Shows
Hallmark Mysteries & MorePie to Die For: Did Hannah Just Bake Her Best Yet?Send us a textIs Pie to Die For the best Hannah Swensen mystery we’ve seen in years? We dig into the flour-dusted details and cozy chaos in this brand new Hallmark Movies & Mysteries release starring Alison Sweeney and Victor Webster.Andrea and Eric are back at The Cookie Jar talking kitchen fight scenes, swoon-worthy kisses, surprising sleuths, and whether Hannah fainting was totally out of character. Plus, we give props to Dolores’ janitor disguise, shout out the costume designer, and wonder aloud if Hallmark is finally leaning into the chemistry we’ve all been w...2025-06-2529 min
Hallmark Mysteries & MoreMystery 101: Dead Talk: AI, Exes & Killer SecretsSend us a textAndrea and Eric are back to break down Mystery 101: Dead Talk, where tech paranoia meets murder in one of the most layered entries of the series. This episode dives deep into the AI-powered premise, the clever red herrings (or lack thereof), and that unexpected killer reveal. The duo debates the real-life creep factor of Travis’s surprise visit, the romantic slow burn between Amy and Travis, and pays tribute to the Hallmark mystery regulars who pop up again and again.Plus: Golden Girls murder fiction, Murder She Wrote trivia, and a fe...2025-06-1930 min
Hallmark Mysteries & MorePrivate Eyes: The Six – Love Triangles, Club Drama & Stride of PrideSend us a textIn this episode of Hallmark Mysteries and More, we’re diving into Episode 5 of Private Eyes, and things are heating up—both on the case and in Angie’s personal life. Andrea and Eric break down all the juicy details of “The Six”, from teen nightclubs and tech-savvy teens to the not-so-subtle sparks flying between Angie and Detective Derek Nolan.Andrea drops a hilarious throwback to her “Dr. Draina” mixtape era (yes, it happened), and Eric tries to keep the mystery on track while fanning the flames of a potential love...2025-06-1716 min
Hallmark Mysteries & MoreMystery 101: Words Can Kill – Triple Murders, Red Herrings & Clue-Inspired Easter Eggs!Send us a textIn this episode of Hallmark Mysteries and More, we dive into the third movie in the Mystery 101 series — Words Can Kill. Andrea and Eric are back with wildly different opinions as they break down the tangled web of three murders, a chaotic campus setting, and a whole lot of suspectsAndrea’s not sold on the college backdrop or Jill Wagner’s performance, while Eric defends the plot twists and revels in the Agatha Christie shoutouts. They explore character dynamics, romantic tension (or lack thereof), and some hilarious continuity errors — including a magica...2025-06-1224 min
Hallmark Mysteries & MorePrivate Eyes: “The Devil’s Playground” – Our Favorite Case Yet?Send us a textGet ready to sleuth through secrets, lies, and… reality TV scandal? In this week’s episode of Hallmark Mysteries and More, Andrea and Eric break down episode 4 of Private Eyes Season 1: “The Devil’s Playground.” It’s a fun, fast-paced mystery set against the surprising backdrop of the Toronto Islands (yes, they’re real!).We dive into why this might be the best Private Eyes episode so far—complete with character-driven storytelling, smart red herrings, emotional depth, and a delightfully unexpected twist involving two very familiar HGTV-style “hosts.”Along the way, we...2025-06-1018 min
Hallmark Mysteries & MoreHallmark Channel's May for Moms Complete ReviewSend us a textAndrea and Eric are back—armed with hot takes, cool sarcasm, and more head-scratching than heartwarming—as they dive into Hallmark’s “May for Moms” movie lineup. Spoiler alert: it’s not exactly a love letter to motherhood… or good storytelling.From balloon-based romances to castles with utility bills the size of small countries, they rate and roast all five flicks. Along the way, they dish on everything from Diagnosis: Murder finally hitting Hallmark+ to the ageism-fueled drama surrounding Love in the Clouds. Plus: how Poker Face got it right, why Kissing Stars...2025-06-0634 min
