Shows
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Interviews Dawson's DarlingsWe're back with our summer interview series and this time we're talking to Dawson's Darlings! Kim and Zazz are hilarious and best friends and you can feel the warmth they have with each other. It was just delightful to talk with them.
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so much to Killya for our amazing theme song. Find them on Instagram @gofreakingcrazy
Thank you to @camadeclub for our social media awesomeness.
Thank you also to Andrew Bush, who helped guide us on how to do this from our houses.
Find Erin...2022-09-211h 23Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Interviews Dawson's WeaklyThis week we are so thrilled to have Kathryn and Katie from Dawson's Weakly on the podcast. Y'all, we had a blast with them and just talked about everything DC. They have charm and charming British accents.
Don't miss this one!
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so much to Killya for our amazing theme song. Find them on Instagram @gofreakingcrazy
Thank you to @camadeclub for our social media awesomeness.
Thank you also to Andrew Bush, who helped guide us on how to do this from our houses.
Find Erin on...2022-09-141h 55Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 6, Episode 21—Goodbye, Yellow Brick RoadWe're 2 episodes from the end and everything seems to be falling apart at the old creek. Dawson is rightfully mad at Pacey but somehow this turns once again into a conversation about Joey and about Dawson and Pacey's friendship not surviving Joey. Did they even have one to begin with?
Also, truly devastating story with Audrey and her one friend, Jack Osbourne. My god, can this girl catch a break?
Finally, Jen and Jack and Grams are moving to New York, as is CJ, whose real name we discovered.
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama...2022-07-202h 13Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 6, Episode 12—All The Right MovesWoof, you guys. What show or shows are we watching right now? First off, Jen's bangs. Secondly, what show is Pacey on because it's not Dawson's Creek? Third, Why does Joey want to help Eddie now that he ditched her and why are we doing a worse telling of the Pacey/Joey break up but with Joey and Eddie. And finally, why the fuck is Emma not all over Audrey? Who are these people and what did they do with the characters we love?
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so...2022-05-041h 39Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 6, Episode 9—Everything Put Together Falls ApartFirst things first, I have to apologize for some of the audio. I (Julia) was at a 100 year old haunted hotel and the wi-fi was fitting of that description so I did the best I could.
But we're talking about this episode that does not much. We like Joey and Eddie, they're cute. We hate Rich still, Dawson is somehow someone we're supposed to be rooting for? No idea. And fucking Emma and Pacey, ugh? Give Kerr Smith better to work with.
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so much to...2022-04-131h 41Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 6, Episode 8—SpiderwebsUnfortunately the song Spiderwebs is not played in this episode where everyone is messy and wild and No Doubt is playing a concert in Wooster. Natasha and Dawson are making out everywhere and getting arrested. Joey and Eddie are hiding from Dawson and successfully sneaking into the venue. Pacey is punching people...or CJ, not people. Jen and Audrey are not thrilled with each other, and somehow the gays end up taking blonde ladies home.
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so much to Killya for our amazing theme song. Find...2022-04-062h 21Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 6, Episode 7—Ego Tripping At The Gates Of HellEveryone is acting a mess this week. Audrey is breaking shit at the bar, Joey is not standing up for anyone. Jen is not getting the hint that CJ isn't into her, Jack is not getting rid of that professor fast enough, and Pacey is dealing with Rich in New Orleans.
Everything is blowing up spectacularly and Dawson isn't even here for us to blame it all on. *wink*
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so much to Killya for our amazing theme song. Find them on Instagram @gofreakingcrazy
Thank you...2022-03-302h 28Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 6, Episode 6—Living Dead GirlWe do so love a Dawson's Creek Halloween ep and this one is the last one. But man is everyone acting a mess in this. Pacey and Audrey implode spectacularly. Jen and CJ we can't get a handle on. Jack has the best game. And Joey's babysitting Hetson's daughter and growing but also giving out some wild advice.
This is a doozy.
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so much to Killya for our amazing theme song. Find them on Instagram @gofreakingcrazy
Thank you to @camadeclub for our social media awesomeness.
...2022-03-232h 34Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 6, Episode 4—Instant Karma!Here we are, the dreaded Dawson and Joey see each other again scene. But wait, there's another girl who actually calls Dawson out and doesn't get mad at Joey and we're actually here for it. Plus, Dawson and Joey talk FINALLY.
We're loving the Jen, Jack, Audrey hang time and we love a fight where everyone's right and everyone's wrong, like the one Pacey and Audrey have.
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so much to Killya for our amazing theme song. Find them on Instagram @gofreakingcrazy
Thank you to @camadeclub...2022-03-022h 20Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 6, Episode 3—The Importance Of Not Being Too EarnestThis episode is just a wild ride and maybe not in a good way. Joey writes an email to Dawson and oops it goes to all of Worthington instead. Then we get Hetson being awful about that email, Julia rants about Philip Roth, we're both so fucking worried about Audrey, and Erin is breaking down star signs.
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so much to Killya for our amazing theme song. Find them on Instagram @gofreakingcrazy
Thank you to @camadeclub for our social media awesomeness.
Thank you also to Andrew...2022-02-232h 13Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 6, Episode 2—The Song Remains The SameIn the aftermath of Joey and Dawson having sex, we get 30 minutes of them being happy before it all comes crashing down.
Meanwhile, Jack, Audrey, and Pacey provide some comic relief in their search for an apartment, though we don't really know what Audrey's deal is but she seems off.
Grams plays wingwoman to Jen as she meets someone who suggest she be a peer counselor. But the place is super touchy feely and no one needs that.
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so much to Killya for our amazing...2022-02-162h 23Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 6, Episode 1—The Kids Are AlrightWe're back! Thanks for being patient with us. But we're taking about everyone shipping out to Boston, why we love Jack and Pacey so damn much, how the music in the summer of 2002 was absolutely unreal, and I guess we'll talk about Joey and Dawson having sex, if we must.
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so much to Killya for our amazing theme song. Find them on Instagram @gofreakingcrazy
Thank you to @camadeclub for our social media awesomeness.
Thank you also to Andrew Bush, who helped guide us on how...2022-02-092h 02Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 5, Episode 22—The AbbyWe're on the penultimate episode of Season 5 and it's a real weird ride, y'all. Like again, we have people saying and doing stuff we've been begging for but they're saying and doing it about the wrong people. Gah! Also, what TV show are Pacey and Alex on? Because it's not Dawson's Creek, that's for damn sure.
Jen, Jack, and Grams are the saving grace of this episode and their store is everything we want and more. Come for them and stay for Dawson telling Mitch's gravestone that he lost his virginity.
