Shows
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesTom and HuckTwo 90s weirdos watch two 90s heartthrobs take on Mark Twain in the Disney's forgotten family flick, Tom and Huck 2021-11-091h 09
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesDuckTalesIf you want to hear two millenials discuss a deeply-lored animated series starring ducks, you've come to the right place! Tiffany & Caitlin watched two 1987 episodes of the original DuckTales series and discuss them, and Don Cheadle, in unnecesary detail. 2021-06-181h 08
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesThe Nutty ProfessorIn this 1996 hit comedy, Sherman Klump just wants to lose weight and get the girl. Instead, he leaves us traumatized.2021-03-121h 12
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesBlank Check1994. The good old days. A time when a small child could buy castles, go karts, garbage cans full of ice cream, and a 30 year old girlfriend for a million bucks. Or maybe that's just the warped reality that is Disney's BLANK CHECK.2021-02-121h 02
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesJingle All The WayJingle Bells, Jingle Bells JINGLE ALL THE WAY back to 1996 to discuss Arnold Schwarzenegger and Sinbad's dive into Christmas chaos.2020-12-171h 21
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesFriendsgivingSpecial Guest/ Screenwriter Anna White breaks down her favorite "Friends" Thanksiving episode, 1998's "The One With All The Thanksgivings". 2020-11-201h 12
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesThe Worst Witch (1986)Fairuza Balk at Hogwarts? Charlotte Rae in a pink wig? Tim Curry wearing the world's biggest cape? It can only mean one thing- we watched and review the 1986 made-for-tv movie, The Worst Witch!2020-10-261h 08
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesMr. BoogedyWe watch, marvel, and scratch our heads over the spooky, weird and wild 1986 Disney Channel cult classic, Mr. Boogedy.2020-10-0849 min
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesAir Force OneIt's 1998. Harrison Ford is the leader of the free world and kindly requests you get off his plane. 2020-07-031h 06
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesBio-DomeTwo 90's slackers (Pauly Shore & Stephen Baldwin) get trapped in a closed ecological system for a year and torture everyone involved. Especially the audience. 2020-05-231h 03
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesGummi BearsTime for The Adventures of the GUMMI BEARS! They're bouncin' here and there and everywhere! It's a serious concern. 2020-03-0541 min
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesHappy New Year, Charlie Brown!Charlie Brown trudges to the end of another depressing year of his short life. Also, Snoopy! 2019-12-3144 min
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesA Muppet Family ChristmasDon ye now our gay apparel! The Muppets, Sesame Street, and Fraggle Rock unite to celebrate the holidays in the most ambitious crossover event of the 20th century. Note: We recorded this episode weeks prior to posting, so some of the information is outdated... you'll see what we mean...2019-12-1150 min
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesTop 5 Thanksgiving FoodsWhat are the best 5 Thanksgiving dishes? We'll tell you! Is your favorite on our lists? There's only one way to find out...2019-11-2335 min
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesThe Lost Mystery EpisodeWe found a forgotten, unlabeled, 5 year old episode in our archive. What is it? We don't know! Listen in to find out! 2019-09-1358 min
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesCare Bears Movie II: A New GenerationTiffany and Caitlin take a critical look at this sugar-coated, candy-colored schlock-fest from 1986!2019-06-1340 min
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesThe Easter Bunny is Comin' to Town!Ever wonder why the Easter Bunny hides colorful eggs? Brings jelly beans and toys? Or why everyone wears shiny new Easter clothes? Well, in 1977, Rankin Bass created "The Easter Bunny is Comin' to Town" to answer all your questions... very, very poorly. 2019-04-2246 min
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesThe Chipmunk AdventureJoin us for for an around the world adventure with the Chipmunks and the Chipettes! We'll see the sights, sing songs, and smuggle blood diamonds! Wait what2019-02-271h 04