Hallmark Mysteries & MorePrivate Eyes S1E3 – The Money Shot: Horses, Heartbreak, and Hard TruthsSend us a textIn this episode, Andrea and Eric take the reins as they gallop through Season 1, Episode 3 of Private Eyes, titled The Money Shot. While the case revolves around a mysterious racehorse and shady dealings at the track, the hosts are more intrigued by the emotional undercurrents galloping just beneath the surface.Andrea admits she’s not wild about horse-racing plots but praises the emotional arc involving Angie’s estranged mother—and the devastating moment when Angie gets stood up. Eric highlights how the show skillfully weaves character development into the mystery, especially Matt’s...2025-06-0213 min
Hallmark Mysteries & MoreOur Review of Mystery 101: Playing Dead - Stage Frights & Sleuthing DelightsSend us a textThe curtain is up, the body count is rising, and Amy and Travis are back in action! In this episode, Andrea and Eric review the second installment in Hallmark’s fan-favorite series Mystery 101 — Playing Dead. Set against the backdrop of a local theater production, this whodunnit brings drama on and off the stage.Andrea dives into the evolving relationship between Amy and Travis, while Eric weighs in on the pacing and whether the mystery gave him enough clues to work with. From shady stagehands to diva drama, they unpack it a...2025-05-2929 min
Hallmark Mysteries & More(Updated) Our Review of Private Eyes: Mise En Place - Restaurant Rivalries & Right HooksSend us a textThis week, Andrea and Eric return to Toronto for a full review of Private Eyes Season 1, Episode 2 – “Mise En Place” – where murder is on the menu and the restaurant world gets a spicy spotlight.The duo breaks down the episode’s culinary crime, character growth, and just the right amount of banter between Matt Shade and Angie Everett. From the sharp dialogue to standout punches (literally), this episode serves up strong character development—even if the mystery feels a bit by-the-book.🎧 In this episode:Why Angie’s bac...2025-05-2817 min
Hallmark Mysteries & MoreMystery 101 Pilot Review – Does the Most Beloved Hallmark Mystery Still Hold Up?Send us a textIt’s the episode everyone has been waiting for—Eric and Andrea finally take on the pilot of Hallmark’s most beloved mystery series, Mystery 101. Fans are fiercely loyal, emotions run high, and expectations are sky-high… so does the very first installment still earn its reputation as the gold standard of Hallmark whodunnits?In this fun and brutally honest review, the hosts dissect everything from the debut of Travis and Amy’s slow-burn chemistry to the pacing, acting, and that infamous dark-toned cinematography. One of them gives it a two…...2025-05-2228 min
Hallmark Mysteries & MoreWe reviewed Season 1, Episode 1 of Private Eyes—and we’re officially hooked.Send us a textIn this episode, Andrea and Eric lace up their skates and hit the ice as they review the first episode of Private Eyes, the Canadian mystery drama now gaining traction with Hallmark fans. Starring Jason Priestley and Cindy Sampson, the show kicks off with a compelling mix of hockey, heart, and a suspicious medical collapse that sparks the unexpected PI duo into action.With strong leads, intriguing backstories, and just enough mystery to keep things moving, Private Eyes proves to be a fun and fast-paced...2025-05-2014 min
Hallmark Mysteries & MoreGarden Gloves & Grave Secrets: Our Deep Dive Into Rosemary & Thyme Season 1!Send us a textWould YOU hire a pair of gardeners who seem to uncover a dead body at every job site? In this delightfully unhinged and wildly entertaining episode, Andrea and Eric dig into the British cozy classic Rosemary & Thyme, now streaming on Hallmark Movies Now and BritBox.From poisoned plants and slow-motion elevators to awkward romances and a scene-stealing dog, they break down all six Season 1 episodes—with strong opinions, hilarious sidebars, and a lot of love for the English countryside.Whether you’re new to the series or a lo...2025-05-1546 min
Hallmark Mysteries & MorePostmarked for the Moon: Reviewing Signed, Sealed, DeliveredSend us a textThis week on Hallmark Mysteries and More, we’re zooming in on the Signed, Sealed, Delivered franchise with an in-depth review of To the Moon and Back. Is it a heartwarming hit or a confusing miss? Eric and Andrea break it down, sharing their thoughts on the movie’s gripping mystery, the emotional dynamics of the Postables, and Oliver’s journey into fatherhood. We even dive into the letter mystery at the heart of the plot—does it deliver the usual SS&D magic, or does it leave us scratching our heads?Along...2025-05-0837 min