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s...2022-01-122h 04Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 5, Episode 21—After HoursWe're here with this weird episode. Joey's trying to study in the library where everyone is acting a mess, but never goes to her room, where no one is. Pacey cheats on Audrey with Alex and all of these stories are so close to being interesting that it's super frustrating.
Jack's storyline is the most fascinating and we don't get nearly enough of it. And Dawson sleeps with Amy, the film critic, but doesn't have to deal with all the guilt that the women of this show have to when they dare to have sex. Funny how that works.
Join...2022-01-052h 32Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique. Season 5, Episode 20—Separate Ways (World's Apart)Guys, what is even happening? We'd love the Joey storyline if it was with anyone but Charlie. We have no idea if Joey even knows that Dawson came to Florida.
We're excited to see Sherilyn Fenn, but man, at what cost? Just not going to mention Jen or Jack in this episode. Overall maybe the worst of Season 5?
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so much to Killya for our amazing theme song. Find them on Instagram @gofreakingcrazy
Thank you to @camadeclub for our social media awesomeness.
Thank you also to...2021-12-221h 40Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 5, Episode 19—100 LIght Years From HomeIt's the 100th episode! And our 100th episode breakdown! And oof, guys, this is not a good episode. Joey is wilding out all over the place, Pacey, Audrey, and Jack get some meat to work with but the Joey/Dawson retrospective is traumatizing and why on earth is he driving to Florida?
Also, Jen's big storyline is that she has a cold and Joey's mean to her. Ugh. Come on.
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so much to Killya for our amazing theme song. Find them on Instagram @gofreakingcrazy
Thank...2021-12-152h 43Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastREUPLOAD—Dawson's Critique Season 5, Episode 18—Cigarette BurnsTHIS IS THE SAME EP THAT CAME OUT YESTERDAY. But some folks are having a hard time getting the replacement audio, so it's a reupload for them. Sorry again for the issues. Maybe 38 will be the year I get my shit together. —Julia
Y'all, somehow we had a ton to say about this episode because it's so frustrating. Jen and Dawson don't seem like they care that they just broke up, except for one scene. Joey and Charlie is a living nightmare that we're still being subjected to. The only great storyline is Audrey and Pacey. And then Dawson is li...2021-12-092h 48Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 5, Episode 18—Cigarette BurnsY'all, somehow we had a ton to say about this episode because it's so frustrating. Jen and Dawson don't seem like they care that they just broke up, except for one scene. Joey and Charlie is a living nightmare that we're still being subjected to. The only great storyline is Audrey and Pacey. And then Dawson is like talking to some random lady instead of any of his friends.
Look, we'll take Meredith Salenger any day, but like this? Must we?
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so much to Killya...2021-12-082h 48Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 5, Episode 17—Highway To HellWhew. It's a real mess this week. Joey is bailing on Lily's 1st birthday to go to some biker bar and sing with Charlie's band and we're glad that she actually expresses a desire, but man do we hate Charlie.
Also, Pacey and Audrey come and there's just zero tension about the fact that Audrey and Pacey are dating? None. That doesn't seem real.
Finally, Jen wants to break up with Dawson and we're devastated. Also, an India.Arie song is cut and we're also devastated about that. Ugh.
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama...2021-12-012h 07Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 5, Episode 16—In A Lonely PlaceOkay, we're in the aftermath of Joey's assault, but don't get too excited because almost no one even seems to care, including Joey herself.
Everyone has nights out—Jen and Audrey, Jack and Pacey, Joey and Dawson—that change their perspectives and we're along for the ride. Jen and Audrey at a rock show and talking to two band members, Jack and Pacey at a gay bar (the delight of this episode), and Joey and Dawson at a movie screening where the run into Wilder. Woof.
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you...2021-11-172h 38Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Talks To Dawson's CreepsHey y'all! Life got in the way this week and we just couldn't get Downtown Crossing recorded in time, but to make it up to you, we have a fun interview with Dawson's Creeps!
We had so much fun chatting with these folks and we hope you'll enjoy as well!
Thanks for being here with us.2021-11-0347 minDawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Creek Season 5, Episode 14—Guerilla FilmmakingIt's time to make a movie! Dawson is shooting Oliver's script which stars Audrey and we have to replace Oliver with Charlie (ugh) who is perfect for the role but must we put Jen through this?
Joey and Wilder are having some conversations that we're having a hard time caring about. Can this story be done please?
And we deal with Pacey and Audrey and their kiss. This was a fun one and next week is not going to be so enjoy!
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so much to...2021-10-272h 24Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 5, Epsiode 13—Something WilderWhew, we love some of this and hate some of it. The Jen, Dawson, and Oliver scenes are just perfection. The fact that any of those men survive is just incredible. Jen has great restraint.
We love Joey and Audrey's friendship. But man do we wish they were talking about anything other than Joey's professor.
Also, Pacey is such a great friend to Jack and we just wish Jack could find people that aren't awful to make new friends with, but alas.
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so much to...2021-10-201h 47Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 5, Episode 12—Sleeping ArrangementsDawson and Jen are living together and honestly have a great argument and make up in this ep. We love it. We discuss Pacey as poor kid fantasy for his rich sometimes lady friend. And Jack's frat bros get homophobic in a way that no one could have predicted (just kidding, we all predicted it).
We're still having fun but a couple of these stories are not our favs. But join us while we rip it all apart!
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so much to Killya for our amazing...2021-10-132h 01Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 5, Episode 11—Something WildIt's winter break and everyone is acting, well, wild. Joey and Audrey make a pact to kiss a guy by the end of their night out and Joey kisses Charlie, which we have FEELINGS about.
Dawson and Jen go home to Capeside and it's the first time going home to meet the parents with a significant other. Dawson acts wild and then doesn't apologize but it's kind of not his fault. But still, ugh.
And also, why is Joey singing again. What a mess.
We hope everyone is staying safe, healthy, and sane. Hope we help you get through this...2021-10-062h 00Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 5, Episode 10—Appetite For DestructionIt's time for this absolute romp of an episode. The gang finds out about Dawson and Jen and everyone keeps entering and exiting various rooms to discuss feelings, avoid discussing feelings, make out, cook dinner, eat dinner, and avoid each other, just to name some of the things that happen.
The complaint we agree on the most, not enough Jen, but we have a pretty frank discussion about Joey and her behavior, Dawson and his behavior and what a delight Audrey is, as always.
Love this one!
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
...2021-09-292h 42Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 5, Episode 8—The Hotel New HampshireWe're here! This is the episode that began our friendship. Yes, it's the one where Dawson loses his virginity, yes, we love every second of it...the Dawson losing his virginity part that is.
Between Dawson and Jen being there for each other, Joey standing up to Jack for being an asshole, and Jack standing up to her right back, and well, let's just forget the Pacey storyline here.
Just a gem of an episode that we had a ton of fun talking about.
