pull and vet a list of logos for a designer at Vercel, and it only took minutes. That started a conversation about how fast AI can help us do work, but the designer took it in a different direction: the time saved was wonderful, but he could feel his own critical thinking starting to slip.

Eric and John use that exchange and a study of knowledge workers to ask what happens when we let AI do more of our thinking. They explore confidence in AI, the difference between extending your abilities and losing a skill, and why generative AI changes the old automation question. They end with grammar lessons, writing without AI, and a surprisingly useful comparison to doing the dishes.

In this episode

00:49: Minutes saved, thinking skipped?

07:54: What the study says about critical thinking

13:34: Confidence changes how carefully we check

21:06: How generative AI differs from earlier automation

27:49: Leave room for your own thinking

30:21: What doing the dishes teaches us about practice

36:31: Become a better writer, not just a faster one

Mentioned

Eric brought Lee et al., CHI 2025, The Impact of Generative AI on Critical Thinking: Self-Reported Reductions in Cognitive Effort and Confidence Effects From a Survey of Knowledge Workers to the conversation. Eric and John discuss its finding that greater confidence in AI is associated with less critical thinking. The study reports people's experiences; it does not establish that AI inevitably causes lasting skill loss.

The study cites Lisanne Bainbridge's 1983 paper Ironies of Automation, which Eric uses to ask what makes AI different from earlier automation.

Eric's opening story comes from preparing keynote graphics at Vercel.