Shows
Why Am I a Mets Fan?DO OR DIE: It's NOW or NEVER for the Mets' Playoff HopesSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are back and it is the last week of the regular season for the New York Mets. With six games to go, the Mets are outside of the MLB playoff picture looking in - currently tied for the third NL Wild Card, but the Reds hold the tiebreaker. Can this team make it in? And if they don't, who's to blame?
00:00-8:02: The Mets fall out of the playoff picture. What does this team DO WELL?
8:03-13:17: Sunday's Mets mess - how is Cedric Mullins so bad?
13:18-17:30: Looking ahead to the last week...
2025-09-2323 minWhy Am I a Mets Fan?COLLAPSE: Will the Mets MISS the PLAYOFFS?Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are absolutely perplexed by the New York Mets. After losing eight straight, the Mets are desperately clinging to the third NL Wild Card. Can they hold on with 12 games to go? What went wrong in Philadelphia? What do we do with Jonah Tong? And where is this team's HEART?
00:00-7:10: The mathematics of where the NL Wild Card race stands: tiebreakers, probability, etc.
7:11-9:43: Meltdown in Philadelphia
9:44-16:35: Jacob DeGrom homecoming, Jonah Tong disaster....should the Mets allow Tong to make his next start?
16:36-17:50: Sproat's Saturday start
17:51-24:50: What is WRONG with this...
2025-09-1629 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?Sproat (mostly) SHINES in debut, Senga to SYRACUSE, Phillies on DECKSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are back to discuss the Mets' new trio of homegrown starters: Brandon Sproat, Nolan McLean, and Jonah Tong have ALL made their Major League debuts within the last three weeks. Analyzing Sproat's debut, McLean's mound presence, and a whole lot more - who would the Mets throw in a three game series if the playoffs started today?
00:00-2:43: Where the PLAYOFF PICTURE stands TODAY
2:44-7:09: SPROAT'S DEBUT: Carries a no-hitter into the sixth, his journey to get the call
7:10-10:30: Kodai Senga ACCEPTS demotion to Triple-A SYRACUSE
10:31-15:42: Mets lose two of three to...
2025-09-0826 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?TONG, MCLEAN, & PRAY FOR RAIN: Can the Mets HOLD ON to a PLAYOFF spot?Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are back to discuss...you guessed it...another up and down week for the New York Mets. After momentum reaches an all-time high with a sweep of the Phillies, the Mets lose 3 of 4 at home to Miami. Just how bad has the pitching been? Is it Tong and McLean and pray for rain? Join us!
00:00-6:05: We've circled around to accepting the Mets' mediocrity
6:06-9:41: Mets lose 3 out of 4 to the Marlins AT HOME
9:42-13:47: The starting pitching problem is NOT new
13:48-16:53: Mets have best offensive month in FRANCHISE HISTORY and go 11-17
16:54...
2025-09-0224 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?NL EAST SHOWDOWN: Is this the LAST CHANCE for the Mets to win the division?Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are BACK to discuss the highs and lows of the New York Mets this week. The Mets drop a series to the Nationals but take 2 out of 3 in Atlanta...yet, it feels like they just keep letting games slip away. Do we have a Senga/Manaea problem? Should they call up Sproat/Tong? And how important is this week's series against the Phillies? Join us!!
00:00-5:38: Mets continue to not be able to close out games that they SHOULD win, dropping a series to the Nats is INEXCUSABLE.
5:39-11:43: McLean is a STAR, Saturday's...
2025-08-2727 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?MCLEAN DAZZLES: Could calling up the kids SAVE the SEASON for the Mets?Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are BACK and there is HOPE in the air for the New York Mets. The Mets won their first series in THREE WEEKS against the Mariners, thanks in large part to solid pitching performances from Nolan McLean and Clay Holmes. Can the Mets keep the positive momentum going? PLUS, the Mets show out at the Little League Classic. Join us!
00:00-5:00: Mets BLOW it on Friday in 11-9 loss to Seattle - Helsley has STRUGGLED
5:01-11:53: Nolan McLean DAZZLES in first start - is he the savior?
11:54-14:50: Mets participate in LITTLE LEAGUE Classic...
2025-08-1926 minWhy Am I a Mets Fan?FOUR PROSPECTS called up to TRIPLE-A SYRACUSEMets minor league analyst and host of the New York Mets Dove Report, Ernest Dove, sits down with Samantha Croston to talk about the current prospect situation and who might be called up next. Plus, a look at how calling up these prospects impact the Binghamton team and also the Big League team in Queens.
00:00-2:50: Ernest Dove's backstory - how he became a minor league analyst and his advice to those wanting to become a reporter
2:50-4:50: Mets promote FOUR top prospects to Triple A Syracuse
4:50-6:20: Jett Williams -- what the well-rounded player brings to the club...
2025-08-1325 minWhy Am I a Mets Fan?METS call up PITCHER Nolan MCLEANIn this video, Samantha Croston and Syracuse Mets Broadcaster Michael Tricarico break down the Mets' decision to promote Pitcher Nolan McLean, who will make his first MLB start this Saturday.
#mlblb #mlb #baseball #sports #pitching #mets #syracuse #newyork
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
2025-08-1311 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?FREEFALL: Could the New York Mets MISS the playoffs?
Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are back and the New York Mets have not WON A GAME since the last time we spoke! The Mets are in FREEFALL. New York has lost seven straight, 11 of the last 12, and are now 5.5 games BEHIND the Phillies in the division. The Mets are holding on to the final NL Wild Card by 1.5 games over the Reds. Have the Mets bottomed out, or could they miss the playoffs entirely?
00:00-7:12: It's FREEFALL in Queens - Mets get swept by the Brewers, Sunday disaster-class, starters can't get out of the FIFTH INNING
7:13-13:17: Carlos...
2025-08-1239 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?PITCHING PROBLEM: What do the Mets do with their starting rotation?Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are BACK to discuss the Mets' weekend starting pitching WOES. NYM loses 2 out of 3 to the Giants at Citi Field...is it time to call up Brandon Sproat or Nolan McLean? What does this team do with Frankie Montas? And why are the drinks at Citi Field $30? All that and more!
00:00-9:55: The Mets DROP 2 of 3 to the Giants, Citi Field experiences
9:56-16:02: Sunday's Frankie Montas implosion...the starting pitching CAN'T go deep into games
16:03-23:05: What do the Mets DO with Montas? Is it time to call up Sproat/McLean?
23:04-27:18: Edwin Diaz...
2025-08-0529 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?MLB TRADE DEADLINE: Did the New York Mets do ENOUGH?Ashley Wenskoski is back to give analysis and reaction to the moves the New York Mets made at the MLB Trade Deadline. The Mets fortified the bullpen with RHPs Tyler Rogers and Ryan Helsley, LHP Gregory Soto, and traded for CF Cedric Mullins. Was it ENOUGH to make this team a certified World Series contender? This week, we are joined by Ashley's younger sister Allie! Join us!
00:00-8:40: The Mets trade for RENTAL RHPs Tyler Rogers and Ryan Helsley, fortify the bullpen ahead of Edwin Diaz
8:41-18:27: The Mets say GOODBYE to Jose Butto, Drew Gilbert, and Blade Tidwell...
2025-08-0236 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?TRADE DEADLINE RUMORS: Who will the Mets DEAL? + Walkoff LOSSSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are BACK to discuss all of the news and rumors ahead of the MLB Trade Deadline! Who will the Mets DEAL before Thursday night? Who should they be shopping for? PLUS, a recap of Monday night's walkoff LOSS to the San Diego Padres, and questions about Emil Jimenez's eyes. Join us!
00:00-6:27: Mark Vientos Monday night grand slam - will Vientos be a Met come Thursday night?
6:28-13:25: Can Emil Jemenez see? Carlos Mendoza ejected, Juan Soto's upset, Huascar Brazoban has a meltdown
13:26-17:16: Gregory Soto - how many MORE bullpen arms do the...
2025-07-3032 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?Mets SWEEP Giants, win SEVENTH-STRAIGHT GAME
Samantha Croston and Intern Dan talk about the Mets' sweep against the Giants as their win streak extends to seven games. The kids stepped up to the plate (literally), and the Bullpen performance made all the difference!
00:00-3:11: RONNY MAURICIO has a BREAKOUT GAME
3:12-4:39: Who can the Mets AFFORD to TRADE?
4:40-7:52: Should the Mets trade Vientos to WHITE SOX for LUIS ROBERT JR.?