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so...2021-09-152h 17Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 5, Episode 7—Text, Lies And VideotapeWe loved this episode! The Jen and Dawson parts. The Joey and Dawson not having storylines together. Joey being a good roommate to Audrey. We'll take it all...with the exception of the Pacey and Karen story, which we have some issues with. How is it that Pacey is our least favorite character this episode?
Guess you'll have to listen and find out!
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so much to Killya for our amazing theme song. Find them on Instagram @gofreakingcrazy
Thank you to @camadeclub for our social media...2021-09-081h 56Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 5, Episode 6—High AnxietyDawson's in Boston to see a shrink but instead of actually going he ends up at a frat party with Jack. Meanwhile, our dream friend couple, Jen and Pacey, talk about what she's going to do about Charlie and she ends up getting back at him with his other girlfriend, Nora, who we love.
Audrey's mom is in town and Joey reluctantly goes to dinner with them, and ignores a lot of abuse being hurled at Audrey before she FINALLY stands up for a woman and we love it.
Everyone ends up at a party on Pacey's boat where Dawson...2021-09-012h 26Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 5, Episode 5—Use Your DisillusionThis episode made us defend frat boys and we're not thrilled about it. We love Pacey and Jen's friendship and wish we got a million more hours of them, but we're so confused about most of the rest of this episode.
What are we even supposed to be rooting for with Dawson and Joey? Are we supposed to be mad at Jack? Because we're not. And finally, why must we always do Jen so dirty?
Also SURPRISE, WE'RE TOGETHER IN THE SAME ROOM WHEN WE DISCUSS THIS EPISODE!
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's...2021-08-252h 17Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 5, Episode 3—Capeside RevisitedJoey, Jen, and Audrey hang out and we love every second of it. Also, please tell us who our characters line up with in Sex and the City because we're having that conversation.
Joey sees Pacey and dare we say growth—she doesn't throw Jen under the bus, and she isn't mad at Pacey. Wow, Josephine, we're proud. Also, she goes to see Pacey at his boat and yet another David Gray song has been cut, but this is just so swoon-worthy.
Jen is having hot sex with Charlie but is worried that sex is all they are. Girl, have fu...2021-08-042h 25Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 5, Episode 2—The Lost WeekendWell apparently Joey and Dawson have spent the whole weekend together and talked about literally nothing, so here we are. Luckily everyone else is amazing so we continue to have a great time in season 5.
Love this Jen and Charlie story so far and honestly, we hope Jen is having a great time with early-00s Chad Michael Murray, so many teenage dreams coming true there.
Audrey continues to be the literal best as she takes Dawson around campus and talks to him about Joey. We even kind of like Dawson while he's with Audrey.
Also, super into Pacey maybe...2021-07-281h 43Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 5, Episode 1—The BostoniansWe're shipping out to Boston this week. That's right, it's the start of season 5 and Joey, Jack, and Jen are in Boston starting college while Dawson has to stay in LA because he needs to wear sandals and cargo shorts to his internship on a movie lot. And we have so many questions.
But honestly, we don't care about Dawson and Joey right now because Jack, Jen, and Joey are FRIENDS! And Joey's new roommate, Audrey, is incredible. And Audrey says that Jen's her new best friend and we have to scream about Busy Phillips and Michelle Williams for like 12...2021-07-212h 19Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 4 Recap, Pt. IIWe are continuing to break down the good, the bad, and the ugly of Season 4 of Dawson's Creek. Join us as we answer listener questions, and talk about how we felt after rewatching this season.
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so much to Killya for our amazing theme song. Find them on Instagram @gofreakingcrazy
Thank you to @camadeclub for our social media awesomeness.
Thank you also to Andrew Bush, who helped guide us on how to do this from our houses.
Find Erin on Instagram at @erin.hensley
Find Julia...2021-07-071h 18Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 4 Recap, Part IWe are breaking down the good, the bad, and the ugly of Season 4 of Dawson's Creek. Join us as we answer listener questions, and talk about how we felt after rewatching this season.
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so much to Killya for our amazing theme song. Find them on Instagram @gofreakingcrazy
Thank you to @camadeclub for our social media awesomeness.
Thank you also to Andrew Bush, who helped guide us on how to do this from our houses.
Find Erin on Instagram at @erin.hensley
Find Julia on Twitter...2021-06-301h 06Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 4, Episode 21—Separation AnxietyWell everyone is broken up and we're going to feel the pain of it. Gretchen is leaving Capeside and Dawson decides that what he should really do is join her on a road trip and skip his high school graduation.
Joey takes Pacey to a Worthington party when the dean of admissions tells her that he has a proposition for Pacey. It's not the one they were hoping for though.
And finally, Jen tells Jack she can't go with him to Boston Bay College because she doesn't want Grams to sell the house and move into the La Brea park...2021-06-092h 02Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 4, Episode 18—Eastern Standard TimeIt's senior ditch day, which we can't remember if we had or not, but Joey and Jen are living out our dream for them by being there for each other in New York as Jen confronts her dad about their relationship.
Meanwhile, Dawson and Gretchen are living out real life shit that's happened to us, by going on an unplanned road trip and then getting a flat tire and dealing with it. Don't worry, we'll be screaming about these teenagers and their decisions around sex some more.
And of course, Pacey ends up with Drue at a dive bar, getting...2021-05-192h 19Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 4, Episode 17—AdmissionsIt's college acceptance time and my god what a nightmare. Jack and Jen have decided that they're going to go to the same college but Jen is hesitant about going back to New York.
When Dawson's parents and Joey's sister call the school and ask them both to call home about college mail (seriously, this was not a thing) they learn that Joey got into Worthington (a very real college) and Dawson did not get into NYU.
But of course, reality is slapped into Joey when she doesn't get financial aid, and thus can't go. Dawson makes the choice to...2021-05-121h 58Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Special Report—Death To Joey Potter's VirginityJoin us in this special episode where we dissect the death of our least favorite character on Dawson's Creek—Joey's virginity.
We take some questions and discuss the male gaze-iness of Joey's virginity loss.
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so much to Killya for our amazing theme song. Find them on Instagram @gofreakingcrazy
Thank you to @camadeclub for our social media awesomeness.
Thank you also to Andrew Bush, who helped guide us on how to do this from our houses.
Find Erin on Instagram at @erin.hensley
Find Julia on Tw...2021-05-0559 minDawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 4, Episode 16—Mind GamesPacey and Joey are HORNY and ready to bone each other like all the time, and we are very happy about this. But oh hey, remember when Joey lied to Dawson, that's coming back to bite her and everyone else in the ass in a big way.
Also, Jack and Jen stalk Jen's therapist, which is wild, but we'll watch this buddy detective show any day.