Hallmark Mysteries & MoreMy Hallmark Takeover: 5 Big Changes I’d Make If I Ran the NetworkSend us a textIn this special solo episode, Eric takes the reins—and the keys to the Hallmark Media kingdom—with five bold (and slightly fanatical) ideas that could revolutionize the network we all love. From network consolidation and smarter streaming to elevated mysteries and influencer-powered marketing, this episode is a passionate, funny, and surprisingly strategic vision for Hallmark’s future.Whether you’re a diehard Sleuther, a Countdown to Christmas devotee, or someone frustrated with glitchy apps and half-promoted premieres, this episode is your cozy call to arms. Plus, stick around for the...2025-05-0225 min
Hallmark Mysteries & MoreSecret Societies, Plot Holes & A Surprisingly Cute Kiss – Reviewing Emma Fielding: More Bitter Than DeathSend us a textThis week, Andrea and Eric complete their journey through the Emma Fielding Mysteries series with More Bitter Than Death—and it’s a wild ride! From secret societies under Keyser College to surprisingly entertaining (and unintentionally hilarious) fight scenes, they break down everything that worked—and everything that had them scratching their heads.They talk about Courtney Thorne-Smith’s much-improved performance, the evolving romance between Emma and Jim, and why this movie might just feature one of Hallmark’s cutest kisses. Plus, they discuss plot holes involving undergroun...2025-04-2932 min
Hallmark Mysteries & MoreSpring Into… Red Flags? Our Take on Hallmark’s Latest Love Stories 🌸Send us a textIn this episode, Andrea and Eric tackle Hallmark’s Spring Into Love lineup—and let’s just say, it’s a bumpy ride through romance, red flags, and questionable plots. From Jenna’s First Love to Kiki’s Fourth Ingredient, they break down all four interconnected movies (plus Journey to You) with their signature humor and honest takes.Expect passionate debates over unrealistic love declarations, a few favorite performances (yes, Steve Lund gets a shoutout), and plenty of eye-rolls at the rushed “I love yous.” Did any of these...2025-04-2542 min
Hallmark Mysteries & MoreEmma Fielding: Past Malice – Castles, Curses & Killer TwistsSend us a textThis week, Andrea and Eric return to Hartley Castle for their review of Emma Fielding Mysteries: Past Malice, and this time—it’s personal (and possibly cursed). From improved character chemistry to surprise villain reveals, they break down why this second film in the Emma Fielding series is a big step up from the first.They discuss Courtney Thorne-Smith’s stronger performance, the castle setting that won Andrea’s heart, and the unexpected killer reveal that had them both rethinking what they thought they knew about Kimberly...2025-04-2333 min
Hallmark Mysteries & MoreApril Telek on Kindness, Chaos & Killer Roles (Literally!)Send us a textShe’s been a red herring, an accomplice, a therapist, and even a murderess—but no matter the role, April Telek brings heart, humor, and unforgettable energy. In this episode, Andrea and Eric sit down with the beloved Hallmark star for a wide-ranging, wildly entertaining conversation that covers everything from Garage Sale Mysteries and Cut, Color, Murder to her early days in Deadlock: Escape from Zone 14 (yes, really).April shares her journey through 150+ screen credits with refreshing honesty, deep gratitude, and a whole lot of laughter. She talks about bein...2025-04-171h 07
Hallmark Mysteries & MoreDigging Into “Site Unseen” – Emma Fielding Mystery ReviewSend us a textIn this week’s episode, Andrea and Eric take a deep dive into Emma Fielding Mysteries: Site Unseen, the archaeology-themed Hallmark mystery that kicked off Courtney Thorne-Smith’s return to television in a leading role.They dig into everything—from questionable historical facts and subdued romance to that surprisingly action-packed ending. Was it a diamond in the rough, or just dirt in your DVR? Let’s just say that opinions were unearthed.🔎 What’s inside:🧭 A full breakdown of the film’s plot, character dynamics...2025-04-1541 min