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesTop 5 Christmas SongsFor a very special Christmas Eve, we sip mulled wine and run down each of our five very favorite Christmas songs of all time. In keeping with the holiday spirit, we try not to yell at each other TOO much. Happy Holidays Everyone!2018-12-2535 min
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesThe Nightmare Before ChristmasWhat's this? What's this? A podcast's in the air! Today we talk about the 1993 Christmas (Halloween??) staple, The Nightmare Before Christmas. One of us loves it, the other hates it. Listen to find out who!2018-12-1351 min
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesSabrina the Teenage WitchA SpoOoOkY review of the 90's TGIF series, Sabrina the Teenage Witch!2018-10-1145 min
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesSweet Valley HighWe dive into the world of Tiffany's favorite book series, Sweet Valley High with an in depth read of book #15, "The Older Boy".2018-08-2958 min
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesLadybugsRodney Dangerfield + Girls Soccer + Crossdressing = A movie? Someone in 1992 sure seemed to think so! Let's Discuss!2018-05-3159 min
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesLegends of the Hidden TempleToday we talk about Nickelodeon's '93-'95 kid's game show, Legends of the Hidden Temple. It's exciting! Educational! Sexy? 2018-04-2541 min
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesSpace JamImagine a big budget blockbuster where the world's biggest celebrity plays basketball to save cartoons from slavery. IMAGINE NO FURTHER. Today we breakdown the greatest film of any generation: SPACE JAM2018-03-211h 08
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesJumanjiIs Robin Williams too soft for the jungle? What's up with the monkey kid? Are your eyes too small? Join us for our in depth look at and many tangents about the 1995 film!2018-02-221h 03
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesGremlins1984's Gremlins can't quite decide what it wants to be- horror? Comedy? Satire? A full on holiday film? Who knows! Also, what is a mogwai? Are stripes the same as mohawks? Is Billy supposed to be 16 or 45? We discuss all this and more in our very special holiday episode!2017-12-241h 05
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesGargoylesWhat is a gargoyle? Why is a gargoyle? Who is this show even for? Do gargoyles make good boyfriends? Has Caitlin had too much to drink? All these questions answered and more on today's episode!2017-11-3040 min
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesCasperToday we watched the 1995 hit CASPER, and discussed the morality of bringing back the dead, Bill Pullman's corpse, and sexual awakenings.2017-10-271h 08
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesSister ActPraise Jesus, Whoopi Goldberg goes nundercover!2017-04-251h 01
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesTrick or Treat Candy!We taste and review our favorite Trick or Treating candy from back in the day. Crippling disappointment ensues. 2016-10-251h 01
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesSailor Moon!We revisit one of Tiffany's old favorites, mid-90s anime sensation SAILOR MOON, and have some very emotional reactions. 2016-09-1436 min
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesGhostbusters IIHold onto your proton packs: We get 4 drinks deep and discuss the plot, cast, and trivial stupidities of Ghostbusters II! 2016-06-161h 10
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesFull HouseWhat do you get when you combine one part Full House, one part Disney, one part cringe, and two parts alcohol? Our podcast on classic 2 parter episode, The House Meets the Mouse! 2016-03-0857 min
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesMy So-Called Life!Listen as we drink vodka and discuss hair dos, awkward 90s parents, and argue whether or not Jordan Catalano is attractive. 2016-02-031h 10
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesThe Monster SquadA very spoopy Halloween treat! Today, we drunkenly overanalyze the 1987 Cult classic- THE MONSTER SQUAD! 2015-10-271h 00
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesSaved by the Bell- The SERIES!We return to our friends at Bayside High to check in with our favorite ethnically and socially diverse group of teens. Today, we discuss two classic episodes, RUNNING ZACK and ALL IN THE MALL .2015-08-0656 min
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesInspector GadgetInspector Gadget- Man? Machine? MONSTER? Explore our in depth discussion of this classic 80s cartoon. Bonus: by far our drunkest episode to date. 2015-06-2530 min