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so much to Killya for our amazing theme song. Find them on Instagram @gofreakingcrazy
Thank you to @camadeclub for...2021-04-282h 25Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 4, Episode 15—Four StoriesIn dealing with the aftermath of the ski trip and Mr. Brooks's death, we get, you guessed it, four different stories. In the first, Joey and Pacey miss the bus and have a post-coital discussion when they're waiting to get back home.
In one, Dawson deals with his feelings about Mr. Brooks and how he lived his life. Do we think Dawson is scared he's going to end up like Brooks? Yes.
Jen gets sent to therapy, which shockingly is happening for the first time, and maybe she'll come back? Let's hope, even if we don't love this therapist.
And...2021-04-211h 56Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 4, Episode 14—A Winter's TaleJoin us for this hot mess of an episode that ends with one of the most romantic scenes in tv history. We're talking about the absolute ridiculousness of Dawson possibly having control over ending Brooks's life, and the fact that Andy Griffith comes to say good-bye to Brooks.
Jack and Jen have one of the best scenes of their friendship on the show, and then promptly ruin it.
And Joey is awful to Pacey until she's very much not awful to him.
Also, that fucking phone call.
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
...2021-04-142h 18Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 4, Episode 13—HopelessIt's time for Dawson to meet Gretchen's friends, and one of them is Rachel True, and we are so excited about it. But the age difference between Dawson and Gretchen has never been more apparent.
Meanwhile, Joey and Pacey have to take Drue and Anna (whose dad is president of the Capeside Yacht Club) on a double date, so Joey can get time off for the Senior Trip. Side note: on what planet are these guys the kind of people who go on a senior trip?
Also, Tobey tries Jen's advice of being nice to Jack with varied results, when...2021-03-312h 32Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 4, Episode 12—The Te Of PaceyIt's Pacey's 18th birthday, and it's full of plot holes. Did Joey and Pacey ever go to Sunday night dinners? Because if they did, why is Joey so shocked at how much Pacey's family sucks?
Dawson makes the rookie mistake of thinking just because you go on a date with someone, doesn't mean you're in a relationship.
And why the fuck is Tobey so mean to Jack, and why is Jen encouraging Tobey's crush on Jack, when Tobey and Jack seem to really not get along at all? So many questions, so few answers.
Join us for this deep dive...2021-03-242h 11Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 4, Episode 11—The Tao Of DawsonThis week we're talking about all kinds of men behaving badly. Between Dawson, Pacey, and Drue, we have a trifecta of shitty dudes...and Joey isn't great either.
Between Pacey trying to pawn Gretchen off on her ex, Drue sexually assaulting Joey (can this girl catch a damn break?), or Dawson trying to tell Grams her life, everyone is messy. And to top it all off, we end with a romcom trope that we kind of love and kind of hate. This one's a ride.
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you...2021-03-172h 06Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 4, Episode 10—Self RelianceThe fallout from Dawson and Gretchen's kiss at the holiday party is reverberating through Capeside, because when is a kiss ever JUST a kiss in this little town?
Pacey and Joey are fighting over how Joey feels about it, while completely ruining their time without Bessie and Bodie watching over them.
Jen and Jack go to Provincetown to a Gay Straight alliance meeting and meet Tobey, who, like every man on this show, must be a dick before he can be nice. Ugh. But great one liners, and Jen is amazing as always.
Join us for this deep dive into...2021-03-102h 12Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 4, Episode 9—Kiss Kiss Bang BangMerry Christmas in March. This episode is all over the place, with Joey completely out of her element and throwing Pacey under the bus at a Worthington networking dinner, while Gretchen negotiates to throw the annual Leery holiday part at Mitch and Gail's house.
Meanwhile, Gail is WAY more pregnant than she should be at this point. Also, we learn that Grams is STILL not talking to Jen for the whole Andie taking an ecstasy tablet that Jen had, but did not procure for herself, so that's wild.
Also, Dawson learns the truth about Mr. Brooks's past and then ends...2021-03-032h 13Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 4, Episode 8—The Unusual SuspectsWelcome to Dawson's Noir! And Congratulations to the class of 2001 (us)!
This week we are trying to solve the mystery of who put the principal's boat and dog in Capeside High's indoor swimming pool (what is this high school?!?). Luckily, the new principal is played by Harry Shearer, who holds this weird episode together.
Warning: This is a dude-centric episode and we feel the dearth of ladies, but Jen gives us one of the best pratfalls of all time, so we can forgive.
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so much...2021-02-241h 46
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 4, Episode 6—Great XpectationsTime to celebrate! Andie gets into Harvard and the gang all ends up at a rave. Andie takes one of the ecstasy pills that Drue gave Jen, and Jen has to be rave mom to Andie, who is TERRIBLE at hiding the fact that she's high.
When the X reacts badly with Andie's antidepressants she needs medical attention, but before she can be taken away in an ambulance, Jack blames Jen for this scene, and must we continue to do this shit?
Pacey feels bad that he didn't know there was a problem and stays at the hospital, while Dawson...2021-02-102h 26
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 4, Episode 4—Future TenseThis episode gives us literally every single thing that we want from Dawson's Creek—friend moments, great Pacey/Joey content, Jen/Joey/Andie girlfriend bonding time, Jack/Andie brother/sister time, and of course, the greatest character: Drunk Joey!
Join us as we just gush about how much we fucking love this episode.
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so much to Killya for our amazing theme song. Find them on Instagram @gofreakingcrazy
Thank you to @camadeclub for our social media awesomeness.
Thank you also to Andrew Bush, who helped guide us...2021-01-272h 06
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 4, Episode 3—The Two Gentlemen Of CapesideIt's the last beautiful day of the season...or so Pacey thought. The Perfect Storm done Capeside style, this episode is action packed. We have Jen and Pacey in danger on the True Love; Joey, Dawson, and Drue thrown together for a school project; Dawson being totally oblivious to Joey's increasing panic.
This is a great one, and showcases not only everything that we've been begging for for multiple seasons, but also sets so much into motion!
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so much to Killya for our amazing theme...2021-01-201h 50
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critque Season 4, Episode 2—Failing DownIt's the first day of senior year, and Pacey is officially not a senior, but he's not going to tell Joey because he's embarrassed. Mitch tells Dawson this for some reason and Dawson goes to Joey to tell her and it's a real nightmare.
Meanwhile, Jack breaks up with Jen for Henry who has proven that he was not worthy of our time last year, and all in all, senior year is not starting great.
We hope everyone is staying safe, healthy, and sane. Hope we help you get through this week.
Join us for this deep dive into the 90...2021-01-131h 51
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 4, Episode 1—Coming HomeWhat happens after you sail off into the sunset? That's what we're talking about in Season 4 of Dawson's Creek. This week, Joey and Pacey come back from their trip and immediately start fighting, but is this the greatest fight ever? We love it.