Hallmark Mysteries & MoreAurora Teagarden – Reap What You Sew Review (and Maybe Snooze?)Send us a textIn this episode, Andrea and Eric dive into Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: Reap What You Sew—but does this cozy caper stitch together a satisfying story or unravel before the final scene? Spoiler alert: one of your hosts may have literally slept through the climax (twice).They discuss the absence of key characters like Martin and Lynn, how the film struggles to find emotional depth, and whether Candace Cameron Bure carried the lead well. The real MVP? Sally, played by Lexa Doig, whose sharp wit and expressive nonverbal cues stole every scene....2025-04-0838 min
Hallmark Mysteries & MoreKaitlyn Leeb Talks The Spencer Sisters, Heartland & Life On and Off ScreenSend us a texthis week, Andrea and Eric are joined by the incredibly talented Kaitlyn Leeb, known to Hallmark fans as Lindsay from The Spencer Sisters and Bianca in Crossword Mysteries. Kaitlyn opens up about her acting journey—from competitive figure skater to Hallmark star—and shares heartfelt stories about her early auditions, behind-the-scenes friendships, and balancing motherhood with a demanding acting career.They dive into her time on Heartland, her favorite Hallmark roles, and of course, what made The Spencer Sisters so special. Kaitlyn also reflects on the emotional challenges of the...2025-04-0344 min
Hallmark Mysteries & MoreBritish Mysteries, Good Witch Magic & A Holiday Football Fumble?Send us a textThis week, Andrea and Eric dive into the latest Hallmark news and bring plenty of laughs along the way! From the network’s big announcement about adding British mystery imports (hello, Rosemary & Thyme and Shakespeare & Hathaway!) to Good Witch: The Grey Lady Secrets getting the full nostalgic rewatch treatment, this episode is packed with cozy, quirky, and occasionally controversial takes.They break down what makes Good Witch so special—including Cassie’s magical intuition, that 1 a.m. party, and Abigail juggling three dates like a pro—and give plenty of flowe...2025-03-3145 min
Hallmark Mysteries & MoreShould You Watch A Fixer Upper Mystery – A Deadly Deed. We Watched It to Let You Know if You ShoulSend us a textIn this episode, Andrea and Eric take on the final installment of Hallmark Mystery Channel’s Fixer Upper Mystery trilogy: A Deadly Deed. Is it a satisfying finale or a crumbling renovation? The co-hosts dig into everything from plot pacing and character development to mismatched outfits and confusing casting choices.Andrea finds the mystery slow and uninspired, with too few red herrings and not enough screen time for the supporting cast—while Eric defends the cozy charm and nostalgic Hallmark vibes. Together, they debate whether Jewel’s performance improved over t...2025-03-2431 min
Hallmark Mysteries & MoreCrowns, Castles, and Chemistry: A Hallmark Royal RecapSend us a textGrab a cup of tea and settle in—this week, we’re diving into Hallmark’s latest royal rom-com lineup! From a Bostonian princess forced into an arranged marriage to a Philadelphia mechanic discovering his inner Duke, we’re ranking, reviewing, and royally roasting all the tiara-worthy momentsWhich leading lady stole the show? Did the fairy-tale romances actually deliver? And why did one merry-go-round scene have us more nervous than enchanted? Join Eric and Andrea as they break down the charm, the clichés, and the undeniable star power of Mallory J...2025-03-1929 min
Hallmark Mysteries & MoreMurder, Mayhem, and Mystery Island: Breaking Down Hallmark’s Latest Whodunit.Send us a textCalling all Hallmark mystery fans! This week, we’re diving deep into Mystery Island: Winner Takes All, where a game of make-believe murder turns into the real deal. Was the latest installment a thrilling Agatha Christie-inspired closed-room mystery or just another predictable whodunit?Join hosts Eric and Andrea as they debate the film’s highs and lows, from the standout performance of Kristen Booth to the surprising reveal that left some fans underwhelmed. Plus, we dish on Hallmark’s latest mystery series in development—could Campers and Criminals be the next big hit...2025-03-1730 min