7:53-10:43: Francisco ALVAREZ continues to SHINE at the PLATE
10:44- 13:02:Gregory SOTO Mets DEBUT (He's awesome!)
13:03-16:08: Edwin Diaz gets out of a JAM
16:09-18:42: Mets TIED for longest winning streak this SEASON
18:43-20:46...
2025-07-2821 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?What MOVES do the Mets need to make? PLUS, David Wright DaySamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are BACK to discuss the Mets' SLUMP to start the SECOND-HALF. PLUS, a full recap of David Wright's number retirement ceremony, AND what moves do the Mets need to make at the Trade Deadline?
00:00-3:20: Mets LOSE 2 out of 3 to the Reds, bullpen management?
3:21-7:11: No. 5 is RETIRED, David Wright Day at Citi Field
7:12-10:14: Mets CLAW their way to a win on Sunday
10:15-17:50: The Mets have been one of the WORST teams in baseball since mid-June...what MOVES does David Stearns need to make at the Deadline?
17:51-19:38: MLB's postseason picture is...
2025-07-2231 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?ALL-STAR BREAK: Mets get Manaea, Senga BACK, Trade Deadline TARGETSSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are BACK for our weekly catchup as we head into the MLB All Star Break. Discussing the Mets' series win against the Royals, Kodai Senga and Sean Manaea returning to the mound, PLUS trade deadline candidates as we look into the second half of the season. Join us!
00:00-7:28: Mets grab series WIN in Kansas City, analyzing Manaea's return
7:29-8:13: Kodai Senga returns from the IL
8:14-9:33: Who will the Mets TRADE at the deadline?
9:34-14:04: ALL STAR WEEK - HR Derby favorites; PLUS Mets send Diaz, Alonso, Lindor and Peterson to the All...
2025-07-1434 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?KEITH RAAD: The Radio Voice of the New York MetsSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are joined this week by a VERY special guest! Keith Raad is the radio voice of the Mets on WCBS Mets Radio 880, working alongside legendary play-by-play Mets broadcaster Howie Rose. Raad gives us insight into the Mets' wild NLCS run in 2024, the outlook for the rest of this season, what it's like to work with Howie, and a look inside his own personal journey to The Show. Join us!
00:00-5:13: The trials and tribulations of 162 and beyond - what it's like to be a part of the Mets family
5:14-11:52: The magical run to...
2025-07-1029 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?SUBWAY SERIES Recap, Soto All-Star SNUBSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are here to discuss the SUBWAY SERIES! The Yankees and Mets faceoff in Queens, and the Mets take two of three. PLUS, Francisco Lindor, Pete Alonso, and Edwin Diaz are headed off to the All Star Game, and Juan Soto is NOT. Reinforcements are on the way!
00:00-16:31: Mets SOMEHOW, SOMEWAY take the Subway Series with NO starting pitching
16:31-19:32: Subway Series overall takeaways
19:33-25:05: Mets ALL-STARS announced - Francisco Lindor to START, Soto SNUBBED
25:06-28:03: Orioles and Royals probables
28:04-35:31: What will it mean for the Mets to get Jesse Winker, Sean Manaea...
2025-07-0837 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?JOHN DEMARSICO: The Man Behind the Mets' SNY Broadcast MagicSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski welcome a very special guest to the show this week! SNY Director John DeMarsico creates cinema on the baseball broadcast for the New York Mets. DeMarsico takes us through his backstory growing up as a Mets fan, his film inspirations, what it's like to work with Gary, Keith, and Ron, and the trials and tribulations of 162. Join us!
00:00-5:00: John DeMarsico's backstory - how he rose from SNY intern in 2009 to broadcast director in 2020 - a story of 17 Mets summers
5:01-17:55: "Baseball is cinema" - a look inside the SNY broadcast magic and how...
2025-07-0829 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?METS MELTDOWN: Step Right UP and BEAT the Mets!Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are here to hit the PANIC button on the New York Mets. The Mets have lost 13 of 16 and were SWEPT by the LAST-PLACE Pirates in Pittsburgh, outscored 30-4 over three games. Where does this team go from here? Join us for a meltdown.
00:00-3:20: Trigger warning...meltdown incoming
3:21-6:40: Mets get SWEPT by the PIRATES, are outscored 30 TO 4
6:41-12:59: Blackburn rain delay NIGHTMARE
13:00-22:40: Frankie Montas Sunday MELTDOWN, team meeting that had no MAGIC
22:41-28:15: Who takes accountability for this TWO-WEEK slide? Eric Chavez? Carlos Mendoza?
28:16-29:18: Pitching hope is on the horizon
29:19-36:49...
2025-07-0242 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?Mets in FREEFALL: 10 game slide, Alvarez, Acuna sent DOWNSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are back to discuss a CATASTROPHIC week for the New York Mets. After beginning the season as one of the best teams in baseball, the Mets have now lost nine of their last ten after disappointing performances against the Braves and Phillies. PLUS, Francisco Alvarez and LuisAngel Acuna are headed back to Syracuse. Is it time to panic yet?
00:00-8:56: Mets have won ONE game in ten days - what's the bigger cause for concern? The lineup or the starting rotation?
8:57-15:19: Mets FALL OUT of first place, Juan Soto is starting to turn...
2025-06-2434 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?SWEEP CITY: Mets MELTDOWN vs. Rays, Rafael Devers DEBACLESamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are BACK to talk about a DISASTERCLASS of a weekend for the New York Mets. The Mets are SWEPT for the first time this season by the Tampa Bay Rays, and the holes have been EXPOSED. The starting pitching CRUMBLES, the RISP woes CONTINUE, and the Mets were non-competitive. PLUS, the Rafael Devers trade that ROCKED the baseball world on Sunday night.
00:00-3:55: Mets pitching WOES in Friday's loss
3:56-9:30: Tylor Megill rant INCOMING: is his spot in the rotation SAFE?
9:31-13:49: The Frankie Montas DISASTER rehab stars continue - what do the Mets...
2025-06-1741 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?WEST COAST WINS: Mets top Rockies, Dodgers...could Pete ALONSO win NL MVP?Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are BACK to talk about the WEST COAST WINS! The Mets head home after going 5-2 against the Dodgers and Rockies. The Polar Bear is HOT, Lindor's toe, Mauricio's bat, and MUCH MORE. How did the Mets handle pitching to Shohei Ohtani? Join us!
00:00-8:35: Weekend recaps - concert experiences at Citi Field and Metlife Stadium
8:36-14:48: Pete Alonso PASSES David Wright on Mets all-time home-run list...Pete is HOT
14:49-21:45: Should the Mets resign Alonso after this season? Will he opt out? What's best for both sides?
21:46-24:44: Francisco Lindor continues to RAKE...
2025-06-1044 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?NLCS REMATCH: Mets open LA series with DODGERS, sweep Rockies
Get your brooms out! Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are here to recap the Mets' SWEEP of the Colorado Rockies (who are historically bad), and PREVIEW this week's series with the Los Angeles Dodgers (who are historically good). Looking ahead at the Mets/Dodgers probables out west, PLUS Franscisco Lindor hits a massive milestone, Juan Soto is coming out of his shell, Senga and Diaz have been EXCEPTIONAL, and the Torrens/Alvarez debate. Join us!
00:00-2:14: Mets SWEEP the Rockies - thank GOD
2:15-5:49: Francisco Lindor is on a HISTORIC home run pace - passes Derek JETER for 4th...
2025-06-0226 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?HOME COOKING: Mets go 4-2 against DODGERS, WHITE SOX at CitiSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are BACK to recap a successful homestand for the New York Mets. The Mets take 2 of 3 from both the Dodgers and the White Sox and now head out west...but not before a CLUNKER of a loss to the Sox on Wednesday. PLUS, Brett Baty and Jared Young are raking, Soto's stealing, and yet STILL no one can hit with RISP. Join us!
00:00-6:03: Mets take TWO out of three from White Sox, Canning FALLS APART in the Wednesday matinee
6:04-11:58: Mets take Citi series from DODGERS with wins on Saturday and Sunday...
2025-05-2929 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?METS/DODGERS Series RECAP with Dodgers Podcaster KEVIN KLEIN
In this episode of the Why Am I a Mets Fan Podcast, Samantha Croston sits down with the host of the Incline Dodgers Podcast, Kevin Klein, to recap the Mets/Dodgers Series at Citi Field and look ahead to the upcoming series between these two teams in LA.
00:00-3:07: The 13-inning, Game 1 Dodgers win was WILD
3:08-5:09: METS pitching HANDLED Dodgers' best hitters
5:10-6:44: What should DODGERS do with ex-Met MICHAEL CONFORTO?