Dawson has the worst hair ever, and also is still hurt, but maybe has moved forward. Jen, Andie, Jack, and Dawson have been hanging nonstop this summer and we love it.
We meet Gretchen Witter—a queen. And we get to discuss why the Real World New Orleans is involved with this episode.
We hope everyone is st...2021-01-061h 52Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 3—Recap, Pt. 2In part 2 of our Season 3 recap,we're taking your questions, pontificating wildly, and just having a good discussion about Dawson's Creek and life.
We hope everyone is staying safe, healthy, and sane. Hope we help you get through this week.
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so much to Killya for our amazing theme song. Find them on Instagram @gofreakingcrazy
Thank you to @camadeclub for our social media awesomeness.
Thank you also to Andrew Bush, who helped guide us on how to do this from our houses.
Find Erin on Instagram...2020-12-302h 00Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 3—Recap, Pt. 1In this week's episode, we start the first of our two part recap of Season 3. We're taking your questions, pontificating wildly, and just having a good discussion about Dawson's Creek and life.
We hope everyone is staying safe, healthy, and sane. Hope we help you get through this week.
Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so much to Killya for our amazing theme song. Find them on Instagram @gofreakingcrazy
Thank you to @camadeclub for our social media awesomeness.
Thank you also to Andrew Bush, who helped guide us on how to...2020-12-2355 min
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 3, Episode 23—True LoveAt last the ship that launched a thousand ships is sailing into the sunset. Dawson tries to remind Joey of what they had before literally telling her she's free—and this is somehow not the end of their friendship.
Jen, Jack, Andie, and Grams go on a wild Carpe Diem road trip so that Jen can apologize to Henry. Jack also goes to Ethan to kiss him and tell him that he's ready but it doesn't go as planned. Still, this is was such a huge deal at the time that we break it down for ya'll.
Pacey and Joey fi...2020-12-162h 41
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 3, Episode 22—The Anti-PromWe remember everything about this episode where Jack is discriminated against for being gay, Joey and Andie are great allies, and Dawson is a dick, but somehow makes this prom happen as if he's a hero? Ugh.
A classic episode of tv, and one of the best of Dawson's Creek, this episode is full of drama and the most romantic scene in tv history. My god we love this one.
We remember EVERYTHING.
Subvert the dominant paradigm.
Put on your life preservers and remember to ask permission before boarding. We're in for a wild ride!
We hope everyone is staying...2020-12-092h 38
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 3, Episode 21—Show Me LoveEveryone behaves like utter garbage in this episode that deals in the aftermath of everyone finding out about Pacey and Joey. Dawson is the worst, but everyone behaves poorly except for Will Krudski, who we say good-bye to in this ep.
But you know what it means when everyone acts like garbage—this is a long one.
Put on your life preservers and remember to ask permission before boarding. We're in for a wild ride!
We hope everyone is staying safe, healthy, and sane. Hope we help you get through this week.
Join us for Season 3, Episode 20 of the 90s te...2020-12-022h 37
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 3, Episode 20—The Longest DayHoly shit! This episode blew our minds in 2000, and remains one of the best episode of the entire series. We follow each character as they come to discover the truth about Joey and Pacey.
It's a ride, each and every time, and we love every second of it, even when Dawson is being awful—and we wanted to give him so much slack. Also, stay for the repeated lines, and the Watergate assignment in which we just talk about what a great movie Dick is.
Put on your life preservers and remember to ask permission before boarding. We're in for a...2020-11-252h 21
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 3, Episode 19—Stolen KissesCue up Daydream Believer, because we are here! Joey feels alive, as does Erin. Julia is dead and by the end of this episode we're so in love with Pacey Witter and his looking for consent that we can barely hold it together.
In other news, this is one of the few episodes where we find Jen difficult to really root for. While Mitch and Gail have some deep conversations about what they mean to each other.
Don't forget to let us know your favorite Wild Women of Dawson's Creek and your favorite Karaoke song!
Put on your life preservers...2020-11-182h 08
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 3, Episode 18—NeverlandYa'll in 2000, after waiting weeks to find out what happened after Pacey kissed Joey, we came back to this episode, which was NOT what we expected. Now, it's one of our favorite episodes.
Andie, Jen, and Joey FINALLY learn that maybe they should have some female friends in a way that has us cheering.
Meanwhile, Pacey and Dawson go camping, where Pacey tries to tell Dawson about his feelings for Joey but is stymied by Buzz and his friends, and then by his own realization that he really will lose Dawson as a friend if he goes for Joey.
Jack...2020-11-112h 32
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 3, Episode 17—Cinderella StoryIT FINALLY HAPPENED! Pacey kissed Joey and the world of Dawson's Creek has started to right itself. But first we have to endure an entire episode with A.J. where we learn that A.J. is the Dawson (this tracks) to his friend Morgan's Joey, and Joey ends up the Jen in this situation.
We also spend time at Gail Leery's restaurant, which is in utter chaos just a week before opening and we are stressed and everyone is eating so much gross chowder. Ugh.
But in the end, Pacey kisses Joey and we haven't been the same since we...2020-11-041h 53
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 3, Episode 15—Crime & PunishmentJoey paints a pretty culturally insensitive mural, but that's not the story, the story is that someone defaces it and Pacey gets in a fight defending Joey's honor. Pacey and Dawson argue over how best to help Joey.
Andie quits the disciplinary committee and tells Jack and then Principal Green about cheating on the PSATs.
Pacey gets kicked out of his house and moves in with Doug, and while moping about his fight, he lets it slip that Dawson asked Pacey to watch out for Joey. But instead of that turning into a huge thing, it makes Pacey and Joey...2020-10-211h 59
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 3, Episode 12—A Weekend In The CountryThis is a big one, y'all. Pacey brings in a travel writer and B&B critic (who knew that was a thing) to review the Potter B&B on its first weekend...and things don't exactly go swimmingly.
Dawson is mad at his parents for playing a happy couple to help the Potter B&B, but he helps and apologizes to Jen, when she comes to him, nervous about what Henry might think about her past.
And of course, we get one of the most important endings of the whole show. This really does change everything.
Put on your life...2020-09-302h 07
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 3, Episode 11—Barefoot At CapefestThere's a huge music festival in Capeside that none of our teens have heard about, but Ethan, the guy Jack met on the train in the last episode, is attending and Jack drags Jen along to camp (ugh).
Jack ditches Jen to hangout with Ethan and when he does, she finds Henry, who is as horrid as ever. Please run away from him, Jen.