Hallmark Mysteries & MorePeter Benson Talks Acting, Directing & Hallmark MysteriesSend us a textThis week, Andrea and Eric sit down with the one and only Peter Benson, a Hallmark favorite known for his work in both front of and behind the camera. From his extensive acting career—including Aurora Teagarden, Mystery 101, and The Chronicle Mysteries—to his growing success as a director, Peter shares behind-the-scenes stories, career highlights, and hilarious audition mishaps.They discuss his love for mystery films, his early years in the industry, and how he’s navigated the ever-changing Hallmark landscape. Plus, could Peter return to Aurora Teagar...2025-03-1451 min
Hallmark Mysteries & MoreDiscussing A Fixer Upper Mystery: Concrete Evidence and Eric's Hallmark Conspiracy TheorySend us a textIs Hallmark about to shake up its network? Andrea and Eric dive into Conspiracy Corner to discuss the potential consolidation of Hallmark’s channels and what it could mean for mystery lovers. They also break down the second installment of Fixer Upper Mysteries, debating the eerie vibes, high school nostalgia, and unexpected twists that had them questioning everything—including how long a house can sit untouched with hidden journals and rocking horses.Plus, what’s next for Hallmark’s mystery lineup? They discuss upcoming releases, missing sequels, and whether Aurora Teagarden, Curious...2025-03-1229 min
Hallmark Mysteries & MoreSeason Finale Deep Dive – The Way Home & The Spencer SistersSend us a textIt’s time for a dramatic season finale discussion! In this episode, Andrea and Eric take their final dip into the pond—at least for now—as they break down the emotional and twist-filled ending of The Way Home Season 3. From time-traveling mysteries and unexpected revelations to standout performances by Jefferson Brown and Sadie Laflamme-Snow, they cover it all.Plus, they discuss The Spencer Sisters finale, the fate of Victoria and Darby, and whether Hallmark will give fans the second season they’re hoping for. What worked? What didn’t? And what do th...2025-03-1041 min
Hallmark Mysteries & MoreReviewing Garage Sale Mysteries: The Novel MurdersSend us a textWhat do you get when you mix Agatha Christie with Sherlock Holmes, toss in a dash of Jennifer Shannon, and top it off with a Hallmark mystery?Well, Garage Sale Mysteries: The Novel Murders, of course. The mystery series has been Andrea's favorite while Eric has been lukewarm. But with this 6 installment of the mystery series starring Lori Laughlin, Steve Bacic, Sarah Strange, and Eva Bourne, we both agreed it was a 5 out of 5 mystery. Synopsis:Jennifer Shannon (Lori Loughlin) is a garage sale shopping expert whose s...2025-02-1929 min
Hallmark Mysteries & MoreEpisode 6's of The Way Home Vs The Spencer Sisters. We Loved One and Didn't the OtherSend us a textThis week we discussed the 6th epidodes of The Way Home, "Ain't No Sunshine" and The Spencer Sisters "The Winemakers Woe". While there were moments each of us enjoyed in The Way Home, this episode didn't do much to get us back into the episode, which is a disappointment since the last episode showed some promise. Kat continues to only care about Kat. We go back to the 1800s, which lost much of its appeal (if there was ever any appeal), and any sense of time travel rules seem to be out the...2025-02-1035 min
Hallmark Mysteries & MoreHalf Way There. Discussing Episode 5s of The Way Home and the Spencer SistersSend us a textIn our weekly dive into the pond, we discuss the 5th episode of The Way Home, Reeling in the Years. After a week of optimism after the 4th episode, this one took a huge step backward with conflicts that don't make sense, plots that are going who knows where, and back to time travel rule-breaking. We are left asking the question, does anyone like Kat?Then we discussed The Spencer Sisters, which we thought we would agree. But we didn't. Andrea gets triggered over the mother/daughter bickering, which i...2025-02-0340 min
Hallmark Mysteries & MoreDiscussing the Final Gourmet Detective: Roux the DaySend us a textThe time has come to conclude our breakdown of the Gourmet Detective series as we discuss Roux the Day. Henry and Maggie are firmly cemented in their relationship in this movie as they return to the show's roots with an epicurean mystery. We also get more of Henry's dad, as their restaurant is key to solving the mystery. And since this was the final episode, we each ranked all five mysteries from our "least" favorite to our favorite. Lastly, Andrea played a fun, elaborate, sleuther game called Uns...2025-01-3033 min