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesBeverly Hills 90210Take a trip with us to the coolest zip code this side of Sunset as we discuss a very special season one episode of Beverly Hills, 90210. Important topics highlighted include race relations, Los Angeles geography, and Debbie Gibson. 2015-04-2839 min
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesA Year Without a Santa ClausWe analyze the rambling plot, the relationship of the Miser Brothers, and Mickey Rooney's alcoholism in the classic Rankin Bass nightmare: A Year Without a Santa Claus! 2014-12-3159 min
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesEpisode 12 - Uncle Buck!We explore Uncle Buck's commentary on the condition of the modern family unit. Also, giant pancakes.2014-12-0556 min
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesEpisode 11 - Nick Toons!We reexperienced three of our very favorite NickToons from the 90s. Did we watch your favorite? MAYBE! Listen to find out!2014-09-241h 07Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesEpisode 10 - A Goofy Movie - with Special Guest!1995 blessed us with many movies: Toy Story, Braveheart, Pocahontas, GoldenEye, Seven and Apollo 13, to name a few. Naturally, we decided to re watch A Goofy Movie instead of any of those other classics. Listen while we all simultaneously remember that it is actually a musical and enjoy as we debate just what kind of creature Goofy actually IS. Also, Caitlin & Tiffany welcome their second ever guest to the show - Tiffany's childhood friend, Jessica Vu! 2014-08-291h 01
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesEpisode 9 - TGIF!Between 1989-2000, between 8-10pm on Friday nights, ABC ran a magical block of television known as TGIF. While many shows appeared on the lineup over the years, we picked three TGIF staples - Family Matters, Dinosaurs, and Boy Meets World - to watch and answer the ultimate question- do they still hold up today? 2014-08-181h 00Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesEpisode 8 - SNES Games!Today, we played a plethora of SNES games, running the gambit from Disney games to MarioKart. We discussed the hotness of child lions versus adult lions, as well as the laws of physics as they apply to the seaworthiness of silverback gorillas.2014-07-0656 min
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesEpisode 7- The Goonies - with Special Guest!!The 1985 nostalgic classic spawns a passionate debate, along with a lengthy sidebar about the Harry Potter Universe. Also, Tiffany and Caitlin welcome their first ever guest, writer for MTV's Happyland and all around good gal, DESIREE PROCTOR!2014-04-2859 min
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesEpisode 6 - SNICK!We (almost) recreated a night of SNICK television: Clarissa Explains it All, Secret World of Alex Mack, and Are You Afraid of the Dark? 2014-04-1859 min
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesEpisode 5 - Food!We eat and judge our favorite childhood snacks. Some hold up fantastically, while others were an unfathomable nightmare. Our taste tests include: Velveeta Mac & Cheese; Kool-Aid; Gushers: Handisnacks; Lunchables; Capri Sun: Hostess Cupcakes: Twinkies2014-03-0858 min
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesEpisode 4 - Saved By the Bell: Hawaiian StyleBayside Class of '93 takes a trip to Hawaii! Armed with nothing but love, ambition, and a trunk full of costumes, can Zack, Kelly, Slater, Jessie, Lisa and Screech save Grandpa Harry's hotel? Will they stop the evil corporate resort from building on sacred Pakuku land? Does anyone actually find French Cut bikinis flattering? 2014-02-251h 00
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesEpisode 3 - Board Games!Today, we played two classic childhood boardgames: Mystery Date Game and Mall Madness. Also, we veered terribly off topic to discuss prom for a while. Enjoy!2014-01-3140 min
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesEpisode 2 - The Santa ClauseLight the yule log, bust out the wassail, and listen to us discuss Disney's Holiday Classic: The Santa Clause, starring superstar/cokehead Tim Allen!2013-12-1659 min
Peanut Butter & Jelly ShoesEpisode 1 - JemWe watched 2 episodes of the classic 80's cartoon "Jem" and provided very, very, in-depth and occasionally inappropriate analysis of the show to answer the question: Does "Jem" hold up today? 2013-12-0959 min