Meanwhile, Andie has signed on to be the assistant director for the school play—Barefoot in the Park. She is appalled to find out that Pacey will be playing the lead character, and after failing to co...2020-09-232h 26
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 3, Episode 10—First Encounters Of The Close KindDawson, Joey, Jack, and Andie all go to Cambridge, MA, to an unnamed university (hmm...wonder which one), where they get their first taste of college life.
Dawson gets knocked down a peg or two when his movie bombs at a film festival, but we are introduced to Bianca Lawson's character Nikki Green, and we are not mad about it.
Joey gets put in a room with a real dick named A.J. and we are definitely mad about it.
Jack tries to discover the gay scene in Boston but goes to a place that really isn't for him. Trying...2020-09-162h 23
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 3, Episode 9—Four To TangoIt's the turnaround episode of season 3, and we're here for it. Pacey needs Joey's help in math and she makes him learn how to ballroom dance to help her win a scholarship in return for her help in school.
When Dawson finds a condom in his room, he makes the wrong assumption that Pacey and Joey are sleeping together, but it all comes to a head when everyone catches Pacey and Jen making out in the coat room. We're renting His Girl Friday again just to keep up.
Meanwhile, Jack meets a guy online and may or may not go...2020-09-092h 02
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 3, Episode 8—Guess Who's Coming To DinnerIt's Thanksgiving 1999 and shit is a mess. Jen and Pacey's burgeoning non-sex life is being thrown off course by Grams's Thanksgiving plans, which includes a surprise visit by Jen's mom, Helen. And in a not super happy turn of events, Helen confesses to Jen that she has a half-sister.
Meanwhile, the McPhees show up to the Thanksgiving, making Pacey and Andie uncomfortable and necessitating a conversation to get them back on track to being friends.
Dawson realizes that his parents's divorce is final, even though his mom is back to living with them, and Mitch and Gail seem to be...2020-09-021h 52
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 3, Episode 7—Escape From Witch IslandThe original four—Pacey, Joey, Jen, and Dawson—get out of writing a paper on The Crucible by traveling to Witch Island and making a documentary that is definitely not a rip-off of The Blair Witch Project.
Jen and Pacey decide that they're going to try to be friends with benefits (or is it that the love potion Jen made actually works?). Meanwhile, Joey and Dawson realize that they kind of aren't friends anymore, and they spend the episode arguing over what that means, and where they go from here.
This is a mighty fun one!
Put on your life pres...2020-08-261h 50
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 3, Episode 5—Indian SummerMan it's a hot one this week. And Dawson and Pacey are in their own weird noir movie where they need to track down Eve because she broke into Grams' house for some reason.
Jack and Jen are adorable, but have a big fight when Jack tries to set Jen up with Henry without telling her and Jen is rightly pissed. When they talk it out, they both reveal some deep secrets and we could not love them more.
Joey puts herself on the line (and loses her job) to protect Andie when she goes out with Joey's creep of...2020-08-121h 28
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 3, Episode 4—Home MoviesRemember the betamax? Aw. Memories.
Dawson gets an opportunity to do a human interest story that will air to a lot of people, but we're not sure exactly where it will air. He chooses Jack—gay kid on the bad football team that makes it a winning team. But when Mitch expresses displeasure with the choice of topics, he and Dawson fight about it because Mitch doesn't actually communicate his concerns.
Pacey and Joey go on a hilarious journey while they cut school that ends with him showing Joey a boat he's going to restore that he's named the True Lo...2020-08-051h 45
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 3, Episode 3—None Of The AboveEve brings Dawson a copy of the PSAT and he, in turn, brings it to the Creek kids. When a fire alarm goes off, the test gets stolen, and instead of Dawson seeing this as the gift it is, he decides he's going to track down who, exactly stole it.
In the meantime, Jack is getting the snot beaten out of him in football practice and thinks it's because he's gay, but really it's because he's the new kid. And Joey is consistently sexually harassed by her boss. Ugh.
When Dawson blames a drunk and sad over Andie Pacey for...2020-07-291h 44
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 3, Episode 2—HomecomingJen's a cheerleader, and Jack's on the football team? We went away for the summer and everyone went crazy?
Joey and Pacey go to get Andie from the mental health clinic she's been in for the summer, but things aren't exactly the same as they were.
Eve, ever the wild card, propositions Dawson for sex where she picks the time and place, and the time and place is behind the screen where Dawson's propaganda football movie is playing during a nighttime pep rally...yeah, it's a lot. Joey sees Dawson and Eve and they have a conversation about how they...2020-07-221h 46
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 2, Episode 22—Parental Discretion AdvisedIt's the end of season 2! And this episode is a wild ride that includes a fire, someone wearing a wire, talk of teen suicide, and Pacey punching his dad in the face.
When the Ice House burns down, Dawson forces Joey to turn her dad in for dealing drugs. We hate it. Thanks. But on the plus side, Jack and Jen decide they don't want to be alone and both move in with Grams. Chosen Family for the win.
Pacey and his dad have a nice moment, but we're not entirely convinced that this really fixes their relationship. Imagine if...2020-07-082h 07
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 2, Episode 21—Ch...Ch...Ch...ChangesChanges abound in Capeside, MA.
Andie's dad has come back to take her back to Providence, leaving Pacey and Jack to try and convince him to let her stay. While Jen contemplates leaving Capeside with nowhere to go, as her parents have told her she's not welcome with them. Ugh, these parents.
Finally, Dawson needs to find people to interview for his film project on how people around him have changed. He ends up interviewing Mr. Potter and in the end sees something he probably shouldn't have. A whole mess here.
We hope everyone is staying safe, healthy, and sane...2020-07-011h 55
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique, Season 2, Episode 19—Abby Morgan, Rest In PeaceAlas, it is time to say goodbye to Abby Morgan, and all of the Creek kids are agreed that she was an asshole, but she changed them all in meaningful ways.
Joey decides to finally visit her mom's grave, and asks Dawson to come with her. Oh, and they say 2 sentences to each other about their kiss and are now apparently back together. Great communication happening all around.
Speaking of communication, Gail tells Dawson that she got offered a job in Philadelphia, but doesn't tell Mitch. Dawson tells Mitch in hopes that his parents will get back together, but that...2020-06-172h 08
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique, Season 2, Episode 18—A Perfect WeddingWell, Mike Potter is back in Capeside and the Ice House is going to cater a wedding. What could go wrong?
Erin and Julia discuss Jack and Joey's continued friendship, Andie and Pacey's role as comic relief, and Dawson and Joey's possible reunion. Spoiler: we hate it.
Top that all off with an ending that will change everything and this is one you won't want to miss.
We hope everyone is staying safe, healthy, and sane. Hope we help you get through this week.