6:45-8:25: Which DODGERS PITCHER is Kevin most excited to see RETURN to the ROTATION?
8:26-10:40: METS vs. DODGERS next few series leading up to playing each other
10:41...
2025-05-2717 minWhy Am I a Mets Fan?METS suffer DISGUSTING LOSS to DODGERS after RAIN DELAY
Samantha Croston and Intern Dan talk about the Mets' 7-5 loss to the Dodgers in a game that lasted over five hours and took 13 innings to decide. Will the Mets EVER hit with RISP again? The world may never know.
00:00-4:39: The Mets CAN'T HIT with RISP
4:40-6:42: Mets Bullpen did WELL
6:43-14:27: SOTO'S STRUGGLES CONTINUE
14:28-18:24: The STARS are SLUMPING, Brett BATY is OUR HERO
18:25-20:16: METS need to discuss PLATE DISCIPLINE
20:17-21:55: Was the OBSTRUCTION CALL on Muncy FAIR or BS?
21:56-26:10: Don't call RAIN DELAYS in the middle of an AT-BAT
#mlbb #mlblb #podcast #baseballplayer #mlbbaseball...
2025-05-2426 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?SOTO SAGA: Juan Soto's DRAMA-FILLED return to the BronxSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are here to recap a SORRY Subway Series for the New York Mets. The Mets lose two out of three to the Yankees and deal with numerous Juan Soto trials and tribulations. The hustling, the smiling, the private plane, oh my! PLUS, the Mets go MISSING with runners in scoring position and the infield defense is a problem.
00:00-3:42: It was an ugly Subway Series for the Mets.
3:43-7:22: The infield defense rears it's ugly head- should the Mets DH Mark Vientos or Pete Alonso more often? Should Brett Baty see more time at...
2025-05-2132 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?SUBWAY SERIES on deck: How will the Bronx REACT to JUAN SOTO's return?
Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are here to talk about the Mets' late-inning WALKOFF MAGIC, Paul Skenes, Brett Baty, and everything in between. PLUS, a Subway Series preview - how worried should JUAN SOTO be about his return to the Bronx? And should Pete Rose be elected to the HOF?
00:00-7:04: Mets' WALKOFF magic- Pete Alonso STRIKES again. PLUS, David Peterson outduels Paul SKENES and Livvy Dunne was there
7:05-10:51: The pitching STAYS HOT- Canning, Holmes continue to overperform
10:53-12:40: Brett Baty IS THAT YOU?!
12:41-15:14: SNY cinema and where is GKR??
15:15-16:33: Baty's in...Shoehei Ohtain's company??
16:34-25:02...
2025-05-1432 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?DOUBLEHEADER DISASTER: Mets stumble in St. Louis, Winker HURTSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski discuss the short-term struggles for the New York Mets, who lost back to back series for the first time this season. After missteps against the Diamondbacks and Cardinals, can the Mets rebound this week? What went wrong in St. Louis? Plus, Jesse Winker and Danny Young hit the IL.
00:00-4:55: THANK YOU for your support
4:56-10:00: Mets have a double-header DISASTER in St. Louis - Tidwell gets shelled in debut, Megill clunker
10:01-11:34: Jesse Winker hits the IL with an oblique injury **NOTE: we filmed this JUST before the news dropped he is out...
2025-05-0630 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?Mets are FIRST team in MLB to 20 WINS after 19-5 ROUT of NatsSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are BACK and the New York Mets are the BEST team in baseball through MLB's first month. What has led to the Mets unexpected success? Has Brandon Nimmo awoken from hibernation? PLUS, Brett Baty is BACK in Syracuse.
00:00-4:11: Mets are first team in MLB to 20 wins, Citi Field is a PARTY
4:12-7:30: Monday's 19-5 ROUT of the Nationals - has Brandon Nimmo found his way out of the woods?
7:31-8:39: Mets pitching staff has best ERA in baseball, the gaggle has impressed, Butto's bullpen meltdown
8:40-11:10: What is Edwin Diaz's deal?
11:11-12:55: Enough...
2025-04-2924 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?Mets REFUSE to LOSE - Alvarez, McNeil on the way BACK, Sproat SPOT start?Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are BACK for more! The New York Mets continue to CRUISE to start the season, taking 2 of 3 from the A's. Reinforcements are on the way to QUEENS, with Francisco Alvarez and Jeff McNeil beginning rehab assignments. Does Luis Torrens deserve MORE playing time? PLUS, the Mets might move to a six-man rotation - will they call up No. 1 prospect Brandon SPROAT?00:00-7:03: Mets take TWO of three from the A's - should Juan Soto take the car BACK from Brett Baty? 7:03-8:38: Kodai Senga SIZZLES in Sunday...
2025-04-1527 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?Citi Field INS & OUTS: Behind the scenes observations from a trip to QUEENSSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are BACK for a BONUS episode this week! We have all of the BEHIND the SCENES from our trip to Queens. What did we see and experience at Citi Field as credentialed media members rather than everyday fans?00:00-5:33: Mets head to Sacramento to play the A's - Luis Severino says the Mets DIDN'T want him back5:34-13:38: Beginning of the behind the scenes BITS - including Mets clubhouse setup, friendliness and accessibility of players, and thoughts on the New York media13:39-15:05: We met...
2025-04-1232 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?Do the Mets have the BEST pitching in BASEBALL?Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are BACK from the CITI. After covering the Mets' home opener at Citi Field, the team has won SIX straight. Is it us? Up to you. PLUS, the Mets open the season with the BEST pitching staff in baseball - is it real, or just a fluke? Will Brett Baty or LuisAngel Acuna get sent down when Jeff McNeil returns from injury? AND, the Blue Jays lock up VLAD GUERRERO JR.00:00-4:49: We are BACK from Citi Field!4:50-13:05: Mets have won SIX straight - have they...
2025-04-0936 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?OPENING WEEKEND: Mets' pitching SUPRISES, Torpedo bats, + Sasaki criesSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are BACK to recap opening weekend of baseball season. The Mets lose two out of three to the Astros but the pitching WOWS...plus, are the Yankees about to CHANGE baseball with their "torpedo bats"? And the Dodgers are 5-0, but Roki Sasaki is crying on the west coast.00:00-8:51: The Mets only take one against the Astros but the starting pitching AND bullpen look great...where is that highly-touted offense, though? Griffin Canning, Tylor Megill, Jose SIRI surprise8:52-9:40: Francisco, Katia Lindor welcome BABY BOY
2025-04-0128 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?BASEBALL IS BACK: Mets LOSE on Opening Day, Soto strikeoutThe Major League Baseball season is officially HERE! Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski recap everything from the last week of spring training for the Mets - who made the Opening Day roster, and who was left off? Who will be fighting for time this season? PLUS, the Mets fall on Opening Day to the Astros, Soto strikes out in a big spot, and Clay Holmes makes his first start since 2018. Join us!00:00-2:14: Happy baseball season!! We made it 2:15-8:54: Juan Soto STRIKES out to end Opening Day vs. the Astros
2025-03-2929 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?Clay HOLMES to start Mets' OPENING DAY + it's SHO-TIME in TokyoSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are back as MLB spring training continues on. The Mets name CLAY HOLMES the Opening Day starter - plus, the impact of Jeff McNeil's injury, the 3-man fight for two spots at the back end of the Mets rotation, and it's SHO-TIME in Tokyo - the Dodgers OPEN the season this week.00:00-6:34: Jeff McNeil is HURT - does this open the door for Brett Baty once more?6:35- 9:06: Jesse WINKER has an injury scare - WHAT is going on in Mets spring training?!9:07-10:23...
2025-03-1826 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?INJURY CITY: Gerrit Cole TOMMY JOHN, Alvarez HURT, Dodgers PAY RobertsSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are back with the lengthy injury report from Mets and Yankees spring training. Is all hope lost for the Yankees with Gerrit Cole's Tommy John surgery? Plus, the Mets will be without their starting catcher to open the season and the Dodgers lock up Dave Roberts.00:00-7:27: Francisco Alvarez to miss 6-8 weeks for the Mets7:28-13:59: Projected METS starting lineup - should ALONSO hit third?14:00-23:57: The sky is FALLING in the Bronx - can the Yankees SURVIVE Cole, Gil, Stanton injuries?23:58...
2025-03-1139 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?Will Mets Name Lindor CAPTAIN? PLUS, Quintana is GONE, Travis Hunter INSULTS OhtaniSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are back to discuss the SPRING TRAINING SPECULATION. Jose Quintana reportedly signs with the Brewers, leaving the Mets with one less rotation option. PLUS, the Mets' captain debate, Siri and Baty are raking, and Travis Hunter makes an OUTRAGEOUS statement regarding Shohei Ohtani. Buckle up!00:00-10:19: The Brewers reportedly sign Jose Quintana; Mets sign Jose Urena. Will we MISS Quintana?10:20-15:57: Mets are HIGH on young guns Sproat and Tidwell; Tidwell throws IMMACULATE inning. Could these two be the Mets' FUTURE?15:58-24:23: Should the Mets...
2025-03-0442 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?ROTATION RATTLED: Mets' Manaea, Madrigal HURT, Yankees MODERNIZE?Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski have a LOT to discuss this week as Spring Training forges on. Juan Soto hits a HOME RUN in his first at bat in a Mets uniform - but Sean Manaea is hurt, and so is Nick Madrigal. Does this open the door for Quintana, Iglesias to return? PLUS - what is HAPPENING with the Yankees lately?00:00-2:13: Juan Soto HOMERS in FIRST Mets spring training at-bat. You can't make it up.2:14-9:54: Sean MANAEA is HURT - can the Mets ever keep a starter healthy in...
2025-02-2626 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?SPRING TRAINING IS HERE: Is it WORLD SERIES or BUST for Mets in '25?Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are BACK and so is Mets baseball! The New York Mets reported to Port St. Lucie for spring training this week with LOTS to like- including Juan Soto in a Mets jersey and Pete Alonso's return. With Frankie Montas HURT, what will the Mets do with the starting rotation?00:00-3:50: It won't stop snowing in Syracuse but the Mets are in Florida so all is well3:51-9:54: Frankie Montas OUT 6-8 weeks with a lat injury9:55-12:11: Do the Mets NEED a starter WITHOUT Montas...
2025-02-1826 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?THE POLAR BEAR IS BACK: Mets Resign Pete AlonsoIt's the reunion we've all been waiting for, and the couple we never wanted to see breakup: Pete Alonso and the New York Mets are back together again. Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski break down his new deal.00:00-2:28: Pete Alonso is REUNITED with the METS2:29-5:23: Was this a GOOD DEAL for ALONSO and the METS?5:24-8:42: Reasons why METS fans should be EXCITED about the ALONSO deal8:43-:11:30: The BAD parts about ALONSO11:31-13:23: Will VLADDY DADDY become a MET?13:24-15:24: Harrison...
2025-02-0616 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?Steve Cohen SPEAKS OUT on Alonso; Mets interested in Flaherty, Mountcastle?Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are back to talk about NEW DEVELOPMENTS in the Pete Alonso SAGA. Mets owner Steve Cohen lays down the LAW at Amazin' Day...and Scott Boras responds. PLUS, Mets rumors surrounding Jack Flaherty, Nick Pivetta, and Ryan Mountcastle.00:00-12:36: Steve Cohen calls Pete Alonso negotiations "WORSE than JUAN SOTO." Cohen puts Scott Boras on NOTICE at Amazin' Day. What's the best option for Pete at this point?12:37-19:42: Fallout from Cohen's COMMENTS - Mets and Alonso TALKING again?19:43-26:23: Other takeaways from Amazin' Day: Montas...
2025-01-2932 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?ALONSO IMPASSE: Jays, Angels interested? YATES to DodgersSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are wrapping up the MLB Hot Stove RUMORS at week's end. Is Pete Alonso headed up North? Are the Mets interested in a Max Scherzer reunion? PLUS, the Dodgers sign Kirby Yates.00:00-7:13: Are the BLUE JAYS and Pete Alonso "at the 10 yard line?" Is Pete headed up north for $5 million more?7:14-11:40: Arte Moreno, ANGELS interested in Alonso?16:30-18:56: Mets, Yankees among teams at Max SCHERZER workout this week- could a reunion be in the cards?18:57-23:16: Dodgers keep COOKING, sign Kirby...
2025-01-2529 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?DODGERS DYNASTY: LA signs Tanner SCOTT, Jays get SANTANDER, is it OVER for Alonso?Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are breaking down the LATEST marquee signing for the Dodgers: Tanner Scott. PLUS, Toronto gets their man in Anthony Santander. Is it OVER between Pete Alonso and the Mets?00:00-1:51: Happy MLK Day! MLK's MLB connection1:52-10:22: The Dodgers sign reliever Tanner Scott to a 4-year/$72 million dollar deal. WHEN WILL IT END? Dodgers offseason signings roundup10:23-11:45: Would HATE to be the Padres right now11:46-14:39: Should MLB implement a salary CAP or a salary MINIMUM?14:40-18:13: Is it fully...
2025-01-2128 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?Roki SASAKI Signs with LA: Is the DODGERS Rotation UNSTOPPABLE?Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are breaking down the LEAST shocking news of the week: Japanese star RHP Roki Sasaki is headed to the Dodgers. LA is building a DYNASTY- is this starting rotation UNSTOPPABLE?00:00-5:15: Sasaki's a Dodger- the LAD starting five is ABSURD5:16-7:46: Should MLB implement a SALARY CAP? How are small-market teams supposed to COMPETE?7:46-9:45: The PHILLIES dance with the devil and give the Dodgers international signing bonus money9:45-12:10: The Dodgers have a STRONGHOLD on Japanese stars- MLB investigation comes back clean
2025-01-1919 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?Are the METS and Pete ALONSO headed for DIVORCE?THE POLAR BEAR IS HEADED TOWARDS EXTINCTION IN QUEENS! Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are dissecting the news that the New York Mets are expected to "PIVOT" from PETE ALONSO. The free agent first baseman reportedly REJECTED a 3-year/$68-70 million dollar offer from the Mets this week. Plus, the Mets sign Jesse Winker, A.J. Minter, and the Padres are OUT on Roki Sasaki.00:00-13:46: The timeline of the BREAKDOWN between Alonso and the Mets. Who's to blame? Is there any chance this deal still gets done?13:47-15:35: Could the Mets...
2025-01-1820 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?SASAKI SWEEPSTAKES heads WEST: Mets OUT on Japanese starSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are hearing that ROKI SASAKI is headed out WEST. All of the updates on the Sasaki sweepstakes, Sean Manaea is REINTRODUCED is a Met, and the latest on Pete Alonso. Join us!00:00-2:24: Our thoughts are with our west coasters because of the wildfires2:25-8:17: Dodgers, Padres rumored to be the FAVORITES for Sasaki; Mets are OUT8:16-16:15: Dodgers VS. Mets projected 2025 STARTING ROTATIONS 16:16-20:16: Mets reintroduce Manaea, emphasizes Mets' FAMILY FOCUS20:17-22:24: Pete ALONSO's camp reportedly offers Mets EXCLUSIVE 3-year...
2025-01-1530 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?METS MOVES: Manaea BACK, Alonso market, would Sasaki SOLVE rotation concerns?Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are BACK from a holiday trip to the West Coast with all the latest on MLB free agency! The New York Mets have brought back Sean Manaea - what's the status of Pete Alonso, Alex Bregman, Tanner Scott, and Roki Sasaki? We discuss.00:00-3:25: We loved San Diego!3:26-7:43: The Mets bring back Sean MANAEA on a three-year, $75 million dollar deal7:44-11:33: Do the Mets have a TRUE ace? Rotation concerns11:34-12:59: Updates on Roki Sasaki sweepstakes - are the Dodgers still the...
2025-01-0828 minWhy Am I a Mets Fan?SOTO introduced, YANKEES sign FRIED, DODGERS SELL million-dollar ballSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski discuss the introduction of Juan Soto as a New York Met, the Yankees' signing of Max Fried, and the Dodgers iconic decision to sell Aaron Judge's dropped World Series fly ball.00:00-2:06: Mets ticket sales EXPLODED since signing Juan SOTO2:07-3:59: Juan Soto is INTRODUCED as a MET, explains WHY he chose METS4:00-5:42: Why didn’t Juan Soto speak to former YANKEES TEAMMATES during NEGOTIATIONS?5:43- 6:53: Juan Soto didn’t JUST sign for MONE...