Join us for Season 2, Episode 16 of the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so much...2020-06-102h 29
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 2, Episode 17—Psychic FriendsJoin us in what is most definitely the worst episode of season 2 of Dawson's Creek. We discuss why this episode happened at all, what they were trying to get at and how we feel like we move nowhere good by the time we hit the shocking ending.
Whew, ya'll. This was a doozy, but we got through it and actually had quite a bit to say about boundaries, gaydar, and Mädchen Amick's first episode!
We hope everyone is staying safe, healthy, and sane. Hope we help you get through this week.
Join us for Season 2, Episode 17 of the 90s t...2020-06-031h 49
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique—Season 2, Episode 16—Be Careful What You Wish ForOn this episode of Dawson's Creek, it is a miracle that Dawson has any friends that will speak to him after how he behaves at his 16th birthday.
Joey plans a surprise party for Dawson, despite his telling her he wants to be together and then getting mad when she says that's not what she wants.
Andie and Dawson get drunk and sing the worst blues song ever. While Pacey tries to corral them to the party.
And Jack and Abby Morgan have an interesting talk about sexuality, which leads to a nightmare scenario in Dawson's room.
We hope everyone...2020-05-272h 23
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Criqite Season 2, Episode 15—That Is The QuestionIn the second half of the big two parter, Jack and Andie's dad shows up when he finds out what's been happening at school with Jack. And Jack reveals something about himself that changes everything...for the better, as far as we're concerned.
Meanwhile, Jen is inexplicably dating Ty, and Joey and Dawson end up at the jazz club we may or may not be referring to as The Peach Pit, where we all learn that Ty can play a passable jazz piano, and where the proverbial triangle of Dawson, Joey, and Jen, find out that actually they kind of...2020-05-202h 16
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 2, Episode 14—To Be Or Not To BeIn this first episode of the big two parter, Jack is forced by a sadistic teacher to read a poem in class that ends up making him cry. By lunch, the whole school is atwitter that Jack is gay.
Joey is with Dawson when she hears, of course, and Dawson goes from being kind of a dick about it to giving her good advice.
Pacey stands up for Jack, which puts him at odds with Andie.
And Jen's storyline is completely out of touch with this main one, as she goes on a non-religious date with Ty, who will not...2020-05-132h 09
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 2, Episode 13—His Leading LadyDawson is supposed to start filming his new movie, 'Creek Times', and he still doesn't have someone to play Sammy, the character that is basically Joey in Dawson's interpretation of his relationship with Joey.
As luck would have it, when Dawson shows up randomly at Joey's art class, the girl who is posing naked is an actress and he casts her in the movie! Rachel Leigh Cook, star of on of Julia's favorite movies, Josie and the Pussycats, is featured in this totally bananas episode of Dawson's Creek!
Check out who is the real leading lady of this episode, and...2020-05-062h 00
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 2, Episode 12—Uncharted WatersIn our first episode recording at home and not at the studio, Erin and Julia navigate the rough waters of the Witter family, namely Pacey's dad and their very hard relationship.
While Dawson, Mitch, Pacey, John Witter, and (surprisingly) Jack, all end up on a boat doing very manly fishing things together, the women of Dawson's Creek end up at the Leery's so Gail can interview them about the struggles of being teenage girls.
Joey's weird competition with Jen finally reaches a head and might we say they reach an uneasy peace by the end?
We hope everyone is staying...2020-04-291h 51
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 2, Episode 10—High Risk BehaviorLet's talk about sex, baby! In this VERY steamy episode of Dawson's Critique, Julia needs a cold shower after Jack explains sex to Joey referencing only works of art, Erin is, as ever, not here for Dawson's weirdo shit, and Erin and Julia agree that Pacey and Andie are so freaking perfect that it's almost too much to bear.
Join us for Season 2, Episode 10 of the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so much to Killya for our amazing theme song. Find them on Instagram @gofreakingcrazy
Thank you to @camadeclub for our social media awesomeness.
Thank you also to...2020-04-151h 24
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 2, Episode 8—The Reluctant HeroWhat makes a person a hero? Erin and Julia break down who exactly the titular reluctant hero is in this episode of Dawson's Creek.
Jack and Joey go on a dat, which is decidedly not a date; Pacey helps Andie with her mom in a way that melts both Julia and Erin into puddles on the floor; and Dawson handles a spiraling Jen in a tremendously shitty way—which is to say Dawson acts like himself.
Join us for Season 2, Episode 8 of the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so much to Killya for our amazing theme song. Find th...2020-04-011h 26
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 2, Episode 7—The All-NighterThe Capeside teens pull an all-nighter to study for their English midterm and drama ensues. Post-breakup, Dawson and Joey are yelling at each other at every turn. Andie and Pacey are sweet, but a little unsure of where they are with each other.
Meanwhile, new guy Chris, played by Roswell star Jason Behr, is trying to seduce Jen, which she is well aware of, while Dawson tries to stick his face in their situation, where it doesn't belong.
Pile on all that a little sister that would make Abby Morgan proud, and it's one wild night in Capeside, Mass for...2020-03-251h 26
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 2, Episode 6—The DanceShit always goes down at dances in Capeside, and this one is a doozy. Jack McPhee and Jen Lindley FINALLY meet each other, while Dawson learns that Jack kissed Joey (conveniently forgetting that Jen kissed him just a few episodes ago and nothing was made of that, but whatever, boys will be boys...).
While Jack, Joey, and Dawson duke it out, Pacey and Andie sweep us all off our feet by dancing to Jessica Simpson to make up for dancing with Ali Larter. It's a wild ride.
Join us for Season 2, Episode 6 of the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank...2020-03-181h 24
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 2, Episode 3—Alternative LifestylesA class project requires old flames to work together, new possible flames to find out more about each other, and Joey to possibly get some guidance from a Successful Business Woman!
Erin and Julia discuss this excellent school project, why Pacey is the greatest dude, and what we're feeling about Jen's behavior to Dawson and Dawson's behavior to Jen.
Join us for Season 2, Episode 3 of the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so much to Killya for our amazing theme song. Find them on Instagram @gofreakingcrazy
Thank you to @camadeclub for our social media awesomeness.
Thank you also to...2020-02-261h 30
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 2, Episode 2—CrossroadsJulia and Erin discuss Season 2, Episode 2 of Dawson's Creek—Crossroads. Not to be confused by the Britney Spears classic of the the same name, this episode features the scene where Dawson Leery became dead to Erin Hensley, as well as the introduction of Jack McPhee: an icon.
Listen as Erin and Julia talk about platform flip-flops as dress shoes, why we love Kentucky but need the citizens of the state to do one thing before they can receive our full-throated endorsement, and what happens when everyone forgets Pacey's birthday.