2024-12-1730 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?SOTO SPLASH: Soto WANTED to be a MET, Winter Meetings RUMORSSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are back because MLB'S WINTER MEETINGS are HEATING UP. Everything you need to know from the Soto signing fallout, including details of the deal and Yankee fan crash-outs. PLUS, Sean Manaea, Pete Alonso, Garrett Crochet and Roki Sasaki RUMORS.00:00-1:51: WINTER MEETINGS are HEATING up1:52-4:12: ACCEPT IT: Juan Soto wanted to be a MET4:13-7:07: Steve Cohen OVERPAID for Soto7:08-11:35: Yankees wouldn’t pay for Juan SOTO’s SUITE ?!11:36-12:50: TWEETS of the WEEK, Soto REACTION12:51-15:38: Uncl...
2024-12-1122 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?METS sign JUAN SOTO to LARGEST CONTRACT in SPORTS, surpasses OHTANISamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski rejoice as Juan Soto signs with the Mets on a 15-year, $765 million deal. Are the Mets the new King of New York?00:00-2:33: JUAN SOTO signs with the METS! Break out the SHOTS!2:34-4:10: YANKEES FANS can’t admit that JUAN SOTO wanted to be a MET!4:11-6:43: UNCLE STEVE swoops in at THE LAST MOMENT6:44 - 10:27: JUAN SOTO didn’t just sign for the MONEY!!!10:28-11:48: JEFF PASSAN’s Sports Center Monologue HEALED Mets fans11:49-14:15: What does Soto S...
2024-12-0922 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?SNELL to Dodgers, MONTAS to Mets, SOTO SPECULATIONSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are back as the MLB Hot Stove HEATS UP. Blake Snell signs with the DODGERS, Frankie Montas signs with the METS - where does this leave those rotations? PLUS, the Juan Soto SPECULATION and rumors you need to know.00:00-8:11: Mets sign RHP Frankie MONTAS. What does this mean for MANAEA, SEVERINO?8:12-14:15: Mets interest in Walker BUEHLER? Pete ALONSO prepared to leave NEW YORK?14:16-21:31: Dodgers sign BLAKE SNELL. Deferred contracts- are they GOOD for the game?21:32-23:23: Dodgers EXTEND Tommy Edman
2024-12-0333 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?Mets "FAVORITES" to win Juan SOTO? Ohtani, Judge win UNANIMOUS MVPsSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski provide updates on the Juan Soto SWEEPSTAKES after USA Today's Bob Nightengale reported the New York Mets are the "clear-cut favorites" to land the superstar. Plus, Shohei Ohtani and Aaron Judge win MVPs unanimously.00:00-8:04: Mets reported "favorites" to land Juan Soto8:05-12:32: Aaron Judge says he HAS NOT TALKED to Soto...why are the Yankees being so CALM?12:33-17:12: MVP races- Ohtani, Judge win UNANIMOUSLY17:13-18:42: Yusei Kikuchi, starting pitching MARKET#mlbb #mlb #mlbhotstove #mlbpodcast #newyork #newyorkmets...
2024-11-2620 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?MLB AWARDS: Will Shohei Ohtani win NL MVP UNANIMOUSLY?Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are back and it's MLB AWARDS SEASON! Does Shohei Ohtani deserve to win NL MVP unanimously? Who will take home NL Manager of the Year? PLUS, an update on the Juan Soto SWEEPSTAKES.00:00-1:35: THANK YOU JAMES BUCKLEY!!1:36-6:06: Paul Skenes wins NL Rookie of the Year: did Jackson Merrill get ROBBED?6:07-10:29: Will Carlos Mendoza or Pat Murphy take home NL Manager of the Year?10:30-18:05: Will Shohei Ohtani win NL MVP unanimously AGAIN? Will Francisco Lindor get any votes- and does...
2024-11-1935 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?SWEEPSTAKES: Where Will Juan SOTO, Roki SASAKI Land?Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski dive into the free-agency scenarios surrounding the Juan Soto SWEEPSTAKES. Where will baseball's marquee free agent land? Plus, diving into Roki Sasaki, Garrett Crochet and an exclusive interview with NL Manager of the Year candidate Pat Murphy.00:00-11:00: Who has the BEST CHANCE to land Juan Soto?11:01-19:06: Why are some teams SHYING away from Soto? 19:07-22:54: DODGERS considered favorites to land Roki Sasaki22:55-24:46: Should the Mets go after SASAKI?24:47-28:53: Will the White Sox trade GARRETT CROCHET? 28:54...
2024-11-1236 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?MLB HOT STOVE: Free agency HEATS UP, could Pete ALONSO become a YANKEE?Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski take you through the very early stages of MLB free agency. Who stays, who goes, what are Pete Alonso and Juan Soto going to do? Who will ACCEPT their qualifying offer? And the SCREAMS we SCRUMPT listening to Yankees fans post-World Series.00:00-1:39: Dodger fans! How is our World Series hangover?1:40-5:54: Mets extend QUALIFYING offers to Sean Manaea, Luis Severino, and Pete Alonso. MANAEA PLEASE STAY5:55-6:56: Mets DECLINE Phil Maton's option6:57-9:05: Could Pete ALONSO become a Yankee?!9:06-12:58...
2024-11-0527 minWhy Am I a Mets Fan?CHAMPIONS: DODGERS, OHTANI win the WORLD SERIES against the YANKEES!The Dodgers are the 2024 World Series Champions! Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski break down a WILD, BACK-AND-FORTH, Game 5 that ended it all. #worldseries #mlb #mlbplayoffs #mlbpodcast #newyorkmets #newyorkyankees #yankees #dodgers #losangeles #losangelesdodgers #newyork #majorleaguebaseball #lgm #lfgm #nlcs00:00-1:46: CONGRATS DODGERS FANS!1:47-3:10: CRAZIEST COMEBACK3:11- 6:30: YANKEES took 5-run lead EARLY6:31-10:54: WHAT in the FIFTH INNING was THAT? Yankees MELTDOWN10:55-11:13: Yankees' last SHRED of HOPE11:14-13:56: BUEHLER, DODGERS put the HAMMER DOWN13:57-14:48: Does this YANKEES LOS...
2024-10-3121 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?HOT STOVE: Who STAYS and who GOES in Mets free agency?Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski officially OPEN the OFFSEASON for the New York Mets. With the World Series wrapping up, free agency is rapidly approaching...and the Mets have some big decisions to make, including whether or not to RESIGN star slugger Pete Alonso.#mlb #mlbplayoffs #mlbhotstove #hotstove #mlbfreeagency #newyorkmets #mets #newyork #mlboffseason #newyorkyankees #losangelesdodgers #dodgers #mlbpodcast #losangeles #majorleaguebaseball #lgm #lfgm #petealonso #juansoto00:00-8:05: TONS of money coming off of the books, David Stearns/Steve Cohen OFFSEASON OUTLOOK8:06-15:44: The elephant in the room: What to do...
2024-10-3046 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?Dodgers up 2-0: are the Yankees TOAST in the World Series?Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski host a special episode of "Why Am I a Mets Fan?" taking you through Games 1 and 2 of the World Series between the Yankees and Dodgers. The Dodgers are up 2-0 in the series- are the Yankees TOAST?00:00-8:37: Are the Yankees just OVERMATCHED by the Dodgers?8:38-9:58: Starting pitching DISCREPANCIES9:59-12:55: Will GOING BACK to Yankee Stadium help the Yanks?12:56-15:27: Judge STRUGGLES, did the Yankees benefit from an easier PATH to get here?15:28-17:33: How this affects JUAN SOTO's pending...
2024-10-2821 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?THE FUNERAL: The Dodgers End the Season for the 2024 New York MetsSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski host a funeral for the 2024 New York Mets. The Mets were eliminated at the hands of the Los Angeles Dodgers in a 10-5 loss in Game Six of the NLCS. We recap the game, the series, and all in all one of the most remarkable seasons in Mets history.00:00-2:33: Sam and Ashley begin the FUNERAL proceedings2:34 -4:27: It wasn’t Sean MANAEA’s night (but he’s still a king)4:28-7:06: The runners in scoring position problem7:07-12:24: Bullpen WOES12:25-14:15...
2024-10-2129 minWhy Am I a Mets Fan?Mets STAY ALIVE in Game 5 against DODGERSSamantha Croston and Dan Papillo discuss the WILD 12-6 Mets win in Game 5 of the NLCS. The Mets have to win two more in LA to get to the world series. Is it POSSIBLE? Or is their trip to LA the END OF THE ROAD? 0:00-3:45 Pregame Nerves; Alonso Comes Through Early3:46-7:24 Dodgers Fight Back, WALK ISSUES, Mets Respond With BIG THIRD INNING7:25-13:19 Dodgers Bad Blood? Winker Comes Through, Questioning Mendoza’s Lineup Decisions13:20-19:08 Game Gets Interesting, Stanek and Diaz Lock It Down, Thoughts and Fee...