Join us for Season 2, Episode 2 of the 90s teen drama Dawson's Cr...2020-02-191h 33
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 2, Episode 1—The KissWe're back for Season 2! The production quality is higher, the haircuts are uglier, and Dawson and Joey have kissed each other when not being dared by Abby Morgan.
Erin and Julia are so thrilled that it's season 2 and we have NEW CHARACTERS! Andie McPhee literally runs her car into Pacey and crashes into our hearts. Julia and Erin have some questions about Joey's decision not to go to France because of Dawson Leery, but maybe come to an easy peace with it by the end.
Join us for Season 2, Episode 1 of the wonderful 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!
Thank you...2020-02-121h 31
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 1 Episode 13—DecisionsIt is the season finale of Dawson's Creek! Dawson and Joey are talking around all of their issues, Pacey's family seems fucking awful, and Jen's grandpa is out of his coma...or is he?
Erin and Julia break down the season finale of season 1 and decide who they're rooting for at the end, what they're looking forward to in season two, and whether Julia can get through the recording without dying of a cold.
Join us for Season 1, Episode 13, of the classic 90s teen drama, Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so much to Killya for our amazing theme song. Find them...2020-02-051h 24
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 1 Episode 10—Double DateReeling from his breakup with Jen, Dawson is super self-pitying and annoying, and decides that the way to fix this is to go on a double date with Jen and Cliff.
Meanwhile, Pacey and Joey get paired on a school assignment and it turns out maybe they are kind of entertained by each other a little bit.
Julia and Erin discuss and break down the best Ferris Wheels in California in this new episode of Dawson's Critique!
Join us for episode ten of the 90s teen drama, Dawson's Creek.
Thank you so much to Killya for our amazing theme song...2020-01-151h 10
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 1, Episode 9—Road TripJoin Erin and Julia as they break down season 1, episode 9 of Dawson's Creek! Inexplicably Billy is still in town, haranguing Jen and leading Dawson and Pacey to a bar in Providence, which may be close or far from Cape Cod—we have no idea.
Meanwhile, 90s-00s teen drama staple actor Eric Balfour plays Warren, a letterman-jacket-wearing dude, spreads a rumor that he and Joey had sex. Jen and Joey bond over using Abby Morgan to get back at Warren and Julia wishes these two queens would run away and take over the world together.
Join us for episode nine of...2020-01-081h 17
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 1, Episode 8—BoyfriendA mysterious leather-jacketed dude shows up in Capeside and lo and behold, he's Jen's ex-boyfriend. Meanwhile, Pacey convinces Joey to come to a beach party with him and she proceeds to get wasted. Erin and Julia break down Episode 8 of Dawson's Creek and gush over possibly the best use of a Blink-182 song in a television show.
Join us for Season 1, Episode 8, of the classic 90s teen drama, Dawson's Creek!
Thank you so much to Killya for our amazing theme song. Find them on Instagram @gofreakingcrazy
Thank you to @camadeclub for our social media awesomeness.
Thank you also to Andrew...2020-01-011h 23
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 1 Episode 4—DiscoveryHappy Thanksgiving, Creekers!
Join Erin and Julia as they discuss episode 4 of Dawson's Creek—Discovery! Dawson finds out about his mom's affair. Jen tries to move her emotional relationship with Dawson forward, offering him a shoulder, but he rejects her and then slut-shames her when he finds out some information about her past. Ugh. Dawson.
Dawson decides he maybe doesn't want to be friends with Joey when he figures out that she knew about his mom. Ugh. Dawson.
And then Pacey and Miss Jacobs continue their illegal and traumatic relationship and will it ever end. *Spoiler: Yes*
Join us for Se...2019-11-271h 37
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 1, Episode 3—KissIn episode 3, Erin and Julia dissect the first loss of virginity on Dawson's Creek, whether rich people always play violins on boats, and maybe we see an inkling that Joey and Jen could be friends at some point. Fingers crossed.
Also, there's a lot of yelling about the inappropriateness of Miss Jacobs's relationship with Pacey. Ugh.
Join us for episode three of the 90s teen drama, Dawson's Creek.
Thank you so much to Killya for our amazing theme song. Find them on Instagram @gofreakingcrazy
Thank you also to Andrew Bush, who makes our voices sound warm and inviting, and gives...2019-11-201h 33
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 1, Episode 2—DanceIn episode two of Dawson's Critique, Julia and Erin discuss the episode Dance, which takes us further inside Capeside, MA, and the lives of Joey, Dawson, Jen, and Pacey.
Dawson is afraid to ask Jen out and gets mad, like the pouty child he is, that Jen goes to the dance with Scott Foley. While Pacey and Miss Jacobs continue to hover around their wildly inappropriate relationship. And Joey quietly pines for Dawson and is super mean to Jen.
This episode has it all. Pouty teens, high school dances that end in heartbreak, and kissing a teacher on the public...2019-11-131h 12
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Season 1, Episode 1—The PilotIt's the pilot of Dawson's Creek! Erin and Julia talk about Dawson and Joey and their burgeoning sexuality and all the problems that comes with it. We meet Jen, fresh out of the cab from NY, and Pacey, whose wildly inappropriate relationship we're going to freak out about for a while.
Join us for episode one of the 90s teen drama, Dawson's Creek.
Thank you so much to Killya for our amazing theme song. Find them on Instagram @gofreakingcrazy
Thank you also to Andrew Bush, who makes our voices sound warm and inviting, and gives us the scoop about growing...2019-11-061h 47
Dawson's Critique: A Dawson's Creek PodcastDawson's Critique Introduction to the Hosts and the Podcast!Welcome to Dawson's Critique, a podcast covering the hit 90s tv show, episode by episode.
This is a short introduction episode to the hosts, Erin Hensley and Julia Callahan, whose friendship started 18 years ago over an episode of Dawson's Creek.
We'll post new episodes every Wednesday, just like when Dawson's Creek was airing on The WB!
Thank you to Killya for our amazing theme song, and Andrew Bush at Cozycroft Studios for making our voices sound great.2019-10-2905 min
Creek of the Week: Dawson Schitt'sEpisode 69 – Creek of the Week: A Dawson’s Creek podcast presents: Dumb Americans: A Young Americans Miniseries Podcast EventThis is the beginning of a beautiful 8 episode relationship.
Long ago when Dawson’s Creek was at the height of it’s popularity, the all-knowing WB decided to use it to jump start a new series in it’s summer line up. Will Krudsky was introduced as a childhood friend of Pacey and Dawson, who showed up for 3 episodes then left to make his own show. That show was called Young Americans, it ran for 8 episodes and was cancelled. Your intrepid hosts, having never had the pleasure of watching the doomed series, decided that it would be...2016-03-0457 min