2024-10-1927 minWhy Am I a Mets Fan?Is it ALL OVER for the METS vs. the DODGERS?Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski go through the five stages of grief as they discuss the Mets' disheartening 10-2 loss against the Dodgers in Game 4 of the NLCS. Will the 2024 Mets season be over by tomorrow, or do they have one more magic trick left in the hat?#mets #mlb #mlbplayoffs #mlbpodcast #newyorkmets #lgm #lfgm #majorleaguebaseball #nlds #newyork #mlbpodcast #syracusemets #milb #mlbpostseasonLIKE, COMMENT, SUBSCRIBE, LISTEN ON ALL PLATFORMS:https://link.chtbl.com/whymetspodThumbnail photos courtesy of Getty Images Learn more about your...
2024-10-1825 minWhy Am I a Mets Fan?Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski recap a FUNERAL of an NLCS Game 3 for the New York Mets. WARNING: We have nothing positive to say. Join us.Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski recap a FUNERAL of an NLCS Game 3 for the New York Mets. WARNING: We have nothing positive to say. Join us.00:00-3:44: Game 3 was EMBARRASSING3:45-6:08: Take Alvarez OUT of the LINEUP6:09-10:38: CLUNKER at-bats10:39-11:23: Severino’s START11:24-13:58: Tylor Megill gives up a MOONSHOT to SHOHEI OHTANI13:59-15:27: Mets pitchers need to stop WALKING BATTERS, need better AT-BATS15:28-19:37: Mets need to play like ANY DAY could be the LAST. We are RUNNING OUT OF TO...
2024-10-1720 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?TIED UP: Manaea, Mets ROAR Back in NLCS Game 2Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski take you through what felt like a MUST WIN GAME for the New York Mets in Game 2 of the NLCS - and win they did. Sean Manaea was masterful, Mark Vientos provided pop, and the Mets are headed back to New York with the series tied 1-1 against the Dodgers. Buckle up!00:00-7:24: WE ARE BACK. Lindor sets the tone for a good night7;25-11:02: Mark Vientos is a STAR11:03-14:48: Have a NIGHT, Sean Manaea14:49-19:16: Bullpen, Diaz get it DONE
2024-10-1540 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?Mets DROP Game 1 of NLCS, Senga STRUGGLESSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski discuss the Mets' 9-0 loss to the Dodgers in Game 1 of the NLCS. A bad Senga outing combined with just three Mets hits was a recipe for failure. Will their magic be back tomorrow?00:00-12:33: Senga has HORRIFIC outing, where does the pitching stand after this?12:34-13:48: Mets bats were LIFELESS in Game One13:49-15:44: Winker's baserunning BLUNDER15:45-28:13: Looking ahead to Game Two, don't PANIC just yet#mets #mlb #mlbplayoffs #mlbpodcast #mlbpostseason #nlcs #nlds #newyorkmets #lgm #lfgm...
2024-10-1428 minWhy Am I a Mets Fan?METS NLCS PREVIEW, Potential SUBWAY WORLD SERIES?Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski preview the Mets and Dodgers NLCS and discuss the possibility of the first Subway World Series since 2000. Could New York City survive it?00:00-11:52: The METS' strengths and the DODGERS' weaknesses11:53-16:54: KODAI SENGA pitching GAME 116:55-22:32: Should JEFF MCNEIL be on the NLCS ROSTER?22:33-33:13: The METS are AMERICA'S TEAM, a potential SUBWAY SERIES World Series?#mets #mlb #majorleaguebaseball #newyorkmets #lgm #mlbplayoffs #nlds #lfgm #newyork #syracuse #syracusemets #milb #mlbwildcard #mlbpostseason #mlbpodcastLIKE...
2024-10-1334 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?CLINCHED: The New York Mets are NLCS BOUNDAshley Wenskoski and Dan Papillo are here to CELEBRATE. The New York Mets, against all odds, are headed to the National League CHAMPIONSHIP SERIES thanks to one big swing from Francisco Lindor. All of the highs, lows, hugs, and tears from the Game Four NLDS win over the Phillies...coming your way00:00-8:09: Lindor is a HERO, the Mets are NLCS BOUND8:10-9:09: Padres or Dodgers?9:10-10:31: Jose WINtana twirls a GEM10:32-12:53: We SURVIVED the Edwin Diaz HEART ATTACK12:54-13:29: How sweet it is to...
2024-10-1018 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?Mets SMOKE the Phillies in Game 3 of the NLDSAshley Wenskoski and Dan Papillo recap the Mets THRILLING 7-2 victory in Game 3 of the NLDS over the Phillies. Sean Manaea's MASTERFUL performance has the Mets one win away from the NLCS.00:00-1:33: Citi Field was FIRED UP, Grimace hits the big time1:34-3:02: Pete Alonso solo SHOT, Mets get to Aaron Nola3:03-4:09: Jesse Winker goes DEEP4:10-6:08: BIG insurance runs, Sean Manaea SHOVES6:09-7:25: Jose Iglesias adds on, CAN WE GET THE CANDELITA REMIX?!7:26-10:37: Bullpen usage10:38-13:39: Looking ahead...
2024-10-0914 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?ONE on ONE with Mets LEGEND Darryl StrawberryThe Why Am I a Mets Fan? Podcast goes ONE on ONE with New York Mets legend Darryl Strawberry. The 8x MLB All-Star reflects on life after baseball, the obstacles he's overcome, and the current playoff run for the New York Mets. Strawberry was a 4x World Series Champion throughout his career with the Mets and Yankees.00:00-5:47: Life after baseball, the lowest point of his career, overcoming addiction 5:48-8:30: Thoughts on the 2024 New York Mets and their potential to "ignite New York" with this playoff run...
2024-10-0908 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?METS BLOW Game Two of the NLDSSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski vent after the Mets' back-and-forth game, and eventual loss against the Phillies in Game 2 of the NLDS. Edwin Diaz and Tylor Megill...oh my. Mark Vientos' heroics weren't enough, and the Mets will now head to Citi Field for games 3 and 4.#mets #mlb #majorleaguebaseball #newyorkmets #lgm #mlbplayoffs #nlds #lfgm #newyork #syracuse #syracusemets #milb #mlbwildcard #mlbpostseason #mlbpodcastLIKE, COMMENT, SUBSCRIBE, LISTEN ON ALL PLATFORMS:https://link.chtbl.com/whymetspod Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
2024-10-0727 minWhy Am I a Mets Fan?MADNESS: The METS are NLDS BOUND!!!Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski rejoice after the Mets' crazy come-from-behind win over the Brewers in a Game 3 winner-take-all classic to advance to the NLDS for the first time since 2015. #mets #mlb #mlbplayoffs #newyorkmets #newyork #lgm #lfgm #letsgomets #majorleaguebaseball #syracuse #syracusemets #milb #mlbwildcard #mlbpostseason #mlbpodcastLIKE, COMMENT, SUBSCRIBE, LISTEN ON ALL PLATFORMS:https://link.chtbl.com/whymetspod Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
2024-10-0424 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?Maton MELTDOWN, WIN or GO HOME for the MetsSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski are back to recap the Mets BLOWING the second game of the NL Wild Card Series. After taking a 3-1 lead, Phil Maton allowed the Brewers to roar back in the bottom of the eighth inning. It's WIN OR GO HOME for the Mets in Game 3 on Thursday. BUCKLE UP!00:00-8:55: Game Two recap, Maton MELTDOWN, bats gone MISSING with RISP8:56-13:34: A look ahead at Game Three. This is it!#mets #mlb #majorleaguebaseball #newyorkmets #lgm #mlbplayoffs #lfgm #newyork #syracuse #syracusemets #milb...
2024-10-0314 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?Mets WIN Game ONE of the NL Wild Card SeriesSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski take you through a GAME ONE WIN for the New York Mets in the NL Wild Card Series. The Mets topped the Brewers 8-4 behind timely hits, Luis Severino doing just enough, a masterful performance from Jose Butto and the bullpen and Carlos Mendoza pushing all the right buttons. 00:00:9-58: Game One recap9:59-13:45: Looking ahead to Game Two, the rest of the series...dare we say to Philly?#mets #mlb #mlbplayoffs #newyorkmets #lgm #newyork #lfgm #majorleaguebaseball #syracuse #syracusemets #milb #mlbwildcard #mlbpostseason...
2024-10-0214 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?CLINCHED: The NY Mets are PLAYOFF BOUNDSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski take you through every high and low of the GAME OF THE YEAR for the New York Mets. In game 161 of the season, the Mets topped the Braves in SPECTACULAR fashion to clinch the 11th postseason berth in franchise history.00:00-5:20: Game 161. How did we get here?5:21-7:48: The Mets were DEAD in the WATER until the offensive EXPLOSION in the top of the 8th7:49-11:30: Edwin Diaz MELTDOWN, Francisco Lindor DOES IT AGAIN11:31-20:06: Who's responsible for the Mets' success this season...
2024-10-0136 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?Mets DOMINATE Phillies, Head to Atlanta for PLAYOFF PUSHSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski break down another WEEK OF WINS for the New York Mets. After sweeping the Nationals, the Mets took three of four from the Philadelphia Phillies and hold a 2.0 game lead over the Braves in the NL Wild Card race with six to go. One week left. Buckle up!00:00-8:00: Mets SWEEP the Nats, DOMINATE the Phillies, Sam goes to Citi Field8:01-10:40: Lineup SCORCHES, Iglesias, Taylor, Alvarez on FIRE10:41-13:47: LuisAngel Acuna MAKES HIS MARK13:48-16:18: The rotation SPARKLES and SHINES16:19...
2024-09-2337 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?Are the Mets DOOMED in the NL Wild Card Race WITHOUT Lindor?Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski assess the state of the Mets with TWO WEEKS to go in the NL Wild Card race. Can the Mets make a POSTSEASON PUSH in the ABSENCE of Francisco Lindor?00:00-9:49: Mets lose two of three in Philly, Lindor HURT9:50-12:17: LuisAngel Acuna is CALLED UP12:18-19:59: Bats FALL ASLEEP, Nimmo and Alonso can't buy a hit20:00-20:52: Rotation HEROICS20:53-24:48: Edwin Diaz blows ANOTHER SAVE24:49-27:05: Blackburn, Nunez INJURIES27:06-34:54: Grimace CHAIR, season ending PREDICTIONS, Syracuse...
2024-09-1736 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?Mets REFUSE to LOSE, Pull AHEAD in NL Wild Card RaceSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski break down the New York Mets' NINE-GAME win streak that has allowed them to take SOLE POSSESSION of the third NL Wild Card spot.00:00-12:40: Mets win NINE in a row, Mark Vientos walkoff HR12:41-16:20: Rotation, bullpen have been LOCKDOWN. What's behind the emergence of David Peterson and Sean Manaea?16:21-18:17: Jeff McNeil OUT FOR THE SEASON18:18-20:47: Noah Syndergaard wants to RETURN to New York20:48-22:04: Mets trade for EDDY ALVAREZ22:05-23:47: Mets lose legend ED KRANEPOOL
2024-09-1033 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?ONE on ONE with New York Mets No. 1 Prospect RHP BRANDON SPROATThe "Why Am I a Mets Fan" podcast's Ashley Wenskoski sits down with Mets TOP-RANKED prospect, RHP Brandon Sproat. The 23-year-old discusses his meteoric rise through the Mets' system, how the SEC prepared him for pro ball, adjustments he's made in AAA, and his biggest influence within the organization. 00:00-2:47: Adjusting to AAA hitters in Syracuse after beginning the 2024 season with High-A Brooklyn2:48-8:01: How college ball at Florida prepared him for the pros, the draft process after not signing with the Mets in 2022 and being picked by the organization again in 2023
2024-09-0416 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?The Mets DANCE WITH THE DEVIL in NL Wild Card raceSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski discuss a week full of very high highs and very low lows for the New York Mets (is there ever any other kind?) Two walk offs against the O's kicked things off- but then gave way to a bullpen-blown loss on Sunday against the Padres. Time is TICKING in the NL Wild Card race.00:00-7:00: Butto, Diaz BLOW the game on Sunday, NL Wild Card race7:01-7:46: We have an announcement!7:47-11:50: Mets WALK IT OFF twice against the Orioles11:51-19:27: Lindor's MVP...
2024-08-2634 minWhy Am I a Mets Fan?Alvarez CRUSHES his first WALK-OFF HOMERSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski provide their immediate reaction on Alvarez's walk-off homerun, propelling the Mets to a 4-3 win over the Orioles on Monday night. #mets #newyorkmets #orioles #lgm #lfgm #mlb #letsgomets #majorleaguebaseball #syracusemets #syracuse #minorleaguebaseball #milb LIKE, COMMENT, SUBSCRIBE, LISTEN ON ALL PLATFORMS: https://link.chtbl.com/whymetspodThumbnail photos provided by Getty Images Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
2024-08-2106 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?Is it NOW OR NEVER for the New York Mets?Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski dissect the highs and lows from the Mets' series against the A's and Marlins and discuss the importance of the crucial ten-game stretch that lies ahead in the NL Wild Card race.00:00-1:47: A week of HIGHS and LOWS1:48-4:49: Mets LOSE series finale to the MARLINS - Jeff McNeil BUNT??!4:50-9:14: The A's series, Ashley's visit to CITI FIELD, Austin Adams OMG9:15-15:23: LINEUP SHAKEUP, Nimmo INJURY, Lindor MVP campaign15:24-18:51: Are the DEADLINE ACQUISITIONS paying off? Blackburn, Brazoban
2024-08-1930 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?SWEEP: Mets bats SILENCED in SEATTLESamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski discuss the Mets' DISASTER SWEEP IN SEATTLE. The bats fell silent- who's to blame? Plus, a look ahead to the most important games remaining in the regular season.**DISCLAIMER: This was filmed before the wheels fell off the bus in Sunday's game00:00-6:00: Who's MOST DANGEROUS in the NL Wild Card race?6:00-8:30: Mets BATS FALL SILENT on end of West Coast trip8:30-14:10: The Mets can’t BUY a hit with RISP14:10-20:08: Alonso, Ottavino lack ACCOUNTABILITY...
2024-08-1233 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?The Mets face WEST COAST WORRIESSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski discuss the Mets' WORRISOME West Coast performance through the series with the Angels and explain why every game counts in this Wild Card RACE.00:00-2:10: The Mets hit the WEST COAST2:11-3:56: THANK YOU to our VIEWERS!!!3:57-7:42:The road trip from HELL7:43-12:42: Saturday’s loss was a GUT PUNCH, Brozoban gives up a 3-run HOMER12:43-15:19: DO NOT hit the PANIC button15:20-16:24: Mets grab SERIES WIN over TWINS16:25-21:54: How are the DEADLINE ADDITIONS fa...
2024-08-0531 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?Grading the Mets' TRADE DEADLINE DEALSSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski join you for an EMERGENCY EPISODE to grade the deals the New York Mets made at the MLB Trade Deadline. How did you feel about the Mets' additions? Come for the trade talk, stay for the Long Island lore.00:00-2:22: Overview of who's IN, who's OUT. David Stearns BUYS CHEAP2:23-6:16: Mets grab RHP reliever HUASCAR BRAZOBAN from Marlins6:17-8:29: Starter PAUL BLACKBURN comes over from the A's8:30-13:32: TYLER ZUBER, Long Island Lisa, and Lore13:33-20:14: Jesse WINKER, Ryne STANEK...
2024-07-3133 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?The Mets face TRADE DEADLINE DECISIONS00:00-8:04: The Mets TROUNCE the Yankees, split series with the Braves8:05-10:01: Jeff McNeil has WOKEN UP10:02-13:51: Mets acquire JESSE WINKER from the Nats13:52-16:47: Kodai Senga is OUT for the regular season16:48-22:58: Where does the loss of SENGA and SCOTT leave the Mets' STARTING ROTATION?22:59-24:43: The Mets' TOP TARGETS at the DEADLINE24:44-28:56: Bullpen MOVES, TRADE for Ryne Stanek28:57-32:29: The Mets' BIGGEST NEEDS before the TRADE DEADLINE32:30-36:37: FUN FACTS of the week36:38-41:04: Why is...
2024-07-2944 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?The Mets' First-Half HEROICSSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski recap the season's first half for the New York Mets heading into the All-Star Break - including the FIRST HALF HEROES and how this team SAVED the season.00:00-1:51: The Mets are IN THE PLAYOFF PICTURE, have 3rd Wild Card spot1:52-4:00: GLIZZY IGGY, Candelita is PERFORMING at All Star Week4:01-7:57: First half MVPS7:58-11:36: Tweets of the WEEK, Stearns's finds on the SCRAP HEAP11:37-13:10: Carlos MENDOZA'S first EJECTION13:11-16:33: Nunez, Butto's impact on the BULLPEN
2024-07-1531 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?Lindor, Nimmo SNUBBED from ALL-STAR GAMEIn this episode of the 'Why Am I a Mets Fan?' Podcast, Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski discuss the crime that has been committed by Major League Baseball: leaving Francisco Lindor and Brandom Nimmo off of the NL All-Star roster, plus a recap of the Mets' come-from-behind win over the Pirates.00:00-8:20: Lindor, Nimmo, SNUBBED from All-Star Game8:21-13:06: Mets COME FROM BEHIND W over Pirates13:07-14:33 Tweets of the Week14:44-16:41: Stats of the week16:42-18:46:Alvarez is INVALUABLE18:47-20:25: Edwin Diaz...
2024-07-0833 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?INSIDE INSIGHT from ANTHONY DICOMOSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski bring you an "Extra Innings" edition of the "Why Am I a Mets Fan?" podcast featuring Mets insider and MLB.com beat writer Anthony DiComo. He shares his outlook on this year's team, his impressions of Carlos Mendoza and David Stearns, how MLB has evolved in the last decade, and co-authoring "The Captain: A Memoir" with Mets legend David Wright.00:00-2:47: INTRO: Are the Grimace Mets back?2:48-6:15: Why Anthony DiComo believes this year's team is DIFFERENT6:16-8:08: The IMPACT of Jose Iglesias on team...
2024-07-0330 minWhy Am I a Mets Fan?OMG! The Mets NEED BULLPEN helpSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski discuss the Mets' recent success, which has been temporarily STIFLED by their bullpen WOES. What will it take to fix it and return to their IMMACULATE vibes?00:00-4:07: OMG! The Mets are one of the hottest teams in baseball and Candelita ROCKS4:08-6:23: Tweets of the week - Mets Twitter is on FIRE6:24-8:51: EVERYBODY HITS8:52-11:35: Comment of the week11:36- 16:30: Have the Mets solidified themselves as BUYERS?16:31-20:19: Lindor moving to leadoff changed EVERYTHING20:20-24:29...
2024-07-0135 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?Mets have an AMAZIN' June, Edwin Diaz EJECTEDIn this edition of the Why Am I A Mets Fan Podcast, Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski discuss the Mets' unbelievable run in June, followed almost immediately by Edwin Diaz's swift ejection on Sunday Night Baseball against the Cubs. It makes you think: Why am I a Mets Fan?00:00-4:39: The Mets are HOT in June4:40-7:43: It wasn’t JUST a 7-day hot streak7:44-10:43 Are the May Mets or June Mets the REAL Mets?10:44-17:26 Can the Mets sell AND compete in the playoffs?17:27-2...
2024-06-2443 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?The Gri-Mets are a SIZZLING 7-0Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski bring you an EMERGENCY EDITION of the "Why Am I a Mets Fan?" podcast. The duo discusses The Grimace Effect on the New York Mets and the ins and outs of the team's seven game winning streak.00:00-8:28: WHO is Grimace and HOW did he change our lives?8:29-14:10: The Mets have FORGOTTEN how to lose14:11-18:51: The IMPACT of Francisco Alvarez (we love Alvy)18:52-22:19: The LOSS of the legendary Willie Mays#mets #lgm #mlb #letsgomets #syracusemets...
2024-06-1924 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?Did Grimace SAVE the Mets' SEASON?Did Grimace SAVE the SEASON for the New York Mets? Ashley Wenskoski, Samantha Croston, and Mike Croston debate the topic and many others on this week's episode, including the impact of Edwin Diaz and Francisco Alvarez returning from the IL, J.D. Martinez's hot streak, and where the Mets go from here. Plus, the duo welcomes Sam's Dad, Mike, to the show in honor of Fathers Day!00:00-3:39: Why Mike Croston is a Mets fan- Sam's ORIGIN STORY3:40-6:46: The Mets have WON 9 of their last 11 games6:47-8:50: J.D...
2024-06-1736 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?FATHERS DAY SPECIAL: 50 Years of METSSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski host a Fathers Day Extra Innings Special with Ashley's Dad, Rich! He takes us through life as a Mets fan for 50+ years, including the highs and lows of 1986, saying goodbye to Shea Stadium, the transition from the Wilpons to Steve Cohen, and his take on the current team. You don't want to miss it!LIKE, COMMENT, SUBSCRIBE, LISTEN ON ALL PLATFORMS: https://link.chtbl.com/whymetspod Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
2024-06-1435 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?Mets play ACROSS the PONDThe New York Mets took their theatrics overseas this week! Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski take you through the Mets/Phillies series in London, plus the Nationals SWEEP, lineup SHAKEUPS, and Juan Soto RUMORS. 00:00-11:11: Cheers, mate! Mets SPLIT series in LONDON11:12-16:32: Lineup SHAKEUP. Jeff McNeil out, Candelita in?16:33-19:24: Nats SWEEP, Lindor, Martinez veteran INFLUENCE19:25-22:25: Where would the Mets have to be on FOURTH OF JULY to BUY?22:26-26:00: Steve Cohen COMMENTS26:01-29:31: What would it take to sign JUAN SOTO?
2024-06-1038 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?The "WORST" Team in Baseball?Glove throwing and home run strawberries...another week with the "worst" team in Major League Baseball. Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski take you through the Mets latest woes, including what Jorge Lopez MAY or MAY NOT have said, a CLOSED DOOR meeting, and more.00:00-4:52: The Mets are ALLERGIC to winning a series4:53-11:22: Jorge Lopez glove throw, comments, DFA'd11:23-15:05: What goes on behind closed doors with this team?15:06-21:30: McNeil, Alonso leadership issues21:31-26:55: A team PATCHWORKED together from five different GMs26:57...
2024-06-0343 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?The Mets are BROKENThis week, Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski have a LOT to say on the state of the Mets. MELTDOWNS, bullpen WOES, trade RUMORS, oh my! The pair takes you through how the New York Mets got to the point of ‘battling’ merely on Memorial Day.00:00-04:56: We are in a bad place and so are the Mets4:57-10:33: This week’s latest meltdowns, bullpen woes, what do we do with Edwin Diaz?10:34: 12:50: Tweets of the week12:51-19:47: Paging some energy, because the Mets DON’T HAVE ANY, Lindor’s Clevelan...
2024-05-2734 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?EXTRA INNINGS: Mets No. 11 Prospect RHP Mike VasilSamantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski bring you the first "Extra Innings" guest edition of the "Why Am I a Mets Fan?" podcast. NY Mets No. 11 prospect and current Syracuse Met Mike Vasil joins the show, discussing his journey through the minor leagues, favorite spots in the 315, and his impression of the Mets organization. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
2024-05-2228 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?Steve Cohen TWEETS and DELETES, Edwin Diaz STRUGGLES, buyers or sellers?Samantha Croston and Ashley Wenskoski return for the second episode of "Why Am I a Mets Fan?" This week, the pair discusses hot topics surrounding a scuffling Mets team, including tweets from the owner and a closer that's lost his way.00:00-06:14: State of the Mets06:15-10:55: Edwin Diaz has the YIPS10:56-14:21: Steve Cohen TWEETS and DELETES14:22-19:05: Veteran postgame meeting19:06-19:45: Tweet of the Week19:46-21:06: Alonso heats up21:07-22:37: The lineup22:38-26:47: Possible internal moves involving Brett...
2024-05-2031 min
Why Am I a Mets Fan?INTRODUCTION: Why Am I a Mets Fan?Ashley Wenskoski and Samantha Croston introduce you to "Why Am I a Mets Fan?" The weekly podcast will explore the farm, fascination, and the facts behind the New York Mets, while providing inside access to the AAA-affiliate Syracuse Mets.00:00-09:54: The answer to the big question- why are WE Mets fans? Our backgrounds, who we are09:55-12:04: Recapping the weekend series against the Braves12:04-12:58: J.D. Martinez's thoughts on his late free-agency signing with NYM12:59-13:30: Thoughts on JD Martinez signing13:30-16:26: The Baby Mets...
2024-05-1438 minWhy Am I a Mets Fan?Introducing Why Am I a Mets Fan?"Why Am I Mets Fan?" is a “Fan Podcast” for the New York Mets but its unique niche in the MLB/Mets Podcast landscape is direct access and discussion about the Triple-A Affiliate Syracuse Mets. This is where the top prospects pass through, well-known veterans on rehab stints, and so forth. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
2024-05-0901 min